These two put no thought or research into Diane Schuler case.

This podcast is great! I love listening to ya boys John and Jamie while I’m mowing my yard or out for a jog. They present cases that are clearly researched and deliver the facts.

I gave this podcast five stars because I couldn’t give it ten. Informative, yet entertaining.

I really enjoy the mix between high profile and lesser known cases. And I love True Crime To-Go. Great idea!

Thanks for doing the story on my babies and Alyssa Dayvault. -Chris

Big fan of the podcast I listen to you guys at work. I want to talk about the Buford T Pusser episode. I feel like the time and money spent on these cases should be spent on solving current cases. I know older cases deserve to be reviewed. Am I wrong for thinking this. Plus I from Nebraska do you have any Nebraska cases in the works

I’ve been listening for a few years now after first hearing yall on Talk Is Jericho, and I’ve been hooked ever since. I usually put it on while I’m gaming or driving, and it always makes the time fly by. I’ll definitely be subscribing to Patreon soon to support y’all. Was wondering if yall ever covered the disappearance of Jason Landry—I’m from the college town where he went to school, and there’s been some talk about new evidence. Hopefully it’s true so his family can get some answers. Keep doing what you’re doing—the show just keeps getting better!

I’ve been listening for years and don’t know why it took so long to leave a review! I really appreciate the respectful way that stories and cases are shared and would love to see you guys cover the unsolved murder of Tawnya Dawn Knight from our small rural town of Spring Hill, Kansas, with the same reverence I’ve heard you honor other victims.

They are easy to listen to and this is the first True Crime podcast I have found that the hosts are open about their faith. This is something that I appreciate and is hard to find. Thank you for what you do and the compassion you show to each victim and case.

These two fellas are learning their way through this content as you listen to the podcast. Mispronunciations, high school level research, etc. Reading Wikipedia is more compelling. Pass.

Really? Ads on precision shooting. Loved this podcast but poor choice. And yes I’m a gun owner but really?!

Hi my name is Brandon and this one episode is very hard but very good. You guys are amazing and thank you both of you for taking care kids. I have three of my own you make the world better. Nothing but love. Thank you so much

I’m a Patreon sub, but still wanted to leave a 5-Star review. I did reach out to you on X with a correction on the Owen Hart story, but haven’t heard the correction mentioned on a show. I first heard you guys on Talk is Jericho and absolutely had to start listening to this podcast! Keep up the great work!

Have listened since the beginning and love the podcast. I am not a big fan of the newer interviews. The Grant Solomon episodes were a little weird. It’s like they jumped on one side without any real reason to. In my opinion there was not enough evidence to smear the name of a father of a deceased son.

Love! Have been listening on IHeart for years but wasn’t able to leave a review. Found on apple & wanted to leave a note. Love listening to you both. Great podcast!

I love the tone of both podcasters. They speak with clarity and empathy, thank you.

Oh poor tesla 🤪. Muskrat is THE welfare baby of the US.

I have been listening to this show for years. As many listeners before have notated I first heard you on Pod is Jericho. I love your story telling and how you never glorify the crime. You also keep it as clean as you possibly can while still talking about some horrendous acts. I would love to hear you all cover the Molly Corbett and Tom Martens case in the murder of Mollys husband Jason in Winston Salem NC. Thanks for considering and keep up the great work!

Been enjoying listening to you guys for the last several years now. I believe the Rob Chaulk case with Chris Jericho was my introduction. I’ve got a good case suggestion for y’all right out of my neck of the woods; Ronald Gene Simmons from near Dover, Arkansas. Love the content, keep it up!

Typically love to listen and still many stars, but I was a little embarrassed for you with all the mispronounced city names. I get that it’s easy to do, but it was obviously confusing for you at times by the pauses. I would hope next time you could research how to pronounce city names (that doesn’t include the struggles with the victims names). I never post reviews but this was pretty bad in my eyes.

Just found this podcast through the “Or No” collab and so glad I did. I love their story telling, they do a wonderful job! Can’t wait to catch up! Kiley from PrimeTimeKrime

Would’ve given you 5 stars, but you said Tennessee is known for mediocre football, so I deducted a couple.

I love listening to John and Jamie! They do a great job researching and covering these cases and it shows that they really care about what they’re talking about and are just awesome people behind the mic as well! Keep it up!

This podcast came highly recommended and it did not disappoint!

I have been listening to this podcast since 2018 when I made my long drives from Columbus to Cleveland and it's been my favorite show ever since! I now listen on my way to and from work, and the true crime to-go's are perfect for my shorter drives around town. I'd love for you guys to cover the case of Carnell Sledge and Katherine Brown! It's been unsolved for 5 years. Thank you both for all the hard work you put into making these awesome episodes!!

Jamie and John do an excellent job telling true crime stories! I have been binging from the start and am up to Aug 2022! My favorite episode was Michael Malloy. Sad story, but loved the commentary about the alcohol and needing to find new friends.

Amazing podcast! Came back to edit my review because you finally changed the theme music again and it is SO MUCH BETTER. Thank you so much! You’re right, it’s much more you guys than the cheesy 80’s cop show music 😂 Great job, keep up the good work!

Me and my friends listen to you guys every night on a call. We always enjoy all of your episodes.

I started listening to y'all after hearing you on Talk is Jericho and have been appreciative ever since. Love every episode and y’all are in my regular pod rotation. I especially love anytime you guys do an episode involving conspiracy and/or paranormal involvement! Keep up the awesome work and know it’s appreciated!

These two present their episodes keeping the victims and their families in mind. No glory to the perpetrators. After listening a bit, you feel as if they could be your neighbors. Give them a listen, you’ll thank me later. 😉

I love this podcast. Technically I listen on Spotify….I started listening to it when I was working on my BSW a few years ago and remember being excited to learn that John was also a social worker and that Jamie has had foster kids. I love the dynamic between John and Jamie and the respectful way they talk about the cases they cover. I think it’s great that they take time to process the information and explore it and not just in the sensationalized way that a lot of other podcasters talk about the crimes. It is clear just by listening the amount of empathy and respect the guys have for the individuals they are discussing. I’ve recently started listening to their other podcast Bless Their Hearts and feel like I’m hanging out with old friends but I guess I should save this for a review of that podcast lol. Thanks guys for a true crime podcast that is informative and interesting without being gratuitous.

Love to hear John and Jamie’s takes on cases. I appreciate how they focus on victims and don’t glamorize perpetrators. I also like the banter they share. Highly recommend!

I especially love “True Crime To-Go.” Keep up the great work!

This is the one podcast I cannot wait for! I look forward to the weekly release. Host are real and relatable. Thank you

You guys are so great! I love your down to earth style and the way you tell your stories gets me hooked to listening!!

These guys do a great job telling stories and adding in their own commentary. They’re very thorough and add their own special twist. Run, don’t walk, to listen to them!!

I have been a listener for almost 5 years and a Patreon supporter for almost the same amount of time. I look forward to your episodes each week and love listening to your take on the stories. Thanks for being awesome!

I have been listening to this podcast since the very first episode that they did on Talk is Jericho. After hearing the way the present each episode, I was hooked! Now I listen to Bless Their Hearts and I binged Paradigm! Phenomenal shows in their own right! I feel like I know John and Jamie, but I’ve never met them! I think a great collaboration would be True Crimecast and Generation Why! We need to make that happen! I feel like their content delivery is really similar! Keep up the great work gentlemen!

Hello found this podcast from talk is Jericho been listening for over a year and never looked back. Enjoy the way they talk about the case not going into graphic details as much but all in all very great content. I would also like to ask Jamie for any advice about your adoption process you went through and advice you have for me and my wife on going through the process. Have bless day and thank you for the content needs to be 10 out of 10 Jamie was great in his advice for adopting as well really enjoy the show and now me my wife listen together

Everyday I walk my dog I listen to Truecrime! It makes the time go so fast and it's like taking a walk with 2 old friends. I LOVE the way they tell the stories- respectful and nonjudgmental. I'm anxious for each episode! Keep up the GREAT work!

Hey guys, my name is Brandon and I’m from northwest Indiana and I’m a route driver for a vending machine company. I heard about your podcast on Talk Is Jericho. I’ve only been listening for a few months but I feel like I’ve known you two for years! I’m currently bingeing every episode from the beginning (and doing the same with Bless Their Hearts) and it’s really helping me get through the days. I have family down in the mammoth cave/cave city area and really enjoy taking trips down there. Big fan of you guys and what you’re doing helping unsolved cases be solved and I can’t wait to see where your shows go in the future! Hope you and your families had a great Christmas and new years!

It takes me about an hour to get to work in the mornings and an hour to get back home in the evenings. I look forward to the drive so that I can listen to True Crime cast. Now that I am caught up I’m looking forward to exploring your other work. Thank you for carpooling with me each day. You should look into the Utah, Megan Huntsman, 7 baby deaths.

I love this show!! Have been listening for years & once I started my own true crime podcast I have started using this one for research on cases! Jamie and John are always so respectful & give great insight into the details of the cases!! Truly a treasure! With love, Crimes and Cannabis 💚💚

Easy to listen to, these 2 guys are fabulous. Interesting topics. I really enjoy this podcast.

I love listening to John and Jaime! Respectfully done cases every time, with the right amount of banter. Definitely a podcast worthy of 5 stars. Keep up the good work guys!

There are many True Crime podcasts out there, but True Crimecast is my go to. John and Jamie deliver the goods. Their episodes are well researched and well written, and are presented in good taste with respect to the victims. I have been going back and listening to episodes about notorious criminals in preparation for the Halloween season. However, I could not find one for David Parker Ray aka The Toybox Killer. If you haven’t already done an episode, I hope you guys add him to your list. Cheers, and Happy Halloween!

This is one of the very first True Crime podcasts I listened to and these 2 guys continue to be my favorite. Awesome variety of cases and their chemistry as friends is so enjoyable to listen to. Keep doin’ what you’re doin’! 😊

Don’t bother, filled with inaccuracies that a simple google search could have remedied.

I just finishing listing to every episode starting from the start! Great True Crime Podcast that has been added to my weekly rotation. I love the small town stores they cover, especially ones from Harlan Kentucky due to my family being from there and those stories rarely get covered. Thanks for all your hard work and dedication!

Started listening to this podcast at work, best crime podcast I’ve listened to, listening to it is the best way for me to pass the time. Could you guys do the case of Darlene Hulse it's a cold case from my hometown!