Reviews
via Podcasts
“You either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain.”
I tried to continue to listening, having heard most episodes since the first, but the pod has reached Cornette levels of vitriol. It is comparable to him (pronouns pal) slandering Kenny and Generation Me every week. In both instances, they could easily talk about anything and anyone else while never having to mention the “offending” parties. Hopefully, the pod can return to form.
Definitely Not P. Brooks
A ways to go!
Really enjoying this show! Starting from the beginning! Only 550 shows to go!!
Chad A. Moore
BRIAN!!!!
I started from the very beginning on the Spotify and I'm up to like # 397 and this is easily the best wrestling podcast by non-wrestlers. Love the Hogan voicemail impressions, Matt's Triple H impression and, of course, when he makes fun of Meltzer by saying, "BRIAN!". I have a friend named Brian that will never hear his name said normally ever again. This pod rules. Also love the homework segments where the review old wrestling like WCCW, Mid South, etc. Fantastic.
Read more
SpideyInATree
Terrible podcast
This podcast is bad, the hosts are a couple of failed,
Bald comedians who are not at all funny. They’ve opinions on wrestling are even worse they like Colt Cabana a failed comedy wrestler that’s not funny and only known for being CM Punks Brutus The Barber Beefcake.
Nylarjoetep
5 Stars
The only podcast I would even compare quality to is MFM. It feels good to be WrestleRino . Stay Strong and Don’t get Body Slammed!
boxofoddities2
All Wrestling is Welcome
Love this podcast. It is not just a WWE review show. They watch and talk about anything wrestling from indie shows they actually attend to old school Mid-South to Japan. It’s about being a fan of wrestling.
Jamie Coy
The best wrestling podcast
Matt and Vince are the WGPTT(Worlds Greatest Podcast Tag Team) Just like Benjamin and Haas, these two have the skill, versatility and work ethic to dominate the division. I love Matt’s hilarious and realistic Triple H impression. I love Vince’s epic long term storyline of Eddie Kingston’s Pants. So many awesome moments: Smarky Jerry Seinfeld, creating lyrics for NES Wrestlemania, the joy that the guys get out of the dumbest gimmicks (Mr. America?!). Listen to this, you won’t regret it.
Read more
Undead legion
Hi
I enjoyed the podcast
maybegravey
Used to be good
Was a big fan when it was the 3 of them but since Tom left it kinda lost what made it unique, now it’s just another wrestling podcast. I also only watch AEW & WWE and they talk mostly about New Japan and indies. Also Matt talks over Vince a lot which is very annoying.
Michael_Scorn
“I’m beggin’ you to listen...”
I’ve been listening to this show weekly since April 30th, 2014 at 3:03PM CDT and it’s never failed to make me chuckle and at the same time help me discover weird and wacky wrestling things on the webs. Subscribe to this and go behind the paywall; it’s even better. It took me way too long to do so and it’s ended up being the best $7 I spend a month. 6.5 star podcast.
BigRemy
My absolute favorite podcast
What can I say - it's my favorite podcast, and I even pay for the extra Patreon content. The hosts are knowledgable and funny, the content is entertaining and level-headed. It's a must-listen for anyone who loves our crazy sport of professional wrestling.
Mitch Mac316
What happened?
This used to be a top tier wrestling podcast, but since their failed attempt to put it behind a paywall the quality has gone downhill. Vince just doesn’t seem interested in anything besides hating on wrestling. Moreover, weekly he admits to not watching wrestling, yet will go to criticize it.
Matty McC tries his best, but unfortunately he has Vince’s mopey attitude dragging him down.
DC530123
Yeah im unsubscribing now
I thought maybe after they whined every episode for 4 years about politics, that maybe they would get back to talking about wrestling. But now they just moved on to whining about anyone who they disagree with/has a different opinion in the most cliche, non comedic way possible. the complaining/holier than thou attitude gets real old after a bit. Havent finished an episode in a while, so ill just move on rather than listen to the opinions of 2 lame guys who cant even get their own health in order.
Read more
onetofollow
Subjective art form
Love wrestling, love podcasts, love this wrestling podcast
Gompy
Miss you, Tom. Miss you every day!
The first 35-50 episodes, with the YouTube clips, Rob producing, and the overall great vibe between the guys — gotta be one of the best pro wrestling pods of all time. From there it was a long, downward glide that bottomed out with the bleak days of Vince and Matt just openly bullying Tom on the show between shilling for razors and begging people to mail them cool old wrestling magazines and merch. Sad! I listened to Sibley’s last episode and then never again.
Read more
MikeDonovan1138
Boop!
Hey Brother, listen to this podcast! Maybe have me on. Schedule is clear, duuuuude!
-HH
Madtown Fro
Time limit draw on tumblr
I seriously don’t watch wrestling anymore but I listen every week and support them on Patreon ($7 tier brother) because this show is all the wrestling I need. Miss you Tom miss you every week
Not J T
If it took place in Japan it would be 6 stars!
Best in the world!
GSONightmare
6 Stars if it was In The Dome
Who’s your favorite wrestler?
SapienChavez
The Bottom Line
No star ratings but plenty of yucks, pal.
Rembrant420
6 Stars
The only Six star Wrestling Podcast I’ve ever heard in the United States.
Rude & Wreckless
Cool your pies with the boys!
Best podcast ever
DaystormX
Best in the business
There is no better wrestling podcast, plain and simple.
Steven Buscemi (not the actor)
Tremendous facility
This truly is the greatest wrestling podcast. It's refreshing compared to the majority of wrestling podcasts that are overwhelmingly negative and want everyone to hate wrestling as much as they do.
These guys have helped me discover how much I love wrestling by introducing me to other promotions, indie wrestlers and classic wrestlers from before I started watching. My neckbeard is now as thick as I ever could have dreamed.
Vince - The greatest babyface in the business. Can do no wrong. Is a God amongst men.
Matt - Great insight and always hilarious. A great educator when it comes to explaining any wrestler, event or angle in wrestling.
Miss you, Tom, miss you everyday. History will be kind to Tom Sibley.
Read more
heelturn
Hell yeah
This is the best wrestling podcast.
bradwenzel
Do you like wrestling!!!???
Just love everything about this podcast.
Jameshodg315
A podcast for the people
Amazingly entertaining hosts, informed and knowledgeable conversations as well as bat stuff crazy tangents and impressions. Absolutely love it. Makes me want to charge a polar bear. I’ll get six shots.
Bigfish62
Really want to like this
As I looooove hearing the host guest on other podcasts, but the meandering ultimately awkward attempts at banter with interspersed slices of their uninteresting personal lives and inside jokes that are so obviously unfunny it doesn’t even pique your interest in their explanation... reminds me of trying to hook up with that nerdy girl from band camp before realizing I wasn’t in band camp or a nerd, so I went back to where normal well adjusted people talk about wrestling. Sorry.
Read more
cnyren
Love this podcast
I’m a casual wrestling fan who enjoys hearing funny people who know their stuff talk shop. This podcast is for me.
ScAlMo
Sometimes fun buuuuuut
Annoying people at their job to ask inane questions about food policy is an auto-unsubscribe from me.
Trenton Albinny
No but YES
It sounds like one of those shows that come on the radio, but I listened to it and can'tWAIT to tell it to the person in my class who loves sports and stuff.and yes,I'm still in school
And I did hate it
foxgirl999
No
This podcast sounds like one of those bad, bad, bad morning shows that are on when one is driving to work.
Mr. El Guapo
Best wrestling podcast period
By far the best wrestling podcast. These guys are so funny and knowledgeable and not annoying like most other wrestling podcast hosts.
TheLarloa
666th review
I’m the 666th rating 🤘🏻
vince russo's beard
Just started listening
Just started listening to this pod and it’s fresh it’s unique and they keep it real. Subscribed!
Me20017089
unpopular opinion
Just want so say I really enjoy the podcast with just Vince and Matt. They get into more details and it really just feels like i’m overhearing two guys at a bar talking wrasslin, which i love
Itsmemulder
I though I never do this but........
It’s addition by subtraction really. Since Tom never really added anything replacing him not might be necessary. It’s five stars from now on baby. Good luck Sib. My favorite wrestler......the Living Legend. Larry Zybicso
Big Harry Ballz
Fantastic Podcast
I hope the show continues well into the future either as a two man show or with a new third host.
Ben Catahoula
Thanks for everything
I’ve been listening to podcasts for about 6 years by now, and this was one of my first and has remained my favorite. What y’all have done is amazing.
I understand that Tom is leaving, and that breaks my heart. Still, I can understand knowing when it’s time to leave (miss you Tom, miss you every day).
I hope Vince and Matt keep it up. Your podcast is a high point of my week. Please stick around and have Tom on for guest episodes.
I never leave reviews for anything ever, and this is my first podcast review. Please don’t stop. Miss you Tom.
Read more
TheBullSon
Best Wrestling Podcast Ever
This is the most entertaining and comedic wrestling podcast out there. Do yourself a favor subscribe and enjoy. Every week they bring excitement and the highlights of the current product from WWE to New Japan to the Los Angles Indy’s such as PWG and Bar Wrestling. I would love to see this show continue. Matt and Vince make a great team, looking forward to the show with or without a replacement for Tom.
Read more
Matt McC from OKC
-boop-
Hey brother, this podcast is flippin rad duuude. Lots of talk about the hulkster and all the little maniacs going on in this thing dude. Can’t wait to make them proud when I come back. Man my arms are jacked, Jack. Gimmie a call guys.
G man Metts
The best in the world
I love it. Keep em coming
Heegman
6 stars arent available
Fantastic! Great mix of wrestling insight, comedy, and nonsense. Hoping it works out where I can see them at a live show
Koho84
My favorite podcast of the week
Each week these guys give some of the best talk of wrestling across the world filled with a lot of laughs. It’s a great break from the week! Thanks guys. You’re the best!
Mddtennis
Hilarious and informative
A great wrestling podcast, the guys a funny, knowledgeable, not to mention the only place to hear Tom on a podcast as he doesn’t seem to have a personal one! Stopped my their table at Starrcast and they were the nicest people you could meet, hope to see them live in Chicago soon!
akabee9
Alright. Alright. Alright.
These guys are great. Funny. Insightful. Knowledgeable. Tom really brings that greenhorn charm. Great listen.
Message to the guys: Let’s cool your pies on Garden City, MI jabs. It isn’t as bad as it used to be. Houses sell for around $15,000 instead of the $6,000 it used to. Plus King Kones open all year round now.
wchihan
It’s a podcast. About wrestling
Sibley burping into mic is better than McCarthy doing impressions
JuiceKovacs
Slammin Beef
My favorite podcast. I love hearing what the guys have to say about current wrasslin and I’m always excited when they bring up stuff from the past. It gives me something to go back and watch. I appreciate you guys! Would love to try and catch a live show I. San Jose or the Bay Area at some point!
Ps, am I supposed to feel bad for Tom yet??
dtowndoesit
STILL...
More fun than punching a sleeping baby!
BryanBrawl
Yes
I’m pretty new to the show but I love these boys! They’re like my best friends and I wanna give em a smooch! I love wrestling and the way these guys talk makes me laugh very hard and deep. Gonna give em a big thumbs up and a five star review. I love em.
SuperDinoMike
