Reviews
via Podcasts
The Fuselage
Back in the day we had a website called “the fuselage.com”. We theorized every season of LOST, in t was an amazing community and much better than Reddit.
Kevonski
Why Jon gave Angela his power?
And why did she accept the power? So they can still be together since now she’ll experience time as he did- so he’ll always be with her.
Also Peteypedia appears to verify Petey=Lubeman with the Canola oil line. And even last weeks fogdancing memo/summary had some heavy Lubeman origin implications .
alchalant
5 stars (at least)
For each plot point that they nonchalantly predicted due to their obvious love for this series. Thanks for making a casual watcher (with no comic or movie experience) become a fan.
LysListens
Host is arrogant and humor less.
I would have given this a better review but the host considers a legit 4 of 5 star review as being a Richard. If you’re going to ask for reviews, don’t be a Richard about it.
Champ1Up
Good not great
They try more than the other Watchmen podcasts I’ve given a shot. But with theories like “Maybe Lady Trieu is going to destroy America to save the world.” and other meandering talking points, you might as well stick to the subreddit while you wait on HBO’s official podcast, and move and along.
Own's Envy
My top favorite watchmen podcast!
They are really well at producing an extensive podcast about watchmen. Hopefully this show does get a season 2!
emdtys
Very Funny and Insightful
Grant and Clay always provide very funny commentary on the show and aren’t afraid to let their opinions to be known. Listening to their podcast as a companion to the HBO show has been a delight.
Theo122009
They get the podcast up fast.
It’s pretty good. Sometimes they pronounce a name wrong. But I’m not gonna knock off any stars for that like a weirdo
Guy_incognit0
So glad I found this podcast
Interesting insights, great guys. I’d love to hear them recap other shows, like Mr. Robot, Succession,etc
earth vs. soup
Review
Very cool show. Love the deep dive into such a great piece of art. One of the hosts seems a bit distracted. Constantly derailing the conversation with stories that rarely deliver a pay off for the time it distracted from the podcast. Still love the show but that’s why it’s not at 5 stars in my opinion.
WatcherV
A Fun Listen After the Show
I love listening to Clay and Grant right after a brand new episode of the show. Their dynamic and humor are a perfect fit, and their discussions always surprise me with new insights into this wonderfully complex show.
CharleneBlue
Great Discussion of the Original Comic
I haven’t watched the show yet so I can’t comment on that part of the pod, but I love the deep dive into each issue of the original comics. Also who doesn’t appreciate a good pun in a podcast name?
Will Cardini
It's Damon Lindel-on.
When discovering that there would be a series continuing to explore the world of Watchmen, I was elated. I’m an enormous fan of Alan Moore’s visionary take on superheroes, morality, politics, and the shades of gray between extrapolated extremes. When I came to learn that this expansion of Moore’s work would be spearheaded by the incomparable Damon Lindelof, it reminded me of the exact moment that one of my favorite shows, Lost, plunged itself into the bottom of the dustbin of my biggest disappointments in TV history. What had once been a compelling and undeniably fun narrative puzzle seemed to have taken a hammer to its own head, striking itself repeatedly with the flat end, and then again with the forky bit on the other side, and then again with the flat end until the handle broke and everything that was great about the show leaked all over its own face like so much wasted brains and snot. Lindelof then went on to spread his writing flaps all over the eagerly-anticipated Prometheus, where he had somehow written the dumbest space scientists ever into existence; the mildly anticipated Tomorrowland, where even Brad Bird couldn’t breathe life into his script; and Cowboys & Aliens, which nobody anticipated at all. If the art of writing was itself a story, then Damon Lindelof would be the twist ending where we find out that writing isn’t really even a thing, and instead we were all dead in that whole last part with the church that nobody liked or understood. So, yeah, he’s doing Watchmen on HBO.
This is a podcast about that show. I’ve heard one episode so far and I liked it. 5/5 stars.
Read more
John Rubio
Squid Pix!!!
This is the first one of your podcasts I’ve listened to! I LOVE it! I REALLY LOVE the squid picture when you’re getting off-topic!! Great job!!! 😁😁
BlackCatNoir
Great add on to the HBO Show
I really like this discussion about the episode. This is gonna be my first stop after each new episode. Big fan
@MrKyleScott
Awesome show!
What a great and informative show. I would highly recommend this to anyone even remotely interested in the watchmen universe!
weldon173
The best Watchmen podcast
I’ve listened to all the Watchmen podcasts currently analyzing the book in preparation for the upcoming HBO series (yes, all of them), and I can say this is the best of the bunch.
It’s a shame that Mike, Grant’s original cohost, couldn’t continue the podcast, but Clay is a great, unexpected addition (coming in at Issue 4). At first skeptical of his lack of Watchmen knowledge and seemingly aloof attitude, I quickly warmed to his dynamic energy, sense of humor, and fresh insights (on Watchmen, craft beer, or life in general).
Grant and Clay complement each other well and episodes never drag, even when they go on tangents that may or may not circle back to the original topic. We’re happy to go for the ride, because while other podcasts are often filled with tedious plot summaries or painfully repetitious exchanges, this one delivers the lifeblood of any good podcast: entertaining conversation.
Sadly I will be parting ways with this podcast soon as I will not be watching the HBO series, but if/when I do, this will definitely be the podcast I return to first.
Read more
francograph
Abraham R. AKA Swolesauce ;)
I absolutely love this podcast! This is a necessary listen to any fan of this timeless classic. I read Watchmen for the first time in college, about 10 years ago now, and every time I re-read it I find something new and relevant to todays politics etc. Listening to Grant and Clay offers even more in depth and interesting points of views and revelations that I hadn’t seen before. Y’all are awesome 💯
Read more
instagram Swolesauce
Very cool, very informative!
I’m not a comic book guy. Watchmen was literally the first comic book I’ve ever read and I only did that because I’m a big Damon Lindelof fan and wanted to check it out before I watch the upcoming HBO show. I’m now reading it through a second time and listening to these episodes as I do is. It’s been really fun and I’m now gonna go buy every other thing Alan Moore has ever created because I can’t believe I’ve been missing out on this stuff all my life!
EDIT: downgrading a star after listening to a couple of more episodes. Why didn’t the hosts read the entire graphic novel before recording? They’re constantly guessing or flat out wrong about details revealed in later chapters. I just read the thing for the first time a month ago, I shouldn’t be more knowledgeable about the details of the story than the hosts!
Read more
Thewire024
Nerding our at its BEST
Love the podcast so far, can’t wait to hear the analysis of the show. I’ve been reading the comics for the first time along with you guys issue by issue break down. Thank you for helping me to catch those tiny details my first time through.
pandaaaaaaaa
So Excited!
Can't wait to hear what Mike and Grant get into on this podcast. They are some of my favorite TV/Fan podcasters and I'm sure this one is going to be just as good.
MyrriahATX
Will tune in
Can’t wait to listen in! Love your other pods. Really looking forward to this one!
Jeanmoodfloyd
Great Dynamic and Format
What I want from podcasts that I listen to are hosts that are enthusiastic and engaged by the materials. These guys are great.
JamesWurm
STOKED
Can’t wait to see where mike and graham go with this, great chemistry and witty funny convo, I love when Mike guests on RBP and can’t wait to support here!
Brb lol
Best Watchmen pod
These guys will do the best Watchmen pod. Fan of TV Dudes and Star Trek Discovery Pod also by Mike and Grant. Lindelof fan for life!
Butnik_
