What an amazing podcast!!!! Best ever! Love Joe Bear!

For being an official HBO podcast this show is missing any sort of intelligent conversation or commentary on the details of such an interesting and well written tv series. The hosts talk about the show with a remarkable lack of understanding of basic plot points and theorize in a way that makes it seem like they watched the show half paying attention while staring at their phones. I’m super disappointed as I was really looking forward to a podcast about this show that I’ve loved and sadly these hosts are just not good.

Thank you for the long and winding roads of possibilities! Great show and fun pod. The Dads are on point! And, could Evan’s mother’s letters have the clues , or answers, needed to resolve the island’s bad covenant? Ruth said “secret mother” and Evan’s mom wrote about two mothers, one secret … scorpion. Hmm.

Any podcast that mentions Boomtown deserves a Auto 5 star rating.

Love these guys, they do a great job speculating, bringing up details I constantly miss and sharing their joy about the shows they cover. Only note is a wish I was on the pod with them, despite not being Bill Simmons.

Super thoughtful and insightful hosts and an amazing supplement to further appreciate Widow’s Bay ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I’ve really enjoyed listening to their coverage of Widow’s Bay. It reminds me of listening to a bunch of dads sit around and discuss something, like where they have some ideas that might seem far fetched but it’s fun so you go along with it. Or like when they keep mispronouncing a word and even if it’s acknowledged, they just keep rolling with it LOL In fact it reminds me of my own dad. Keep up the good work!

Loving this show and this podcast!! Joebear is a great addition! And I’m not just saying that cause he’s my brother❤️!

A really fun podcast for a really fun show. You can tell the hosts really enjoy what they are doing.

Love these guys! I really appreciate the background in television that they bring to their episodes. Xoxo

I’m so hooked on this show and the boys from The DVR Podcasting Network are rockin it with their coverage! Super fun podcast to listen to with great insight! Keep the theories coming!

Let’s all go to Widow’s Bay, bayby!