Reviews
via Podcasts
…
I saw this show I think it’s good but I have been wondering are you going to do bonfire side chat again? Please and thank you
Bush_where_fire_burns
The best!
Some of the only people on the internet that are actually good at talking about video games! Modridge rules
bigoldgorpy100
Didn't work for me
I personally play Metroidvanias almost exclusively and this is the first gaming podcast I ever tried. I thought content was ok (ocassionally an interesting comment or context), but I listened to three episodes (Aria of Sorrow, Ender Lillies, Tunic or at least the public part) and in all three they just complained about the combat (or bosses) being too hard. I should probably have tried to find one game they liked to see what they're into. But if you want a podcast that complains about combat a lot, this one is for you. (Honestly, happy they're doing something that people like - just trying to give context to people who haven't listened yet).
Read more
OdedGu
A chore to listen to
Constant passive aggressiveness and a slog to listen to. Kaye is especially dry and boring but Gary’s pick me energy is even worse.
Dopetydopedope
Best Gaming Podcast
Love the vibes, love the host, and I loved watching them find their voices over the years.
CrossFtW
The best
Kay Ross is a boss and I luh that Gary Buh
mafoster101
Biting the Hand
This podcast has this really awesome feature where you can spend $200 to have them talk about your favorite game and they will spend the whole episode complaining that they had to play it
hgjfd frjhf ddgb
Easily my fav game review show
Thoughtful and detailed analyses of both retro and more recent games. These guys are easily my favorite pod casting duo — check out this show and others they do on Duckfeed.tv. Their Baldur’s Gate 3 series (Real Lich Hours, season 1) was AMAZING and what initially got me hooked. Well worth your time!
SemperAudientis
deep, sharp, poignant, and my fave gaming pod
I listened to this podcast during cancer treatments because it pulled me in no matter how scattered I felt that day. Empathetic storytelling and intelligent analysis.
And I haven’t even played most of these games, :).
Soulaco
…
…
Jareditish
I hearthishow.
The best show about games. Detailed from experience in playing the game or lovin the lore. Comprehensive and never any needless sidebar giggling. Well adjusted and reasonable, Everything id expect from two adult nerds. I heart this show. Also, i think some bots or folks that dont listen, made some bad reviews. Such hateful poison. Im sorry. Dont listen to that garbage. Your very professional and its delightfully pleasant to listen to you two talk about games. Both gary and kole have wonderful voices. its pleasant listening. You do you Kay!
Read more
oinicknayme
The best podcast
A wonderful podcast. Many great hours have been spent listening. Curious what they think of Ron Gilbert’s new game.
SbEthan
Definition of Woke
These guys are just looking to be offended by anything that doesn’t align with their political views. They’re the definition of what’s wrong with people today
19mh87
Great show
I don’t think Gary has any idea what is cool or good. He constantly talks about the editor in him but if it was up to him he would edit the best stuff. Ff7 for example the giant snake impaled is nothing but awesome. Then he says the planetary stuff is bad which I’ve never heard anyone say or complain about. The dude says a lot of stuff like it’s concrete and most of it is opinion. He will say stuff like “ I’m trying to think of things objectively “ where it doesn’t even relate. Besides that I still love his deep take on games but opinion and objectively are not the same thing.
Read more
Certified Eric
Great show
I repeatedly listen to the episodes on RE and Silent Hill games. Love the show
EddieM1993
Feels good man
I’ve found this comedy show very entertaining for years. Looking forward to Gary “stepping on [my] God damned neck” due to his inability to process alternative worldviews.
wutreviews33
Cringy at times
“This feels like something I should be offended by” is a real statement from one of the hosts. This was one them wanting to be offended by the Japanese accents in Tenchu, only to find out that they are voiced by Japanese actors….That should give you some insight into their character.
AngelasDong
FIREBALLZ
Y’allQaeda and Vanilla ISIS upset over empathy for different people. Also, water is wet.
J Dermen
Excellent show
Thorough game analysis that goes further into the philosophy of culture in our lives, and always from a place of respect and solidarity for human rights. Essential and necessary.
1988abe
cool show, weird reviews?
show is great but what the actual heck are these reviews? i’m just here for the games discussion
retrokid104
Good podcast (but)
Bigots are mad that they support trans people which is an endorsement in itself
WOFF and Bonfireside Chat are both shows that are easy to listen to because the hosts are very funny and articulate and have a good chemistry together. I think my main problem with the podcast is that they are very good almost too kind critics when they discuss a game they like and very bad and unfair critics when they discuss a game they like. And because of the mercurial nature of Butterfield, there’s little consistency in their likes and dislikes. And what makes it worst for me is they are incredibly humorless and frankly a bit stuffy about receiving criticism about some of their insane takes.
Read more
Jill Lloyd Flanagan
This is interesting
Ooo another video game podcast that is nice to trans people like me and has hate in the comments. I know I’ll love this one :3
Cold Blooded Lord (she/her)
Marxist propaganda disguised as a gaming podcast
I came to this podcast form their bonfire side chat which is great but the ad way to many of their own politics in their podcast. If I wanted politics I’d listen to a political podcast I come to these podcasts for game discussions. Edit Dec 2024: even more woke than they were before. Pushing sick values and a “charity” that supports the mutilation of kids. Lol and he’s sooooo Butthurt and sad about the election lol what a bunch of soy boys
Read more
blowhardbillybob
Good podcast but
You should lead off with the trans kids alliance instead of ending the episode with that so those of us who have moral beliefs can choose to listen about video games elsewhere and not contribute to what we believe is evil
chip scranton
Watch out for soy boys
Gary is the soy king of progressive issues but left his cat with strangers to be put down. MAGA.
jukeboxhero1990
They raise money for gender affirming care of 10 year olds
I enjoyed the show at first but slowly their twisted ideology kept being brought up (by them). They donate money to a gender affirming group that, per their website offer gender affirming counseling to KIDS AS YOUNG AS TEN… disgusting. Let kids be kids.
Link_In_Love
Fair and Interesting takes and reviews
Great listen, and constant reminder of my rose colored glasses.
AJ4086
Whatch out for (fire) BALLS
Good show but, It says BALLS where are they I like slurping down c#m in my sleep and I need BALLS in my life to do this 4 stars-Gavin_chingchong_from_Asia kenkechow byeeeeeee 😘
SOMEBODY___ELSE
303 episode
Ah yes, my favorite game genre, ROUGE LIGHTS 💡also the most recent episode title made me have a stroke and tore my brain in half.
Man of the ratings
Consistently Entertaining
Been listening since 2014 and just realized I never wrote a review. Gary and Kole are good podcasters and good people. Glad to see them have the kind of success they’ve earned over the years. On a side note the Patreon really is good value, there are a ridiculous number of shows worth looking into in addition to WOFF. Thanks again guys.
MooseKnuckle28
I love the content from these guys!
Gary and Kole’s content is always enjoyable. They make games far more fun for me to play through for many reasons. They are such stand-up guys, and they add a satisfying amount of depth and breadth for the topics they cover. Even when I occasionally disagree with something one of them thinks, they’re just so pleasant to listen to.
S Johnson 419
It's very good
Highly recommend this and all of the other Duckfeed shows. Especially Everything to Guppy.
jackyjo237
Top Tier Deep Dives
Been listening for years, the hosts are great at what they do and keep things interesting. I enjoy learning and seeing the different perspectives they bring to the games they cover. One of the best gaming podcasts so check it out!
CyberneticGorilla
Mixed review?
I’m conflicted! I’ve listened to watch out for fireballs & duckfeed for years. These are two very intelligent, driven dudes! They also strive to be a socially conscious force for good. This might be their Achilles heel. They often preseverate on straw men from their hyper online existences. They are very resistant to criticism & build up odd excuses for harmless questions. Gary in particular has a kind of bloodthirsty bent towards people who don’t have the same politics as him. He talks about how he agrees with a death sentence for ppl & idk, it seems very emotional.
Read more
BellmerGynoid
Bin Laden fans
It’s an anti American manifesto of a podcast. pro Weather Underground pro Bill Ayers pro 9/11 pro Khalil Sheik Muhammad. Unless you agree with all the above and hate white ppl I’d not bother here. No hearts or minds are changed just an echo chamber of Bin Laden talking points for other Bin Laden fans.
TheBinApt22322
Unique Perspective on Games
Both Butterfield and Ross have unique tastes in games, at least from my perspective. They have helped me broaden my love of games and helped me to appreciate what makes games I normally would not play good and fun to others. I think that some of their criticisms could rub people the wrong way so maybe this podcast will be difficult for you to listen to if you have a hard time hearing people speak poorly of games you love. But if you’re interested in entering into a more critical discussion of games I think you will be benefited by their perspective. Also they are fun!
Read more
oxg89
Made me think about games in a new way
I’ve listened to these guys for a long time now and their angle of criticism has left a lasting mark on how I critique the games I play.
Even though I don’t always agree, I appreciate their thoughtfulness and now I examine what games are trying to do and what I like about games, personally.
Occasionally poignant, always funny and insightful.
alinktreetothepast
Skip
Like the concept, but the hosts are insufferable. Avoid at all costs. Yep yep.
EnricoPalazzo19
Insufferable
Best way to describe these two is “if you don’t agree with me, you’re unequivocally wrong”
greg7428953
My Favorite Way to Game Vicariously
Gary and Kole bring a thoughtful perspective to game reviews that balances critical analysis of gameplay and mechanics with insightful story discussion. Listening to WOFF! is a consistently enjoyable way to experience the games you never found the time to play, as well as revisit old favorites.
Yung Muckle
Crucial element of the next perspective
I subscribed to the Patreon for Bonfireside Chat and discovered this podcast, an excellent book club for games is how I look at it. They go through section by section and discuss specific elements and themes as well as the specifics in a way that you can picture the game in your minds eye! This is funny, comforting, and compelling and I love listening to it while playing games, driving, or before bed.
Best suggestion? If you’re still reading, look for a couple of your favorite games first, look for a game you know and give that episode a listen. I promise you’ll enjoy it.
-JustinZode
Read more
LordZode
Great Gaming Pod!
Love this show; so much back content to go through. Happy to be a Patreon supporter as well!
RadAdam111
95% great gaming podcast. 5% unbearable cultural takes
These guys are funny, passionate, knowledgeable and entertaining. They are also the type of intersectional critics that find fault with every facet of society because it’s probably built to support a white male hierarchy. If you can endure the random moments of vitriol that randomly erupt it might be your favorite podcast.
RonnieJ0930
Found through Resident Evil
I found WOFF while going through a phase of consuming any media I could about Resident Evil. It’s so nice to listen to Gary and Kole talk about games, and I love their sidebars about other games or media in episodes.
xoxo about 10 years too late
5.5 stars for being WOKE libs
glowlitas
Good
I like them
Fippolito9
Hardworkin’
Some hardworkin’ folks here and they take their content seriously. I appreciate that the episodes are structured and that they stick to it. They clearly put a lot of work into this network and it shows. Also, verbal confirmations like “uh-huhs” and such are critical elements of engaged conversations and it shows that the person is listening. Thank you for using verbal confirmations during a conversation.
Read more
The garlic Bastard
Not for me
Show summary: “Uh-huh. Yeah. Right. Yep. Liberal handwringing. Mmm hmm”. Hard pass.
Tim The Enchanter 3
Emotionally shallow host hides behind veil of articulating his words well
Just listened to 5 min the MGSV pod and my stomach hurts from laughing at the irony. The entire concept of Metal Gear is about the negative impact of nuclear weapons. Upwards of 270 thousand people lost their lives in Japan and all the one host is worried about is the sexism in the game. Nuclear fallout is yesterdays news I guess. Making sure every knows how YOU feel is so in. Just wanted to hear in depth analysis of a video game but instead we get this clown reiterating himself every 2 seconds about his feelings while berating the creator for the doing the same. I genuinely hate this podcast.
Read more
KyleinClyde
Great podcast!
I really like the way these guys recap the game in its entirety, to the point where they’ll do multiple episodes on one game. They have a good sense of humor, often making rather imaginative jokes (“Kangle- kangle telp —and we kicked him out of the office when he started making conversation”—Episode 288: Plants Vs. Zombies). Overall, I recommend listening to this podcast. Good stuff, and they give honest reviews on the games as well. Thumbs up, Gary and Kole!
Read more
Demos the Boss
I’m sorry
I left a review on everything to guppy to be funny but then I felt bad so I’m saying it here too. Happy birthday, Kole!
fartbutt9000
