Mike and Gibby are the best. Great research, conversations and jokes.

Love you guys so much!! Keep up the great work and keep your own time tickin 💜💜💜

I normally do not like listening to unsolved cases, but it is something about them that made me change my mind. Love this podcast so much.

This differs a bit from the regular TCATT…it’s a bit more deliberate and low key. There is less levity and humor but it suits the subject matter. After all, these are unsolved crimes. Also, there is generally a more investigative element which requires that you pay attention to the details. I admit that it took me a few episodes to get into it as much as the regular TCATT but it is well worth it.

Can’t express how much I love listening to you guys. I’m 63 and got my love for true crime when I was around 11.. I remember buying true crime magazines and was just so fascinated.. flash forward 50+ years and more obsessed than ever.. I’ve read so many books and watched so many documentaries. Your true crime podcast is by far the best.. I took a road trip to the state of Washington from California.. and for the 13 hours I drove you guys were with me!! Thanks for being the best there is!!! Alicia Ramirez

I love you guys and I’m so glad y’all have done an episode on the Houston Lovers’ Lane murders. These horrific murders happened just outside my husband’s childhood neighborhood, and I now work down the street from the location of the murders. Even 30 years later, it’s a well known story for people that grew up at that time on the west side of Houston.

I love listening to Mike and Gibby! They have such great chemistry with each other as hosts and they do a great job covering these cases in an insightful and respectful way. Keep up the great work guys and thank you for all that you do!

This show is great. The hosts are funny while still showing respect to the victims. What I love most about this show is that they tackle the lesser known cases

These guys do a fantastic job! Feels like listening to friends telling you a story.

Great podcast! I am a True fan of both TCATT and Unsolved - love both Mike’s - There is no “I” in team so we need you both. I was not familiar with your latest episode on Unsolved “The Pimlico Poisoning “ but I have to say there were laugh out loud moments throughout that brought me to tears- your dialogue is hysterical! Keep up the great job and we’ll keep listening and laughing 😂. Thank you guys and stay safe and keep your own time ticking..

The most off-putting thing about these hosts is that they’ll regularly guilt trip listeners saying Pateon subscribers have tapered off. It can get a little frustrating considering they have 3 podcasts combined. 2 that only differ in solved vs unsolved, and the third being one Not-Gibby Mike does with another person. It’s called criminology. The cases are interesting buuuuut nowhere does Not-Gibby Mike explain why he does an entire other identical podcast in addition to the true crime podcast he does with Gibby. It gets old hearing them pander for subs. Seems pretty obvious that there’s a limited number of people who will pay to listen to 3 identical formatted podcasts 🙃🙃

Love the show! I have listened to all of True Crime All the Time and now and working my way through Unsolved. I love the humor of Mike and Gibby. I also appreciate the fact that they don’t use f-bombs like some other podcasts. You guys are awesome!

I listen to a LOT of true crime podcasts, and this is my favorite duo period. Funny, factual, insightful…I can go on and on. It’s a pleasure to listen to these friends talk cases. They each contribute something unique, and the podcast wouldn’t be the same without either one. For anyone who wants an amazing true crime listen, this is it. Stay safe and keep your own time ticking! (I always wanted to say that.)

Just as fantastic as the original TCATT! The fact that these cases are unsolved add so much to the interesting and creepy. If you like a good mystery, give this podcast a try.

I love these guys. They're always knowledgeable about the case they're discussing and keep it interesting enough to follow along.

Legit cannot get enough of this podcast. The best thing to listen to around!

Come on guys do your research. I have read every book and listen to every podcast on Natalie woods death. You guys aren’t even close first of all Natalie‘s third Oscar nomination was for love with the proper Stranger, not sex and the single girl second, there was no wine bottle in the dinghy. Where did you hear that third RJ did not have a speedboat. They were only two boats, the dinghy and the yacht. I stopped listening to you guys after that so I don’t know how many more mistakes you made you need to read Suzanne Finstead book, the autobiography of Natalie, Wood, and Sam Perrone’s book brainstorm oh, and by the way, brainstorm was not filmed in Rome It was filmed in Raleigh North Carolina.

Is a liar

I’m a home health nurse, sometimes I have 1-2 hour drives to see patients so having this entertainment while driving is priceless.

Best podcast ever! My all time favorite!

Great hosts, great stories, great podcast!

Best thing about you guys is you don’t speak in monotone or use a computer voice. I hate monotone speakers because they make a good topic boring, like listening to that one high school teacher you hate listening to because they are flat, no emotion at all, and computer voices are worse. The banter between you two makes some of these topics easier to listen as some of the things people do to people are horrific. Great job guys!

You do a pretty decent job covering the different cases. Unlike many other true crime podcasts I like how you do a good job sticking to the case at hand and don’t get lost in off topic banter.

How do u make it podcast on apple podcast

I love both original TCAT and Unsolved! Mike and Gibby’s mixture of humor with seriously dark subject matter paired with real person insight has drawn me in - keep it up!!!!

These two talk about themselves constantly. They seem nice but it is dull. If you are interested in the traditional podcast guys chattering about their personal lives and opinions then you may like it. At least they don’t do the raucous laughter thing. I could not get through an episode.

Ugh. Could barely get through the first episode. This is just awful. Gibson adds nothing to the show.

In searching for true crime mystery podcasts, I listened to a few others first. Y’all are way more interesting and entertaining in the way you tell the story. Most importantly, your voices aren’t annoying to me! I know this sounds silly but I get tired of podcasts where the host speaks 100 miles per hour and doesn’t have a pleasant speaking voice. I’ve really enjoyed listening and am a new fan of your show. Keep being yourselves with your wonderful personalities combined with the extensive knowledge you piece together r in the perfect order for a perfect show. Thank you.

Thanks for the show! It rocks! I'm gaining an appreciate of unsolved cases even though my natural inclination is to like justice.

I absolutely adore the way the straight facts are given and how compassionate Mike and Gibby are towards the victims. Great job, guys!

Love this podcast

I found TCATT about a year and a half ago and listened to all several hundred episodes of both TCATT and TCATT Unsolved. Listening to Mike and Gibby feels like listening to your two friends tell an interesting story. They are respectful of victims and their families but still find a way to add levity and humor. I love that they find cases many others haven’t covered, and they frequently share what they have learned from the experiences of other listeners which is cool. Keep up the good work guys

Mike and Gibby do a wonderful job . They are also very funny which helps you when you are listening about all the horrible things that happened . I highly recommend their podcast .

Ferguson comes off like AM radio host, but does convey some information. Gibson is a nothing, offers nothing, pointless.

I have listened to you guys from the beginning. Love your show.

My favorite and only people I will listen to are Mike and Gibby. I was born and raised in Ohio and lived close to Spinning Hills. Your Pod casts keep me on track and able to get through my work day. I can’t choose who I like better and actually change depending on the episode. Soooo I developed my own catch phrase I am team M&M for Mike and Mike and because it is my favorite candy . I keep my head in a swivel. Keep up the great work and love that you are respectful and tell us about the victims not just their untimely deaths.

I’m Team TCATT! Love both Mike & Gibby! You guys are the absolute best ever! I discovered you about 5 months ago and have listened to every single episode . Just started this week listening to unsolved, and I’m loving it as well. Looking forward to getting through all the episodes on this one, keep up the good work guys!

best podcast in ohio

Love listening to you.

Thank you for the clear and passionate reporting on the lives of the victims of crime and the survivors, as well as the beasts that torment them.

I’ve been listening for about 2 years now. Love the dynamic, the information, the cases they pick. One of my favorite true crime pods out there. Minimal off topic chatter, like barely any ever. Mike & Gibby seem like great people.

One of the only true crime podcasts I continually come back to! The stories are always well told and interesting, and Mike and Gibby are two of my favorite podcasts hosts because their friendship is fun to listen to!

You guys are awesome, appreciate a good podcast. Only downside is falling asleep and having to trace back my previous place in episode. My husband still doesn’t know how this is my preferred sleepy time magic, but you guys make this listening experience super chill, and I totally recommend y’all to anyone who doesn’t want to listen to high pitch madness and can enjoy the curiosity that comes with true crime. Thank you!

I discovered this two months ago and have been binging it almost exclusively ever since. Really like Mike and Gibby’s personalities and feel like I’ve gotten to know them!

All around great podcast and story telling

I enjoy listening to the podcast as it is one of my go-to podcasts. I admit the research involved in trying to cover cases and comparing that to what some of us have come across in years of following a case is entirely different. Very challenging. Howerver, I wrote a review on 01 June 2018 regarding research on the Colonial Parkway Murders. And now I'm seeing the same situation come up again. And it is this: There are some that believe there is no one common killer(s) in the Colonial Pkwy Murders. And IF that is true, in this area of Virginia there is some belief that the murders of Winans/Williams is very similiar to the first set of the CP murders - Kathy Thomas/Rebecca Dowski. One connection is that it is believed a common person involved - a park ranger. Whether the ranger is involved is one thing, but the details of the two crimes are very similar. Thanks for your episodes and keep up the good work.

Mike and Gibby are the best! Their banter helps take the edge off of the subjects.

Amazing podcast. Great work

I was listening to the latest episode about Georgette Bauerdorf and the location sounded SO familiar. Who knew that I lived directly across LaCienega for 10 years, with my balcony facing that apartment building. I do so love TCATT and Unsolved. As a coroner I think hearing the stories of these cases makes me better at my job.

I love what you guys do. Your a good team and the show benefits from it. Keep ‘em coming fellas.