First time listener and it took over 7 minutes into the show before the actual content even started.

I left and came back to this pod as it is good but can’t…after every statement, sentence or pause that is made Kevin has to comment or make some sort of noise…hmmm…and it gets distracting!!

Hailey does great research and script writing, and Kevin is a perfect sounding board. I love their “what are you drinking” segment at the beginning, cause it feels like we’re all there together. The opening music is in the top 5 of podcast intro songs for me (honestly might be top 3). The energy is light spook, so if you’re looking for a real thriller, this isn’t the right energy, but it’s got such cozy vibes. My favorite episode is the one about the Black Forest Haunting; for whatever reason, this one really gave me the chills.

Great stories told in a way that keeps you on the edge of your chair! Keep up the great storytelling Hailey and Kevin!

Hailey and Kevin are so endearing, and the storytelling by Hailey seriously keeps me on the edge of my seat. Definitely worth a listen! (Try the Skinwalker Ranch episodes, I went down a rabbit hole after those…👽🤣)

Love the podcast! Great topics, and genuine heart.

Never miss an episode :) I love how the stories are delivered. I’ve heard a couple of the stories from other podcast but you guys deliver it the best! Seriously. Don’t ever stop ;)

This is such a fantastic podcast. Hailey does the best job storytelling making each one very easy to listen to. You can tell she has done her extensive research…so much respect for the way she lays out each episode. Kevin’s reactions are great. Love the little bits of humor thrown in as well. Keep it up guys! I can’t stop listening :)

This is not your typical crime or supernatural podcast ladies and gents. Hailey and Kevin do a fantastic job of mixing up their themes and topics. Hailey reviews the facts, lays out the story and discloses the conspiracies and theories. This one’s sprinkled with light hearted humor. Give it a listen!

I found this pod at the recommendation of a friend. I have binged all 12 episodes in a matter of a few days. This podcast is very well done and super interesting to listen to. Most podcasts when they are new aren't very polished and clunky but this one from episode one sounded like its been on the air for years. I can’t wait to hear more!

I like how doozy it is

Binged the first five episodes and really enjoying this podcast! 😃

I love the detail, the respect for and the background information on the victims, the pacing, the extra dialogue, the feel good fact, the drinks…this is a masterpiece.

This is your bro! Cannot stop listening to these doozies of stored, and I’m looking forward for to come!! Keep up the great work!

Hailey - This is your mom! I love you too! Excellent first show! I was captivated by the story and by you and Kevin! Great job! Can’t wait for the next! Just listened to Episode 3! Crazy stuff!! Great job!

Hi it’s your sister in law.. YOU GUYS ARE AMAZING!!! This was done so well and I enjoyed listening so much! Kev is so funny 😂 KEEP DOING THEM PLEASE!!!!!!!!!

Hailey and Kevin are hilarious and fun to listen to! Love love love this podcast ❤️

I love true crime and mysteries! I had never heard of the shark arm case. Love that y’all tell about the case but also keep it light and funny! Can’t wait to hear more.

Such a fun podcast to listen to and learn about unsolved mysteries or whatever new thing pops up. Love this couple and their unique, intelligent banter. Creative, historical, and even a bit spooky. Well done!

Love the “unscripted” banter … love the details of the story and the natural way you tell a story! Can’t wait for the next episode—P.S. not your moms!

Hailey and Kevin are so much fun to listen to!