In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But… fellow WKNC DJ Sarah joins Cutter to tell her tales of wrecked first dates and pilgrimages to candle outlets, as well as offers her guess as to which of Cutter’s two stories are true.

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But… Cutter’s sort-of-uncle Daniel comes on to tell stories of singing in front of the President and hitting basketball legend Dean Smith with a door, as well as fret about his guess as to Cutter’s stories

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But… Cole Miller, runway model and friend of Cutter's, comes on to tell stories of almost being kidnapped and driving at a fire towards a friend’s grandma, as well as make his guess on Cutter’s two stories.

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But... Cutter’s younger sibling, Phoenix, comes in to discuss their experience with flirtatious fictional characters and a walk out created at their school, as well as decide between Cutter’s stories.

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But... Cutter’s friend since birth, Price comes on to tell stories of his time at Virginia Tech athletics, including basketball halftime scooter races and getting hit by a snowball from the new football coach.

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But... Cutter’s roommate and longtime NC State friend Maddie joins him to talk about her times sneaking out and running away, both on top of a shopping center and in the middle of the night in Wilmington.

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But... Natalie, friend of Gabby’s and friend of Cutter’s, tells stories about her return to her birthplace of Las Vegas and her high school orchestra’s fitful field trip to New Orleans.

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But... the star of one of season one’s stories, Gabby, kicks off season two with stories abroad in Jordan and in high school theater, as well as making her guess on stories she isn’t a part of this time around.

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But... host Cutter begins Season 2 of the show by telling his stories about mishaps working summer camps and conversation-given concussions that all future guests will have to pick between.

In this episode of You’ll Never Believe Me But... Cutter brings on a special guest for a bonus interview to get their side of one of the season one stories. While there aren’t any new stories, we get a good look at an old story from a new perspective.