Reviews
via Podcasts
News for all of us
This series may be considered “one-sided” but “big media” won’t share this side of the story with you so Audible tells the other side of the story.
Kozmo 702
Addictive
Could not stop listening - a classic example of how easy it is for people to turn into exactly what they claim they hate…. And the tendency to mislabel entitlement as either authority or activism.
TheRecruitBuyer
Responding to the last Reviewer
Skwarepeg you are a Libtard. You are not willing to see things from anyone else’s side. That is not what they are saying whatsoever and you just showed how unintelligent you are. You have no idea how much others have listened to of this podcast and they are entitled to their opinions. MAGA love immigrants however the illegal ones they do not love because just like every other country it is WRONG to enter a country illegally. Even legal immigrants do not like illegals. You’re blind and you’re a hypocrite. You will eat your words one day and a good podcast will see things from every side not just one side so keep being a fool. And this podcast needs to learn to see things from every side unless it wants to keep failing.
Read more
RhoadyM
One Sided Journalism
This is one sided journalism. It would’ve been nice to hear the other sides opinion in more than five second clips. If these activists were as nonviolent as they claim. Then why does Tort AKA Turtle’s Mother ask him if he has a gun with him in camp? In my opinion, his Mother asked the question because she knows it’s very possible for Tort to carry a firearm. In other words they were not "murdered". They were shot after opening fire on the police.
Read more
Jcicala
Amazing & Informative
This podcast blew me away! It is incredible what can happen in America that doesn’t get covered widely by news outlets. Even if you do not agree with a protestor’s political position they still have a right to protest. What sticks with me beyond the tragic details are the true hearts and feelings of these maligned main actors. Also that these actions in the sixties would have been called ‘peaceful protest’ not ‘terrorism’. And the commentary that any violation of any citizens’ rights is wrong and will only lead to further violations of larger and less marginalized groups.
Read more
PayneInSA
Good podcast
Personally I really liked this, I thought it did a good job of showing different POVs. Clearly it was biased towards the protestors, telling their POV, but I thought it also did a good job of highlighting some of their missteps and the racial tensions and how they can be perceived as out of touch. I also have a personal bias towards the liberal side so I’m sure that factored into how I experienced this podcast.
Even with that, honestly I kind of symbolically rolled my eyes a lot - the fact that they’re white and gender bending (foreign to the majority of the black community in the US) and the community seems to be against them too, clearly unorganized, clearly taking a lot of wrong steps and playing right into the hands of people that want to demonize them, makes it hard to fully be on their side. I’m so glad they had Matthew on there because he felt more grounded than anyone, until the end. I kind of want to send this to my GenZ sister who is a lot more progressive than me and see what she thinks, but she doesn’t listen to podcasts…
I will say I’ve been amazed at and disheartened by the complete 180 from 2020 to now and I don’t know how to get that momentum back. Clearly we need different tactics. I’m also a supremely practical person and I’d like progressives to be a little more centered in reality; but then again idealists are the ones who change the world.
Read more
Glo3489
Can you find the uneducated boomers?
The number of reviews from people who didn’t listen to more than 10 minutes 🙄or who complain that the protesters don’t have their political ideology (MAGAT), or who don’t know what victim means, or who don’t understand nuance or that reporting doesn’t mean “defending”, or who don’t know actual American history and want everyone else to leave … well, the # is astounding. The relief is that the worst of these is dying off pretty quickly if not soon enough.
So the podcast was done well enough, I’d say, but it was hard for me to completely see the POV of the protesters. I do wonder what it would have been like to have the other POV reported side by side.
Read more
Skwarepeg
Confused…
This is really less about the podcast (which was garbage) and more about the protest… so u think cops are ill-trained bullies so you’re going to protest a place where cops can be trained not to be bullies?
Ellipsis King…
Balanced reporting of an issue that will soon affect all of us
I’ll be honest - I was getting annoyed by the somber music and use of phrases like “be in community with each other” when they just mean “hang out.” I was also getting confused by so many different names for one person: Tort, Tortugita, Manuel, Mani…it felt like a reading Dostoyevsky.
However, I’m so glad I stuck with it and listened to the end. I was in tears by the 6th episode as I felt the community’s anguish over the loss of Tortugita.
I was deeply impressed by the journalism that humanized both the journalists and the cops.
Read more
SimoneDraws
Whine City
Weakling Hippies Progressive Propaganda Podcast. Nothing but woe is me from kids raised with silver spoons in their mouths talking about communism.
truthruck
No thanks
This story was meant to gardener sympathy for mentally ill people who simply want to destroy everything that is normal in our world. Get over yourselves and stop with the terrorism.
NikkiPonce
Eye opening for Atlanta folks, especially
Those who don’t appreciate this podcast are clearly in question of basic human rights. I found it to be impeccably researched and non biased in the message it aims to get across. Using people’s intended pronouns is important, and something that we need to get used to in this day and age. I found all the interviewees to be intelligent and well spoken, and I thought that it was very well presented. As a metro Atlanta native, I am well aware of what goes on around here, and I say good on these producers for getting this story out! I will never forget seeing “stop cop city” in graffiti on the outside wall of a gas station I used to frequent, probably 25 miles away from the forest where this went on. I’m open minded and I understand all sides. However, it’s so important to realize that people have the right to be able to protest against that which they believe to be wrong. And nobody deserves to be subjected to unnecessary force.
Read more
Hannelore Eshbach
Sheeee baby
Who is she ??? I love her !! Stand up for what’s right and never let anyone tell you , you can’t !!
Jordy😈
Interesting
Thought the story was interesting. Was a little miffed by the protestor behavior which was a drag…
BigAppleGreg
Disappointing
Author is skilled at making “what if” statements sound like facts and only ever defends protesters - refuses to hold protesters accountable for their actions
AmyBeckner516
Terrible
Couldn’t get through first episode. Use of preferred pronouns was ridiculous and hard to follow. Are they talking about more than one person or a single person that thinks they need to be plural?? Geez. First episode was slow and definitely has a bias. Unfollow.
mtnbikecrash
Comment bombing aside, it's great!
Sad to see so many disingenuous commenters. This is a well reported show concerning vital issues - thank you for your hard work!
ThisGameIsAdorable:3
Worth checking out
I recall hearing about Copy City in the news, though I didn’t follow the developments closely. I found the podcast both informative and engaging. The story definitely favored the side of the protestors, but the producers stated they attempted to include perspectives from government officials and law enforcement, but those parties declined to participate. While it appears that most of the forest protesters were engaged in peaceful demonstration, a minority escalated tensions by engaging in destructive acts. The decision to classify protesters as domestic terrorists and pursue RICO charges is deeply troubling and sets a dangerous legal precedent. If this approach becomes normalized, it raises serious concerns about the future of First Amendment protections.
Read more
root@
Stupid
Ok so a bunch of loser young adults that come from upper class households have no jobs and destroy people’s property. Same people keying people’s Teslas. You guys wanna start your own alphabet soup hippie commune? He’s an idea get a job, buy your own land and do it.
TB12 2 AH81=7
Hard to follow
It’s not fair to people who don’t have crazy mental disabilities who have just been affirmed by woke people their whole lives. How am I supposed to know what character is what when everyone is ‘they them’ and they’re saying she but you’re hearing a man speak?
EnterTAINmeFTLOG
Lies and more lies.
If the person interview lies there’s nothing you can do but when the host himself blatantly lies about things that happened on camera you lose any credibility
In the last episode the host joins the terrorists. Do better Wondery.
You must use the proper pronouns when describing criminals what a joke.
papabev
Mental illness is running rampant in this podcast.
Can’t believe I’ve wasted this much time. I just can’t not listen to the train wreck.
MaleMan07
No thanks
I like podcasts because I enjoy hearing about people’s stories/opinions who I might not otherwise come across in my daily life. I was so excited to see a new Wondery podcast, but was very disappointed in this.
Like an author of a written book, a pod host needs to be able to give the listener a clear picture of who we are listening to. This podcast vaguely introduces people, but with all the they/them pronouns and ‘partner’ terminology I couldn’t tell who I was really listening to, which made me care less about their story than I normally would.
These activists speak about peace in one breath, then laugh about torching a contractor’s work truck on fire. Most have no jobs, don’t pay taxes, and want to live for free on government/city-owned land.
One activist thought it was good they destroyed & set a business on fire because a parolee driving under the influence stole an officer’s weapon, tried to flee, and was ultimately shot by the police.
The host seemed to sympathize with these people without really giving an unbiased report.
I honestly hated every second of this.
Read more
TXMOM04
Controversy not equally represented
The podcast downplayed the fact that the forest dwellers were purposefully protesting and trying to be in the way of progress. I also found the misuse of pronouns very confusing and unnecessary. Calling a person “they/them” is at least bad grammar and at most very confusing in any produced work.
Cdogit
Long journey to nowhere
This could of been done in one or two episodes with more of a
Punch. I started loosing interest early in.
Don’t waste your time
c-crash
Reviewers, take your political agenda elsewhere
If you are looking for well-researched story about real people (both the protesters and the cops), give this a listen. There are too many political trolls out there with the same hateful comments as the politicians they worship and who have nothing better to do with their lives.
AZlover247
Real life
Kind of a waste of time, one sided view of misguided and confused people.
On a heater
viva viva tortuguita
this series was beautifully produced. hearing the story from the voices of the forest defenders lends a new perspective to the masses — one that forces the listener to reject the narrative they’ve been fed. love and solidarity to all of these storytellers.
pangelina holie
Good podcast about a non-sympathetic subject
Really not a sympathetic view of the protesters or the cause, most of us can agree. The podcast is pretty well done though, and I listened through to the end, so three stars.
marbel1010
Absolute Garbage
I live in Atlanta. This is literally a giant homeless encampment full of drug addicts. Almost none of them have a Georgia ID or pay taxes but they want to talk about how our city should spend tax payer money.. it’s a complete joke. This podcast is glorifying the underbelly of society.
philipejose
Ummmmm…..
If you want a story about a bunch of losers, picking fights with police and destroying property, and then acting like they are the victims, this is the one for you.
Scottdawg2
Why lie?
A lot of buildup only to find out the “victim” was a (nother) violent criminal. Pass.
Bellamammal
Boring, one-sided narrative, skip this podcast
This is a real yawner, told from the perspective of a bunch of self-appointed and self-anointed “freedom fighter” activists who used a protest against the construction of a law enforcement training facility outside of ATL as an excuse to hang out in the forest glamping and having a huge pity party for each other. Most of the people interviewed are suffering from varying levels of self-delusion and mental illness. It’s pretty pathetic and easily one of the worst podcasts Wondery has ever produced. I listened to three episodes and there is not a single interview of anyone from the law enforcement community who were involved in the disputed training facility, rather it’s just bunch of woke, entitled brats who’ve never done anything except mooched off of their parents and later society, always quick to blame everyone for everything that’s ever gone wrong except themselves. This is a pathetic story, poorly produced, and conducted by a totally unimpressive interviewer. Don’t waste any more time than what it takes to read simply the title to my review and wave off from this drivel.
Read more
racecar38
I’m liberal but…
I like to think of myself as a woke liberal. But these protesters sort of made me side with building cop city. They don’t want law-enforcement, but then they commit crimes in order to express that desire, even though they claim they want to create a new crime-free society. Huh?? Lol. It’s kind of annoying listening to them.
PodListener124
self righteous virtue signaling Olympics!
Sweet Jesus, this needs to go down as a gold medal winner in white savior history! Never have I heard such pathetic snivelings as this podcast. From the get-go a group of deadbeats sneak into a drive -in movie to being surprised a cop would shoot back when fired upon!?!? You miserable saps constantly complaining about cops need to do a better job ( I actually agree with you here) so they want to build a training center to have more training and your upset at that? My real grip is at these perpetual victims, they don’t care about these causes or people, they wear through these causes like it’s fashion. That’s all it is to them. Ohh look at me, I’m nonbinary and protesting whatever the woke mind virus has told me I should be angry at today!
Read more
Turdbird77
Mr Shaer you’ve lost a fan.
I enjoyed the first podcast of yours I heard so much I sought out all your other works. This one is BY FAR the worst. You threw all your journalistic integrity in a burn pit. In your other works I greatly appreciated your skilled ability to report on very sensitive and polarizing issues without showing any obvious bias for either side. The way you told this story is so despicable and unprofessional that it distracted from the nightmarish series of events you are discussing. I spent 18 years as an Army Ranger and was severely wounded in Iraq and Afghanistan. The first people I learned NOT to trust when I joined was the government. So I am a listener that had an intimate knowledge of how corrupt, dirty and unapologetic any arm of the government can be. You still managed to completely enrage me which led me to writing my first review for ANYTHING!!!
This is disappointing because i had great respect for you as an investigative journalist but you lost all credibility with me. I stopped after episode 5 but hope i can manage to finish listening at some point because it’s a story that needs to be told and it’s one that could be used as a tool to train new Law enforcement officers.
Do more research on things you know nothing about.
I guarantee you, not one person in uniform that day had a “fully automatic assault rifle.”
Fully automatic firearms are exclusive to the military and are called machine guns.
There is absolutely NO such thing as an assault rifle. That is a word created by politicians and used to vilify and mislead the public. An AR 15 is semi automatic just like a 9mm pistol is.
I’m not going down this road but you need to google what the AR stands for instead of regurgitating info.
Listen, all LE officers with boots on the ground in operations like this are operating on orders from superiors who are also relaying orders given by their Superiors and so forth. You can guarantee this whole plan to put officers in those woods stared at the city council level. So the police chief was probably told to “Fix the problem” so we can start work on the facility. That mission was passed down level after level to the officers who would be charged with the task. There is no telling how much or how little Info they were given about the group they were being sent to remove from the woods.
A lot can be learned from both sides of this event.
Local governments have to spend money to ensure officers are trained at much higher levels in every aspect of that job. Like the army, when an officer takes action that leads to an investigation to determine if he was negligent, his chain of command should also be investigated to determine if they were derelict in their duty when it comes to the proper passing of information to those involved. The supervisors are responsible to make sure officers are prepared, equipped and trained for the daily duties required by the position they hold. They are especially responsible for ensuring the proper personnel are briefed and selected for these types of operations.
That said, the officers on the ground had every right to be on high alert. The violent actions by select members of this organization are to blame for that. If you want to protest then follow the rules, get a permit and protest.
If you want to live in the woods, start a commune or whatever then go buy some property and have a blast.
I have no problem with challenging the government, in fact I encourage it. I do have a problem with a group that decides to intimidate by destroying property and threatening violence against people who have just as much right to be there as they do. They also justify that by saying it’s to save the forest which I absolutely don’t buy. They chose that spot and they got comfortable and simply were not going to be told they had to leave.
I grieve for the lost of life in this story. This could have all been avoided and there are lessons to be learned by everyone moving forward.
You dropped the ball you could have done a lot of good with this story. Instead you have lost a fan and I am sure I won’t be the only one.
Read more
B.Med101
I'm liberal and against cop city...
...But this podcast does a weird job of presenting the facts. Leaving critical information until the last episode. Seems this could've been done better to portray the movement in a better light. A valid movement is getting lost in the sensationalism and poor reporting.
mikewestside
Skip this podcast!
I listened with the intention to understand and empathize with the protesters but they lose me. And are they fighting for exactly?!?
Good reporting but storyline was disappointing.
Sleepy Hollow 🥱🥱🥱
Really?
I could only listen for 10 min. This podcast illustrates the naïveté, overt cluelessness, and sheeple attitude that has created the mess our country faces. The ‘I’m so oppressed’ voice of Vienna is nails on a blackboard. A typical, spoiled rich kid who wants to rebel. But makes all of moral humanity and pay the price for her narcissistic desire for attention and misguided attempts at ‘activism’. I hope God gives you mercy when the time comes. If left to Me…I AM ashamed to say I WOULD NOT.
Life’s hard. Wear a helmet. Stop playing the ‘victims’. America has HAD IT. If you do not like America returning to its Constitutional and Christian roots… PLEASE LEAVE. Go live in a Communist/Socialist country… live well and prosper. LEAVE. This America is here to stay. Our patience for this madness is exhausted.
Read more
JAPC
A perfect illustration of the world we live in
Don’t let the other reviews fool you. This is a very well done podcast. Excellent production quality. Great story telling. Important opportunity for learning.
VerbenaMama
Also here for the red hat cultists tears 😭
Excellent podcast!
Venice Mamacita
Here for the right wing tears
Delicious.
@thedcal
Trash
Woke garbage
lanibuckets
So Biased
If this podcast was meant to elicit sympathy for the activists, it did the opposite for me. The story was incredibly biased. Nearly all of the airtime was dedicated to the activists. They made themselves the victims. The activists had no plan to actually create change, and their actions actually caused more violence. It sounds like it was a bunch of people who needed a bandwagon to jump on, unhappy with their lives and searching for identity. My daughter was convinced she was trans for a while, and started to transition until she realized she had been influenced by what basically constitutes as a cult. Vienna’s comment “when they came in they were she/her, then they became she/them, and by the time they left they were they/them. Oops!” was nauseating. And Portland and Seattle tried to defund the police, with disastrous results that they are trying to change. I’m so over this woke nonsense.
Read more
MkmHgk
Trump beat you guys😂😂😂😂
How does it feel that the American people exposed you guys?
The reviews on this propaganda are one of the most encouraging things I’ve seen in a very, very long time!
It’s over! The people have spoken and the democratic money laundering scheme is over!
Your factions will be arrested very soon! Oh the sweet, sweet fragrance
I refuse to have a nickname
Challenging
This was a challenging listen. It challenged my perspective and bias, and my penchant to jump to judgment of those I disagree with. I learned a lot about “cop city” and a lot about the activists. Criticism of both the activists and the cops in this story is valid, but I felt the reporting allowed me to make up my own mind. One note - I would have liked to hear interviews with the cops, not just the forest folks.
Read more
Becks39
Too Woke
I tried…I can’t…I’m just so over this woke nonsense. It’s SO tired.
Darbybow
What???
I was really engaged, thinking. This was a man holding the people down situation. Until I realized how much spin that wondery and the writers were putting on the story. An unemployed, environmental terrorist. Shoots at a police officer, and that is brushed under the rug, and a servant of the church uses his car as a weapon? There’s definitely a story to be told here but it’s not the one in this podcast.
Read more
stalverd
Still waiting...
I hope the first couple of episodes are just setting the groundword and we eventually get to an unbiased story. I'm definitely choking on the pro progressive activism that is being forced down my throat right now. This story has the potential to be good, but it aint yet.
lilDan81
Exceptional journalism
This is journalism at its finest. It’s well written and well spoken objective coverage on a polarizing subject. Seems the people writing the negative reviews don’t understand the journalist remains neutral, going above and beyond to cover both sides equally with thoughtful detail and bravery.
Cambridge1976
