Five's A Crowd Podcast
Five's A Crowd Podcast
Five's A Crowd
Was Halloween Actually Better in the '90s?
1 hour 29 minutes Posted Oct 19, 2026 at 10:00 am.
Start!01:19 - Childhood Halloween and homemade costumes10:52 - Plastic masks and school Halloween12:16 - The daylight saving time detour22:04 - Trunk or treat vs. door-to-door27:50 - Candy hauls and neighborhood pranks37:01 - Halloween TV we grew up watching47:05 - Old-school decorations and Halloween cartoons51:58 - Candy buckets, pillowcases, and candy checks56:03 - Sweet treats and fall food debates01:07:44 - Mischief night and unusual Halloween treats01:14:02 - The traditions we'd bring back01:18:17 - Two-sentence horror stories01:25:48 - Vampires or werewolves?01:27:46 - Wrapping up Halloween nightReddit- Our Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FivesACrowd- Our Account: https://www.reddit.com/user/FivesACrowdPodcastFollow Our Personal AccountsAustin - https://allmylinks.com/austinspomerCam - https://www.instagram.com/effinburch/Chris - https://www.instagram.com/thechrishummel/Tony - https://www.instagram.com/theonlytonyc/Zach - https://www.instagram.com/zvanbeekum/P.O. Box**Please no packages, letters only**Five's A Crowd Podcast1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041
0:00
1:29:00
Download MP3
Show notes
Was Halloween actually better in the '90s—or do we just miss being kids? We're revisiting homemade costumes, pillowcases full of candy, classic Halloween specials, and the neighborhood traditions we'd bring back. Plus, we debate trunk or treat, where pranks cross the line, and finish with two-sentence horror stories that get darker than expected.Tell us which Halloween tradition deserves a comeback—and thank you for being part of this crowd!#Halloween #90sNostalgia #FivesACrowd #HalloweenNostalgia #TwoSentenceHorror00:00 - Start!01:19 - Childhood Halloween and homemade costumes10:52 - Plastic masks and school Halloween12:16 - The daylight saving time detour22:04 - Trunk or treat vs. door-to-door27:50 - Candy hauls and neighborhood pranks37:01 - Halloween TV we grew up watching47:05 - Old-school decorations and Halloween cartoons51:58 - Candy buckets, pillowcases, and candy checks56:03 - Sweet treats and fall food debates01:07:44 - Mischief night and unusual Halloween treats01:14:02 - The traditions we'd bring back01:18:17 - Two-sentence horror stories01:25:48 - Vampires or werewolves?01:27:46 - Wrapping up Halloween nightReddit- Our Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FivesACrowd- Our Account: https://www.reddit.com/user/FivesACrowdPodcastFollow Our Personal AccountsAustin - https://allmylinks.com/austinspomerCam - https://www.instagram.com/effinburch/Chris - https://www.instagram.com/thechrishummel/Tony - https://www.instagram.com/theonlytonyc/Zach - https://www.instagram.com/zvanbeekum/P.O. Box**Please no packages, letters only**Five's A Crowd Podcast1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041