Reviews
via Podcasts
Insightful but political
Alas, I remember the days when Alan’s terrific blog had the rule of no politics in the comments. Glad this pod exists, but your mileage may vary, as the hosts take a very distinct view.
DDA321
Hype
Hope this podcast breaks out
Holysquall
Entertaining and thoughtful
These TV critics are deservedly well-regarded and the podcast is well worth your time (consider checking out their Patreon to support them and get bonus content). It’s always interesting and valuable to hear insights from these professionals to enrich my understanding of good TV (and their discussion of Gilligan’s Island was fun and raised hopes that they’ll occasionally cover other pre-prestige TV rerun staples that live rent-free in my Gen X brain like the Brady Bunch).
Read more
KateDanielsMercyHauptman
Two of the Best to Do It - Do It!
Alan and Kathryn are two all-timers in the tv criticism game, but more importantly, in the TV talk game as well. And their podcast is a real Goldilocks of a gem. Enough structure to make it feel cohesive and not just a random hodgepodge every week, but not so much structure that fun and surprise are leached out of the effort. A joy to hang with Alan and Kathryn every week!
Tosy and Cosh
*So* Good
I follow exactly one weekly podcast and it’s this. Delightful.
butch-el
Appointment Podcasting!
You could not ask for better experts to guide you through TV’s past and present. Such a joy, so enlightening, and always surprising — hope they make more episodes than “The Simpsons.”
theduke86
Love These Two
I love Alan & Kathryn. I’m excited they’re starting a podcast together.
Tracinator1
THANK GOODNESS
TV is good, Kathryn is good (Alan you’re good too), I am now also good because this show exists 👍
kjohm
So great to have Alan back in my podcast feed.
I’ve been a huge fan of all of Alan’s previous pods, going all the way back to Firewall and Iceberg. The same familiar banter is back with this one, and he vibes really well with his cohost, Kathryn. I’ll definitely be tuning in each week!
Ggfdxvv
Is TV good?
TV IS good!
Jerome Cusson
Love these two
These are two of my favorite tv writers, and I’m so excited to have them on a podcast together.
AndrewVance
