Five's A Crowd Podcast
Five's A Crowd Podcast
Five's A Crowd
Scary Stories From The Depths of Reddit..
40 minutes Posted Oct 12, 2026 at 10:00 am.
Start!00:20 - The Scary Story Challenge Explained00:57 - Why We Love Scaring the Neighbors03:06 - Story 1: The Unplugged Baby Monitor07:32 - Story 2: The Green Woman08:23 - The Bloody Mary Tangent10:46 - Story 3: The Water Meter Camera13:49 - Story 4: The Voice in the Woodshed16:21 - Story 5: The Apartment Above 4B20:15 - Story 6: Woman on the Highway22:04 - Story 7: The Last Passenger24:12 - Story 8: Closing the Tudor Hall25:41 - Story 9: The Missing Minute28:03 - Story 10: The Boy Who Knew29:50 - The Reveal: Which Stories Are Actually Real?34:21 - The Missing Minute Debate38:00 - Final Scores & OutroHashtags:#ScaryStories #RedditStories #TrueScaryStories #Paranormal #CreepyStories #LetsNotMeet #Storytime #Podcast #FivesACrowd #HalloweenBOO!👻 Which of these stories gave you the biggest chills??Reddit- Our Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FivesACrowd- Our Account: https://www.reddit.com/user/FivesACrowdPodcastFollow Our Personal AccountsAustin - https://allmylinks.com/austinspomerCam - https://www.instagram.com/effinburch/Chris - https://www.instagram.com/thechrishummel/Tony - https://www.instagram.com/theonlytonyc/Zach - https://www.instagram.com/zvanbeekum/Hashtags#JoinTheCrowd #HitTheBell #PodcastP.O. Box**Please no packages, letters only**Five's A Crowd Podcast1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041
0:00
40:42
Download MP3
Show notes
Welcome back to the table! Today, we are kicking off spooky season with a chilling challenge: reading 10 terrifying internet stories from the depths of Reddit and guessing which ones are actually true and which ones are completely made up... Timestamps:00:00 - Start!00:20 - The Scary Story Challenge Explained00:57 - Why We Love Scaring the Neighbors03:06 - Story 1: The Unplugged Baby Monitor07:32 - Story 2: The Green Woman08:23 - The Bloody Mary Tangent10:46 - Story 3: The Water Meter Camera13:49 - Story 4: The Voice in the Woodshed16:21 - Story 5: The Apartment Above 4B20:15 - Story 6: Woman on the Highway22:04 - Story 7: The Last Passenger24:12 - Story 8: Closing the Tudor Hall25:41 - Story 9: The Missing Minute28:03 - Story 10: The Boy Who Knew29:50 - The Reveal: Which Stories Are Actually Real?34:21 - The Missing Minute Debate38:00 - Final Scores & OutroHashtags:#ScaryStories #RedditStories #TrueScaryStories #Paranormal #CreepyStories #LetsNotMeet #Storytime #Podcast #FivesACrowd #HalloweenBOO!👻 Which of these stories gave you the biggest chills??Reddit- Our Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FivesACrowd- Our Account: https://www.reddit.com/user/FivesACrowdPodcastFollow Our Personal AccountsAustin - https://allmylinks.com/austinspomerCam - https://www.instagram.com/effinburch/Chris - https://www.instagram.com/thechrishummel/Tony - https://www.instagram.com/theonlytonyc/Zach - https://www.instagram.com/zvanbeekum/Hashtags#JoinTheCrowd #HitTheBell #PodcastP.O. Box**Please no packages, letters only**Five's A Crowd Podcast1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041