Our first Macaulay Culkin movie! What starts as happy nostalgia quickly evaporates as the boys are angry and Jim is agitated by everything. Is this The Brave Little Toaster 2.0? Is Vada Sultenfuss the worst name ever? Is Dan Aykroyd's character the worst dad ever?! Take some deep breaths and prepare yourself for Season 3 Episode 8 of WTTWG? as they review "My Girl."To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

Jonathan Taylor Thomas teams up with Chevy Chase and Farrah Fawcett in this tale of a potential stepdad just trying his best. Nick is distracted by a zipline while Jim is impressed by one of the most influential clowns of our time. This episode has it all: shower scenes, mimes and childhood trauma. Enjoy Season 3 Episode 5 of WTTWG? as they review "Man of the House."To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

Three 11-year-old boys befriend a prostitute with a heart of gold. What could go wrong?? Jim desperately tries (unsuccessfully) to harness his rage while Nick wonders how big of a reach Cosmo Magazine has. Buckle up for some sex education, wetlands, and a possible grown up character from another reviewed movie. This is Season 3 Episode 4 of WTTWG? with the review of "Milk Money."To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

Brendan Fraser? Leslie Mann? Talking gorillas? How could this possibly go wrong. We’ll tell you how! This movie has it all: oily abs, kicks in the balls and coconuts in sleeping bags. Grab a vine and take a ride with us as we review "George of the Jungle” on this week’s episode of the pod.To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

A movie about a boy, a cupboard, and a PLAS-TECK Indian. Were Nick and Jim's hearts warmed from the nostalgia? Not exactly. Poor tattoos, animal cruelty and a bad friend lead to a movie that even the great Frank Oz can't save. Enjoy Season 3 Episode 2 of WTTWG? as they review "Indian in the Cupboard."To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

Feel the rhythm! Feel the rhyme! Get on up, it's bobsled time! Just in time for the Winter Olympics, the boys watch this classic about four underdogs led by John Candy. Kiss your lucky egg and buckle up because they are going full speed to the finish line on Season 3, Episode 3 as the boys watch "Cool Runnings" and ask, "We Thought This Was Good?"To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

Is this a fever dream? An early version of what will eventually become Toy Story? A horror movie for children? The guys have SO many questions. Why does everyone hate Blanky? Can toasters run? Even Jon Lovitz can’t save this movie for Nick, and Jim’s warm memories of this movie come to a screeching halt. Buckle up as the fellas do their best to find Master in the big city in S3E6 where they review “The Brave Little Toaster.”To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

Did you miss us? It's been a minute, but we're back with Season 3! Jim has hate in his heart for one person and one animal in this movie, and Nick wishes there were less fat jokes and dog balls. The two discuss another unhinged Ebert review as they review the 1993 classic, Homeward Bound. To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

A bonus episode? What is the meaning of this! Nick and Jim have the honor of interviewing Max Goldblatt, star of one of their favorite movies, "Heavyweights". The guys discuss Max's family history in Hollywood, Heavyweights aging so well, and hilarious harmonica scores. Also, make sure to check out Max's new movie, "Sacramento" on Hulu right now! Enjoy this bonus episode as we get ready to embark onto Season 3 of WTTWG.To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons

It's the Season 2 finale! Nick wants some PF Flyers and Jim finally pays Ebert a compliment. The guys discuss Benny being the best role model ever, Smalls' hat being the worst ever and they both get way too invested in dog years. Grab your mitt and get ready for Season 2 Episode 10 of WTTWG? as they review "The Sandlot."To watch and listen to other episodes, follow us on social media or support the show, check out: https://linktr.ee/WethoughtthiswasgoodInstagram: https://instagram.com/wethoughtthiswasgoodFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/WeThoughtThisWasGoodTik Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@wethoughtthiswasgoodTheme song by Greg Henkin of Greg's Guitar Lessons