Reviews
via Podcasts
Yay!
Update on 22oct26: YES I LOVE THE CHRIS EPISODE HES A HERO!!
Love how involved Chris is!! He’s reacting for all of us. His laugh is contagious and so pure 🥹
itsvickyt33
Love the podcast but I wish they’d remember it’s a podcast!
I am a huge fan and listen to almost every episode! I often skip the ones where they are naming people/characters that can do xyz. They’re clearly looking at a screen but they don’t tell the audience who they’re talking about. They just give their answers. Sort of no point in listening to it. I love the normal episodes though!
Flowerpower171819
Greatest Singer Episode
🎶Almost agreed with Nick 💯 … but I’m going to put on Maria Callas now ♥️
T Drinker
Nick, you’re gay 🏳️🌈
nick needs to accept that he’s really, really gay bc i CANNOT handle more of these absurd role plays
anyway, love the pod.
supercutofus
The Guncles our son never had
My husband and I listen to this podcast when we are winding down for the night. It’s causal, amusing and very funny. Thank you for extending your episodes longer, you make it easier to endure long nights with our 3 month old.
BF GA
I love these guys!
This podcast brightens my day so much. Matteo and Nick, thank you for being you. Yay, gays!!
Joeandangie123
Amazing duo
You two keep me looking like a weirdo laughing to myself with my headphones in. So glad I found the pod! Always loved Mateo and Nick is a new favorite. Thanks for being who you are ❤️
Allison Holtzclaw
When you’re on the Odessey and it’s a-rockin, don’t come a-knockin
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
kennaedw
Loving this shows evolution!
Ive been listening since day 1 and I absolutely love where the show is at today! I know some people don't like guests on pods but these guys consistently pick the funniest people to have on that always compliment the show perfectly! Also the fact that Chris is more included is awesome, it's giving Stern show vibes which if you know, is a HUGE compliment. My only gripe is with Matteo constantly repeating the same bits, snarky remarks about Nicks clothes, same voices/accents, constantly showing off and bragging that he can speak other languages 🙄🤦🏼♀️it's just getting a bit old and feels a little "try hard". Just be yourself my dude, you are funnier and more enjoyable when you are nicer 😊🫶🏼 love you guys!!! 💕
Read more
Reviewconoe
I love love LOVE this pod
I love them both dearly. Like sons. Like fathers. Daddy’s? Anyway! Such a bright spot in my week. Praying they don’t go the way of Las Cultch and have guests every episode tho. Please for all of our sakeeeee
Rach924
Improv episode
I’ve never laughed out loud at a podcast before, still haven’t.
JUST KIDDING, literally crying laughing.
jackeyjohn
I never loved a podcast more
This podcast and Mess are my two favorites.
nmrb
Hilarious
They are hilarious. The best parts are Nick saying something insane and Matteo going ‘Huh?! Back up….’ And Chris losing his mind cackling in the background.
Memyselfandi28
Movie Franchise Episode
If you listen to this episode and you don’t love LAUGH out loud while Nick explains the plot of Star Wars with the Miami Falcon and Matteo explaining Hunger Games - there is something wrong. Go see someone. Your Long time fan!
ANoa Design
Come visit Lake Erie Nick
Just started listening and I just finished ep 30 about vacations. I was snorting with laughter over the Indiana Dunes beach, landlocked state confusion hahahaha. Nick come to Erie and we’ll hang on the beach of Lake Erie and search for beach glass!
LC6ally
I always liked you!
I’ve been a fan from the, was able to see you both live in Pittsburgh. This podcast is in my top three favorite podcasts .I’m always laughing at the banter between these two and I’m enjoying them bringing on more guests now!
NeikoBroz
Obsessed
Found this podcast a few weeks ago and binged every available episode. Now that I’ve gone through all available episodes I miss them. Might have to relisten. Thank you Nick and Matteo!
Hammi1!
Laugh Out Loud Funny
Listening to this is like having drinks after work with your funniest friends. Love it.
cahoola
Good program
My grandchildren recommended this show to me. I learn a lot from this show.
earthysmell
Crying at work
I simply can’t explain to my coworkers why I’m crying laughing at my desk. 1000/5 stars.
Comfort music
Laughs galore
Matteo and Nick always make me laugh out loud. I love their friendship and banter and they always have interesting guests. The Bob the Drag Queen episodes me in tears.
frpk2010
Thanks!
As a straight guy, it’s been really cool listening to you guys be so open and honest about things you’ve discovered, experienced, and endured. Gives me a better appreciation and understand of my gay friends who aren’t as comfortable sharing some of those things. And it doesn’t hurt that the two of you are hilarious. Thanks for helping me be a better friend to my my friends.
AfibVfib
These are my gays
I love them I get it and I’m here for it
aashgasm
My favorite Frog and Toad
I’m really enjoying this Frog and Toad reboot!
JuliaPancakes
Bob is so toxic.
Bobs argumentative nature is so scarily unfunny. Get him some therapy along with Nick!
Tamikandy
Reviews!
“Welcome back to another episode of I Never Liked You where we talk about the titular subject for approximately 2 minutes and 17 seconds before going off on multiple tangents for the rest of the episode.”
No notes. 5 stars.
Mjc3000
would recommend
definitely a must
9668ynot
LOVE!
New favorite podcast ✌️
Ell Bee 33
Huh
Enjoyed it but these boys are… not smart. They talk about Opening Ceremonies that Matteo didn’t even watch and Nick thinks that the hand gesture segment was improv even though there was on-screen explanations?! Matteo thinking Mariah did a good job even though she looked like a beautiful mannequin barely even trying to lip sync? Mess.
AttilaTheFun
Weekly Tea ☕️ update
Oh Hell yasssssss! Slay 😆🤣😆I can hardly type, dying, dead ☠️ 😆🤣😆☠️
sustainabletia
Love! 🥰
Nick & Matteo - you’re so funny! I love your connection, friendship, and humor. Like Nick, I’ve learned a lot of history that I never really cared about but love learning new things! You guys crack my up and brighten my day! 😊 Please keep doing what you’re doing because it’s working. 💕
cdoern
Absolutely Fabulous
Love this show - love these guys…..bring back Nick’s beach hat and more movie reviews(well, reviews of Nick’s “viewing experience”).
Alock115
I don’t get their dynamic
I just don’t
GayBrenda
I am Learning with Nick
Nick really shouldn’t feel bad because I am as surprised as he is when learning common knowledge. Or we’re both pretty daft and should both feel bad. Either way, I too was second-handedly shamed by Lizzo.
P.S., my bestie and I started playing Fortnite because of you both and now we play it every night. We always freak out and yell that it’s Nick when we see a secretary skin in heels.
Love the podcast!
Read more
123luckydog123
Psychological twist
I first found out about Matteo while listening to Fortune Feemster’s original solo podcast. I followed him ever since and have purchased two of his signed Pasta books. In the beginning, Nick annoyed me so bad. But two years later, I realized Nick is the best and think Matteo needs to go sit in a corner because he bullies Nick. I will defend Nick with my life.
jen98a
Now come on now!
I wish these episodes were longer. Too funny. More mean comments please! I listened to the mean comments episodes and died laughing on a plane!
betseyville0820
Nick!!!
I think it’s crazy all the hate that Nick gets! He is amazing! So authentically himself! The show would never work without him!
***jenn***
I WILL NEVER STOP LAUGHING
Absolutely hysterical. All I can say is I heard Matteo’s impression of Nick BEFORE I heard the podcast. 🤣🤣🤣
Capesterintx
Cringe
Matteo is so insecure and cringey.
Matteo’sOverinflatedEgo
MORE!! Longer episodes please!!
I have never loved a podcast so much. Matteo and Nick complement each other so well. Their laughs are infectious and Nicks sass is unmatched. Their dynamic has me listening to episodes on repeat. The newest with Neil DT was insane and I need more and longer episodes asap!
JTill27
I never knew how much I needed this podcast!
In a world where so much can be serious and discouraging, Matteo and Nick bring the fun! These two have a rhetoric that is unmatched in hilarity. Every episode has me laughing out loud. It really is a highlight in my week to listen to these two bicker at each other and provide color commentary on all the things. The Neil Degrasse Tyson episode was INCREDIBLE! Thank you for giving us such a humorous and lighthearted space to just enjoy hanging out.
Read more
RunninJess
Neil deGrasse Tyson
I absolutely love this podcast, but the Neil deGrasse Tyson episode was top tier. Can we please get an All About Chris episode??
DorothyCN
Halloween episode hysterical!
I laughed so hard all by myself that I couldn’t breathe! Thank you for being a light in my day
Tracy Spiess
Love this pod
I love the dynamic between these two. I started watching clips on TikTok but now I listen to the full show every release.
Jordan Pants
Love Matteo- Nick is like pepper
Matteo- love. Been a fan of his for years. I get that he finds Nick funny (IRL)- but he’s like pepper. A SMALL dash might make a dish flavorful, but you don’t want it as a main ingredient. Too much- it ruins the dish….
Lorenz12
The angel and devil on my shoulder
Hilarious banter with so many opinions I find myself agreeing and disagreeing with as if I am in the room with you. Thanks for the laughs!!
Ridiculousbread
Hilarious half hour to inject into your day
Genuinely a delight. You never know where these conversations will go, even with the prompts. Matteo and Nick play off each other perfectly and their banter is unmatched. They know exactly how to get the most random, absurd and hilarious ideas to come out of each other’s mouths. I thought episode 89 was a perfect encapsulation of what the show is, so if you’re new here, start there to get a taste!
Also, just for the record, I agree with Nick that Chris the producer always takes Matteo’s side. Justice for Nick! lol
Read more
natatouille dux
LOVE!
A delightful, funny break from a world that continues to be hot street trash.
Vinnie Morrison
I laugh, I argue, I think
I love this podcast. It truly cracks me up. I find myself talking with yall like you can hear me. It's so authentic and real and funny!
Thehaylanater92
So funny
Every episode is hilarious and so clever. Their chemistry is genuine and so funny.
Drivindownthehighway
