One of my favorite podcasts. There has not been one episode that hasn’t made me laugh out loud or want me to do further research. ☺️

Edit: as sad as I am to see Paula go, I'm excited that Elaine has continued and can't wait to see how the show evolves! Elaine and Paula were a funny duo but Elaine by herself is equally as hilarious and at the same time - the stories continue to be in depth, scary and make you say, Wait, Whaaat? Love it and will continue to love it. I've been listening from the very start and I love Elaine and Paula! They are both hilarious in their own way and I love their different takes on the stories. I find myself interested in topics I normally wouldn't be interested in because of the way they tell it! My only criticism is sometimes they read straight from the article -I prefer when they put it in their own words!

Amazing Elaine, the yet undiscovered funny genius. Her voice is on the level of the best ASMR audible experiences. I can’t wait to hear what she has to share each week. 👻👽sphincter tingling funny.

Elaine and Paula, Oh my goodness! I am in AWE! I only just started listening to you guys a few months ago and I can’t stop! You don’t get a lot of chances to listen to creepy or strange stories that make you laugh out loud! I am incredibly happy that I found this podcast and I really feel like I am right there in the studio with you! One of the things I love most about you two are how supportive and open-minded you are about everything. I like how you don’t believe every single story is legit. Most things I watch or listen to either have people who are strong skeptics or they believe everything, even if there is a completely reasonable explanation for it. You keep an open mind, but are ready to find an explanation and I appreciate that!! Every day I listen to Wait, Whaaat! when I’m doing chores or drawing for my comic and it is just truly outstanding how you can change creepy into chuckles without completely changing the mood. I look forward to listening to you more!! Cheers! -Sam

I am friends with one of the host’s daughter. I mentioned that I listen to a lot of podcasts and she told me about this show. I’m really glad she did. I wound up listening to 10 episodes over the last 2 days. It’s a lot like My Favorite Murder, but the hosts are more realistic and the content is interesting and fun. Totally binge worthy.

Love it. So far I’ve gotten goose bumps at least once an episode. I was listening on stitcher but the volume seems a little low. Also would be nice to get a mic on feet so we can hear her too Update: I’m almost caught up. I deny myself a few episodes just so I can binge. I just joined their patreon and I’m so excited for all the bonus content!

So glad I found this podcast! I love the topics but I love their banter and tangents the most!

I am so happy I found you ladies on TikTok because you’ve become my favorite podcast to listen to and I count down the days til Friday when a new episode comes out. For anyone interested in paranormal, supernatural, aliens, etc., mixed in with hilarity and a great friendship dynamic, this is your show! I listen on my walks and I end up laughing out loud and people give me weird looks. (Also love how there is an Italy reference in like every episode haha!) Keep up the amazing work!!!!

I have loved getting into this podcast! It’s a nice break from my typical true crime genre. Instagram somehow connected me with Wait, Whaaat?! and I took the plunge to try a few episodes and now I really look forward to them each week! I find your friendship and back and forth so similar to ours and the stories super interesting and informative. I love creepy stuff but wouldn’t have ever thought to explore a podcast of that genre. Do you guys have any episodes about witches?! We LOVE anything having to do with halloween and witches. Keep up the awesome work! WHO AMONG US?! -Rachael

I’m not even into weird stories but I stumbled upon your first Baggin on Baggins and laughed so hard that now I tune in every week. It feels like hanging out with my hilarious girlfriends!! Side note-just found out the Muffin Man is real, can you do an ep on him?? (And the Milk Man)

I’m sorry it’s taken me so long to write a review I’m really bad with technology but I finally figured out how!! This is the first podcast I’ve actually liked and binged. I tried to expand my horizons with other podcasts but I just keep coming back to you guys. I love how funny you both are and thank you for your hard work!! ❤️❤️

I LOVE these women. They are so hilarious and their stories are amazing.

Love Paula and Elaine Super funny and smart!! I'm a fan forever!! Keep up the GREAT work ladies!

I’ve become podcast obsessed in the past year and stumbled across this pod via TikTok (my other new obsession). Halfway through my first episode, I knew I found a keeper. HILARIOUS and super fascinating. This is a binge-worthy pod I can’t get enough of!

Globally significant masterpiece of creative genius! the hosts are hilarious and totally remind me of me and my best friend bantering and joking around, so listening to them is like sitting around a campfire with your stoned group of friends, having profound conversations and junk food.

Look forward to every new episode!

So I actually found out about your podcast on tiktok. I’ve been listening every day at work since Wednesday and I’m fixing start episode 6. I love it! Funny, scary, and fun facts! DON’T LOOK AT MY PEOPLE HOLES 😂😂😂 y’all are hilarious

I have been listening to this podcast during my commutes to and from work. And so far, I haven't been able to stop. I always learn something new and get a good laugh out of it too! I highly recommend giving this podcast a listen. You will love the topics, their witty and funny responses, and the way they can curate an entertaining and engaging atmosphere from start to finish!!

Really great show, love the hosts and episode content, give it a listen guys!

Who's out here picking up hitchhikers? My luck I would pick up a ghost hitchhikers too haha :) Great podcast with such intriguing stories! I fully support this podcast!

Elaine & Paula are so much fun to listen to!! They are always finding some pretty rad stuff to chat about and it always feels like they are sitting right there with you. Elaine is hilarious with an awesome laugh and Paula my goodness is someone I want to have over to crack up with. They find some stories you may know and tons you haven’t heard of! They love their listeners and are so involved and respond to all their listeners on social media! Hugs ladies and keep rock’n it!

I have to say the first time my husband got in the truck and heard your podcast was hilarious. I was listening to you guys talk about anal abscesses on episode 23 and he says, “What the f—- are you listening to?” Omg yes. I love you girls. You’re the best.

These ladies CRACK ME UP while also covering some really interesting stories. The perfect podcast for your daily commute or a road trip. You’ll be laughing and saying...wait, what?!!!

Combining lightheartedness and supernatural subjects is a popular idea, but many shows struggle with the balance. That is not the case with the Wait, Whaaat podcast. It excels with an easygoing nature led by energetic and humorous pair of hosts. Beyond that, who doesn’t like hearing about the supernatural? Like and subscribe!

I love the chemistry between Paula and Elaine. I love their voices and their humor. It makes me want to hang out with them. I listened to episode 9 and I got a little spooked out. Great show!

These two are a funny combination, and the stories! Funny! Keep up the humor!

Love the show and the range of topics. The hosts have great chemistry, I found myself laughing quite a bit. But also well researched and cool facts. Highly recommended!

I love listening to you two. Such a fun show!

You two are funny to listen too! Hope you get lots of listeners!