Reviews
via Podcasts
The superpower? He's a teacher
I enjoy this show a lot. My favorite thing is that Greg is a music teacher. I'm pretty ignorant about music, and he does a great job explaining musical concepts.
robertbohl
Wonderful
It’s hard to believe that you can get two people talking about a 2 1/2 minute song for 1 1/2 hours, and have it be entertaining. And yet it is.
SlickRickDude
So great for a TMBG fan
Greg’s ability to connect with all of his cohosts is a gift. The commentary is fun, thoughtful, informative, spontaneous, and entertaining. I’m very interested in seeing his final scores at the end of the tour.
Shacklebolt30
Fellowship of TMBG
Apart from my immediate family, life as a TMBG fan has been mostly a solitary pursuit. It’s like a breath of fresh air to have somehow even found my way here to this podcast. It’s a small miracle, really. Each day there are wee victories for this old school/pre-internet era gal, and this is one of them. I’m thankful for all the hard work and creative energy that is poured into the making of each episode. I have only listened to a few so far, but I am sincerely enjoying what I’m hearing. I’m glad to have found a landing pad to camp out on where my favorite band and their incredible body of work is debated and celebrated! This is not such a solitary pursuit after all. Not to put too fine a fine point on it, I am Thankful!
Read more
WBeeDee
Best. Theme Song. Ever.
I have heard a lot of TMBG’s music videos, but that gave me a clear understanding of their theme song for Mickey Mouse Clubhouse. #playhousedisneyera
5194270
Ohhhhhh, Definition of good; Greg Simpson’s podcast about tmbg.
Anyone who thinks they know a better podcast, put your hand on the computer and cast that podcast to the wind. Even after every clam has been baked, this podcast will go on. Greg is an amazing host and his guests are amazing guests. So what a are you waiting for? Put your hand on the computer, turn your hearing aid back on, and you’ll have to admit that it’s your podcast now.
ndhs bdbffbgsbkt
Excellent
Very enjoyable
cool dude11225387
Far from Reprehensible
Really enjoy Greg’s style. He spends time talking about the band with an ever changing list of colorful and varied co-hosts. His style highlights his love of the music and real appreciation for the people he talks with. It’s irreverent, but the tangents highlight his love and appreciation for the people that guest on the show. Regarding the comments other reviews have made on cover songs... I personally love that he looks for opportunities to feature other fans’ covers. He has opinions, but they seem far from harsh. He seems pretty inclusive to me. Sensitive much people?!?
Speaking as a long time TMBG fan that has been a fan in isolation (I can’t seem to find anyone else around where I live that are fans), it’s nice to have this conduit to share my love of the band. The podcast has made me think on and appreciate songs I haven’t given enough time to study. What more can a fan ask for? And jeez, there are other podcasts out there about this band too!!! It is truly a great time to love TMBG!!!
Read more
KyFifer
ONDINE
Hey ya - been a dedicated fan for about 30 years.
I have maybe an interesting angle to discuss on a show — in all those hundreds of songs, my favorite is a b-side that nobody cares about, Ondine.
I remember showing up for shows in the 90’s wearing a Nixon mask and holding up a handmade sign that said “Ondine”. The guys were just confused because... who does that? Lol. I had fun though!
Barndoor1
jaden
You should try to get the rapper Open Mike Eagle on the show, TMBG is his favorite band
Senorfattykins
Tom Dunford
Really enjoyed the episodes with Tom Dunford from the Boston area! Keep him on, you guys have a great repore.
Rocopen
Great Podcast
If you’re a fan of They Might Be Giants, then you will certainly enjoy this podcast. It is great to hear people talk about what they love about this band. Every episode gets better and better. If you are a fan of They Might Be Giants, sit back and listen. And if you are not, then you really need to think about the choices you’ve made in your life.
Huffing Dry Paint Cans
So fun
The personal nature of this podcast is just so endearing. If you want to hear someone read you the wiki for two hours, go find one of the other TMBG podcasts. Greg and his guests get personal about the band and gather facts along the way and it’s really fun to listen to. Hearing a different fan talk to the host every time makes keeps it so fresh, and reminds me just how special the fan base of the band is. I am loving this podcast. The production is great too.
Read more
sn0rb
Fun and addictive
I like the personal takes on TMBG and the interpretations of songs from so many different fans. Its interesting to hear how people got into TMBG and what their music has meant to them. It’s a fun and entertaining podcast for TMBG fans.
otherdrworm
Talking TMBG
I love hearing people talk about the Johns and their music, and there’s a lot to say. Sometimes they go off on tangents but you get to learn about other topics and more about the host and his guests. Other podcasts may spend more time going in depth about the music and lyrics, but with this one you get guests and covers and good ole insanity. Listen. Do it now.
spejampar
Promising concept, poor execution
When I saw there was a podcast breaking down a different They Might Be Giants song every episode I thought "what an idea"! There's so much to talk about with any TMBG song; unreliable narrators, wordplay, cultural references, unique arrangements... you really could break down any of them for an hour. What we have instead is a podcast where the host spends half an episode going off on totally irrelevant tangents with guests, discusses the song itself in depth for a few minutes on average, plays and criticizes amateur cover versions, cites outright incorrect information instead of doing research on basic facts about the band, and laughs at his own jokes (think Jimmy Fallon interviewing). But the thing that really pushed me to write this review is that some of the potentially most interesting episodes, like ones where actual TMBG members were interviewed, are behind a paywall and not available on iTunes. That seems backwards to me because it feels unlike TMBG to give interviews for someone to monetize. 2 stars, but only cuz it's TMBG.
Read more
marieP_1984
It started so great
Ok so i've been a huge TMBG fan for years, and was excited to see this Podcast show up on Reddit! My first minor critique would be the 45-second 'Fingertips' type montage intro... 15 seconds, ok... But 45 is a stretch.
What really killed it for me started with the third, and what I can't stand is the open mockery of the various covers found on YouTube. Now, I understand them playing their own band's cover, neat. But their new meta is playing and openly critiquing other artist's covers - to what end? If the intention of this podcast is to discuss a song, why would you spend 8-10 minutes commenting "I don't think that's the right note" or "her ukulele is out of tune"?
Honestly If you are looking for a pure, deep dive into each song, you'll need to wade through a lot of speculation and excessive soundbites. Sorry Greg, I really wanted to like this.
Read more
IndieChix0r
This Might Be (a GREAT) Podcast!
There's no "might" about it - this is a great one. Clever, insightful and well-researched from a true TMBG fan. I can't wait to hear more!
shawnalley
It is a podcast!
Listened to check and can confirm it is a podcast. Au contraire, it’s not just a podcast, it’s a great podcast! Don’t let’s start arguing, I’m impressed. James K. Polk would even enjoy this. Hot dog! I like fun and this is the greatest. Everything right is wrong again so hop on your dirt bike and give it a listen. It’s going to be as popular as experimental film in Istanbul. What a gift even though it’s not my birthday.
Read more
josafisch
TMBAP
Cast your pod to the wind.
DanielJosLeary
