White Hot Hate: Agent Pale Horse
White Hot Hate: Agent Pale Horse
CBC
Reviews
via Podcasts
Biased “journalism”
The host fails to hide an obvious far left socialist agenda in “reporting” this story. Interjecting clear subjective adjectives into the narrative is not providing a fair and balanced representation.
..Hi-def..
Excellent podcast with a big caveat
This is a enlightening and well done podcast, definitely worth your time. However, when you're listening to it, try and take in the irony of a man like this that is a Trump/MAGA supporter trying to educate the world about extremism. He belongs to the white supremacy party. His commentary about his faith and his wife's faith make me want to scream considering what we know Christian nationalists are trying to do to this country right now.
Read more
death stapler
Powerful Storytelling and Eye-Opening Insight
This was an exceptional interview and an incredible story. The host did a fantastic job guiding the conversation and bringing out the depth of an FBI agent’s undercover work infiltrating domestic terrorist groups — specifically white supremacists. I was completely fascinated by the storytelling and the bravery it revealed. Scott’s dedication to protecting all people in our communities, even at great personal risk, is inspiring. Listening gave me new insight and, surprisingly, a deep sense of gratitude for law enforcement — something I haven’t felt in years. Truly a must-listen.
Read more
Jenro78
Beautiful reporting
Highly recommend. One the best!
Carebb
Would have been a FIVE * but…
Loved this! Blew right through every episode. Scott…thank you! I can’t believe the detail you gave and the sacrifices you’ve made over the years. Wish every agent were just like you!!! Michelle…wow. Was that good?! YOU are good. In fact, way TOO good to so obviously and insidiously challenge Scott on his personal politics (thanks for not caving in Scott) and then get on your soapbox. Thank you for proving those who say the mass MEDIA is absolutely the most biased and manipulative group of people who have too much ready influence on citizens and can twist any subject you choose to tell them in your “fair reporting”. The fact that you chose to voice YOUR biased personal opinions at the end of your amazing podcast was shameful. Did we ask? No. I thought I was listening to a true crime podcast. Those four stars I gave are for Scott. Thank you again, Scott! I learned so much…you’re an excellent teacher, so add that to your resume:)
Read more
1Bamamom
Scott is great, Host hates Trump
Scott was awesome how he shared his experience and risking his life for his country. Thank you Scott! But then the Host had to share her political views and bash Trump and Trump supporters. Really, can’t you tell a story without interjecting your own Political opinion.
partynwithplants
Extremely well done.
Thanks to this team for putting down such a quality piece of reporting from the dark side of America. This documentary evokes gratitude for the undercover professionals out there who have/are truly risking their lives to keep us safe.
Hckshcks
So Good. So informative.
This season was inspiring. I wish the world had more Scott Paynes in it.
GrandMasterJS
Well Researched & Interesting
I was amazed how well researched this was. The host was engaging and asked great questions.
Keeno_BigK
Interesting, well-reported, and on point
Excellent reporting, narration, and production. The first season was already fantastic but the CBC crew have continued to cement their work in the second season. Michelle finds great balance between summary and first-hand accounts, and carries the story with pace that allows for detail without over focusing or stagnating the narrative. Scott is the perfect type of big personality that brings intrigue and additional life to solid journalism and an intriguing, well-executed podcast. Easily one of the best in true crime I’ve listened to in a while. Seems funny to me how many people loved the show until politics got involved, as though the two were somehow, up until the end, completely unrelated. It’s almost as if they were more surprised and offended that political issues were raised than they were that the normalized rhetoric in some political circles is both a gateway to and perpetuator of hate… Must be truly awful to leave the door to the echo chamber open, then yell at everyone else like it’s their fault when some truth leaks in.
Read more
jonathannashhh
Excellent
Absolutely gripping and beautifully done. The complaints in these reviews, however, about literally 3 minutes of acknowledging how political rhetoric and policy can contribute to hate-based movements (an indisputable historic truth) are ridiculous and a perfect example of how denial helps foster those movements. If we can’t be honest about these motivating factors, we are going to need a lot more Scotts…
Read more
SESirles
Absolutely loved it but politics need to be left out
I love a good FBI Agent tell all story especially someone like Scott who’s a big guy and big personality who went all in. I like the host and she is who helped write his book but the cross over into politics needed to be left out. I knew right away that someone like Scott isn’t going to go along with her leading questions to get him into the drama of it all. His view and his words were perfect for across all parties and he diffused the direction she was going in. He did all the incredible under cover work so it’s his story…..she tried to take some of the glory by bringing in the politics.
Read more
Dbraidman
Was good to start
I enjoyed it until the end when you got into your political rampage about Trump. Now I’m done listening to any of your material.
butch327
Great podcast
Loved the whole podcast , accept the last 5 minutes which shouldn’t have gotten into politics!
faithhope007
Politics Ruin the Show
Podcast was engaging, Scott does a great job telling us the story. I would have given a better review had the host not went political. Can’t we just leave your politics out?
Lars5075
Good show
Enjoyed the show, Scott is interesting, clearly a dedicated lawman and naturally deeply flawed. I loved his mental gymnastics when trying to separate the current administration from the thugs he infiltrated. Disappointing but unsurprising.
Charrese1
Fascinating story and insight s and questions
A great job with Scott sharing his story and Michelle’s questions. I had attended college 2 years in Canada so would have caught Michelle’s accent immediately 😊. Thanks, Michelle, for asking the questions you did at the end of the last episode, especially as I was binge listening to it at the end of the Prez’ (imperialist thinking “king”) first 100 days. I appreciated Scott’s responses.
USA Mknitter
Don’t need your politics
Keep your political views out please
URGIGUY
Great listen
Have really enjoyed
nordseg
CBC always Outstanding
I loved this podcast. Very interesting and the story itself was great. Bravo CBC!
osuzque
Eye-opening!
The journalistic instinct(s), investigative experience, and courage required to do deliver this kind of work is always woefully under appreciated. Much respect to Michelle and all her colleagues for their efforts on both seasons. This was eye-opening work.
JRBIER
The truth, excellently presented
If anyone has there is widespread white supremacy, this podcast should dispel it. It is well written, narrated and produced. I was struck by Patrick’s father who didn’t see anything wrong with a swastika on his son’s wall, blowing it off to that that’s what kids do. And then later he rails against non-whites. This is reality, folks.
PW from GR
Content is amazing!
Great content. Scott is a great agent and tells the story perfectly. Thank you for your service. Maybe the host shouldn’t put her political views as part of this podcast. She should look up the people Biden pardoned as he shuffled out the door.
CL443
Good! Until…….
Good story, but the idiot host couldn’t resist making her political statements at the end. This behavior existed under democratic presidents as well. Get over it. Funny how Trump derangement syndrome has taken over Canada as well!
reggeee
Great Season Start to Finish
I see a lot of lower ratings because the host decided to talk about the very true and very obvious correlation between these far right groups and Trump. They’ve been emboldened by Trump and him pardoning the J6ers is only going to want to make them sprout up even faster.
Gingerstache56
WHY do the libs need to drag politics into everything
Scott has lived an amazing life, thanks for sharing. The host is a political baiting activist. To bad. Enjoyed the podcast right up to end when the host , like all libs, had to inject their feelings
rudytutes
Great story
Recommend
BAEH008
pretty solid worth a listen
it was very weird the way his personal voting was interrogated. that said a lot of other reviewers seem to mention the hosts left wing bias. which maybe a little but the host makes it clear when it’s her opinion. and this is a podcast not a news article. finally people seem to complain about connecting this stuff to trump…after they literally play audio of the base members talking about trump as a gateway. no one is saying “you” are in support of right wing extremism and voting for trump doesn’t mean you are. but acting like it’s not generally associated with a particular set of political beliefs, idk who people think they’re convincing.
Read more
JamesMcNally000
Scott is AWESOME
Not a fan of the host but Scott is awesome and has such an interesting life to share
BFW25
Was great
Up until the host gets political. Having a group of racists support Trump isn’t the same as Trump supporting their movement.
BlindNotBroken84
Scott Payne Story
The story of Scott Payne is awesome but as with most of the media Michelle just can’t seem to back off her own bias.
Mongo@72
Horrifying knowing they’re out there
This was a fascinating podcast. It was horrifying when you realize these people are out there, just walking around among us. I fear it’s going to only get worse.
Eagle treehouse
Love most of the podcast
I find Scott’s story fascinating. I found Michelle tedious at times. To pretend that both political parties do not stoke hatred to the far left as well as the far right is either extremely naive or, I suspect, by design. If you are truly a “journalist” it’s not enough to “agree to disagree”. Do better.
threebeesandme
Baddest MF walkin’
Netflix please give this man a show; this is an incredible story, VERY well reported/produced!!
goinbrazie
Could have been great
This is a well put together podcast and an even better look into hate groups and crimes. However, it’s obviously left leaning and although the host is a great presenter she does not keep her beliefs out of the story. Even finds a way to link trump to white supremacy at the end. There are hate groups on both sides of the fence and yet it is all “far right” on repeat. Also, I’d say putting an episode together based on text to speech doesn’t seem like great reporting. I think this could be amazing but I wish it could be neutral reporting and investigation. I won’t be listening to season 2 , but make your own judgement and decide if it’s for you.
Read more
Dustin beard
Interesting but
Good podcast and appreciate the coverage on exposing terrible hate groups. What bothers me is that there are extremism hate groups in both the far right AND the far left, however the far right get mentioned over and over again as if hate groups in the far left don’t exist.
Aj18428
Sad
It’s unfortunate, but the old man in episode 1 called it. Scott’s entrapping these young men. They are pathetic racists but they would never go this far without a boost from Scoot. Michelle is amazing!!!!
Msp629
Sad
The depths Scott will go to in order to avoid conflict with the writer during the final moments of this podcast are telling. Instead of standing up for his convictions, he nervously laughs and lays down. Pathetic.
ClaudiusGuias
Interesting subject, terrible host.
Interesting subject to hear and learn about. Too bad it was overshadowed by the host’s left leaning talking points. In the end she of course finds a way to link Trump to white supremacy. Such nonsense. Don’t spend your money supporting such garbage “journalism”.
J-VS
Phenomenal
Every bit of it
Crackersandcheese69
Good content. Incredibly bias.
The coverage of the hate groups and undercover operations themselves is top notch. However it is incredibly left bias and ends with the writer claiming Trump is the problem and insinuating that Kash Patel is also a White nationalist. Very disappointing ending to a great show.
Jesse AIB
Loved this podcast!!
Loved this podcast. Michele is such a great interviewer. Scott is a really great story teller. I felt like I was right there in the action. There is one thing…I really hope Scott has changed his opinion on our current government.
bdhdjn zcnvdom xu
The best most interesting thing I have listened to in a very long time!!! Thank you ….
Super!!
Bob’s widow
They uh, they did actually burn down towns
Sorry libs
🐢💨 turtle farts
Fact Check
Zero cities have been “burned down” by anyone, let alone “BLM” or “antifa” despite the propaganda other reviewers are pushing. This is important reporting, and just like science - it doesn’t matter if you don’t “believe in it” it’s happening.
j_a_x_
Just stop
BLM, Antifa, et al are rioting, burning down cities, causing chaos and untold harm. So sick of the liberal lies trying to cover up their crimes and recreate reality as if it’s a white supremacy problem.
MylissaR
And I knew it was bad…
If you don’t think there is hate and fascism knocking at the door, listen to this podcast and the investigative reporting here will verify and then validate your darkest notions of how far down the rabbit hole groups of mostly young, white men have fallen. The historical review in episode 6 was stunning. Thank you for taking risky chances so we all could get a firmer grip on this new abnormal 2.0
Read more
MtnBikingGirl
Stop lying
This is NOT a wide spread or large movement. It just isn’t.
Mike in WY
WOW
This is probably the most thought provoking journalism I’ve ever heard!!!!
ArrowLauncher
I Could Listen to Ms. Shephard For Hours
Amazing podcast about horrible people but I love the way it was presented. I could feel Michelle abhors the deeds but she refrains from being overly dramatic like "Oh my god!!!" statement. She just narrates and leaves the judging to the listeners.
Josh from California
Load more