Reviews
via Podcasts
Tom Johnson Episode
I’m an avid podcast listener, but have never taken the time to leave a review. After listening to the episode with Tom Johnson I felt compelled to do so because what a gem of a man! From the beginning to the end of the episode, Tom shares a wealth of information from his personal accounts. This first hand knowledge and experiences from another generation is such a treasure to have recorded and I’m so thankful it was shared with newer generations on this awesome podcast!
Read more
MSU Mankato 2007
Nothing new to see here peeps, keep moving……
Just another Libtardian agenda driven mouth piece social media outlet. Garbage in—Garbage out!!
dfrcomp
Thorough
One thing I truly love about this podcast is how he tries to see history from as many perspectives as he can. The host and guests seem honest and genuinely interested in finding truth, not just to get hits or sell books, but to better understand the president and their situations. Thx!
love to Learn bits at a time
Great podcast
This is a podcast not be missed. The historical information is presented clearly and concisely enabling a normal person to fully grasp the critical aspects of Presidential decision making.
Sepeters801
Egads
Just a look at who has contributed tells me there is a lefty slant that cannot be unseen. Not one historian a conservative would follow. Disappointed.
Pamela7644
Trump at 6?
I used to enjoy this podcast, then I got away from listening for several months. I tuned in just in time to listen to a guest who placed Trump as the 6th best president, and Obama and Biden as the worst ever.
Are you kidding me?
You lost this listener.
Jay Foulk
Love the Pod & Congratulations on your Book!
So happy to hear your book is being published! I love the podcast, and I can’t wait to read your book! Thanks for all your hard work and dedication!
rturner19
Political Bias At it Worst
Been following the podcast for years but the last few months had to say no more. You always had a sense the episodes tilted a certain political direction but I was okay with that. There wasn’t the shove it down your throat, slap it across your face bias. You learned a lot. Now, it’s gone full bias. Leaving heavy not on conservative values but on full MAGA. For Richard, you would think he would be more aware of the bias as his favorite president is Washington, heck he even wrote a book about it which heavily focused on Washington stepping down after two terms. And yet, he ignores recent political history (hello Jan 6). Now it’s switched to episodes like Charlie Kirk and praising him like his values align with the rest of America. Since when was this belief an American value “Happening all the time in urban America, prowling Blacks go around for fun to go target white people, that’s a fact. It’s happening more and more”. It would be truly interesting to see Richard do a January 6 episode. He probably won’t as he knows he couldn’t spin it and his sponsors would ditch him.
Read more
Badger Strider
My favorite podcast
I look forward to each new release. Keep up the great work.
Frontline1964
Beyond Bias
Based on a scroll through the episodes, it was apparent that the program has a conservative tilt. I respect that and looked forward to a refreshing perspective. But it goes too far in explaining away the mistakes of Republicans while ignoring accomplishments of Democrats. And Mr. Trump is generally praised in spite of his lying and grifting. A guest has him in a top 5 while denigrating FDR; that’s pretty weird.
Read more
Moonda21
MAGA Propoganda
I was hoping this podcast would offer an unbiased, historical look at the American presidency. Boy, was I wrong. You lost all credibility when you hosted a guest who claimed Trump is one of the five greatest presidents who ever lived and FDR one of the five worst. Cmon, man. Do better.
Kerrbird88
Ok
It’s fine but please less partisan tilt. I know you worked for W but that doesn’t mean you should have far right guests and write for prageru. Still going to cautiously listen to the occasional episode though.
brooklynhistorianLars
Trump 6th best President???
I learned a lot…..
SDI….everyone knew it would work
purdue-7
Dec 16, 2025 Debunking Presidential Myths is a lot of Bunk
I have generally enjoyed this podcast but today’s show was astoundingly biased. It started out ok but when the guest got to Eisenhower I started to think, hmmm, this is sounding a bit weird. Then from that point on to the end of the show the guest was unbalanced and completely slanted toward conservatism. I am middle of the road politically so some conservative ideology appeals to me but this guy was off the chart by the end of the episode. The host did no pushback to question the lack of balance. Sorry not sorry. You lost a listener.
Read more
coalminersdawtr
Not a fan of the recent approach
I’ve been listening to this podcast for a long time now and have mostly enjoyed it. You could tell it’s always had a bit of a conservative tilt to it, which is fine because I don’t mind hearing other perspectives.
Recently though, that conservative tilt has become a bit more like a conservative hard right turn. Between the recent obsession with how misunderstood the 1920s conservative presidents are, an episode almost entirely about Charlie Kirk (who last time I checked has nothing to do with presidents), and guests who are very openly partisan (the most recent guest had Trump in his top 5 presidents and Biden and Obama as his worst presidents), it feels like the show is becoming something that I didn’t sign up for. It’s a shame too, because I think the host is a good storyteller with an obvious enthusiasm for this subject matter.
If you haven’t already, go back and listen to a lot of the earlier episodes because there’s a lot of good stuff in there. Here’s hoping the show returns to a relatively more even handed approach.
Read more
CGI Monster
Revisionist Claptrap from Schweikart
I find the overly partisan nature of the last episode disconcerting. I don’t need the pablum from right wing mouthpieces just as I don’t need to watch the nonsense on RT TV.
gskarp
Yikes
The Charlie Kirk love is so odd. Used to love the show. Unsubscribing. There are better (unbiased) shows on Presidents out there.
GTGMcast
Oustanding podcast
I recently discovered this podcast and listened to it on a long road trip from Alabama to Albuquerque (and back). Wow, did it make the trip go by so much faster. If you enjoy US History, you will love this podcast. Richard does an awesome job!
John-Cyr
Great podcast
Thoroughly enjoy listening to this podcast and always seem to learn something new. Richard Lim does a good job of explaining contemporary views, both positive and negative, of the President being discussed; and then shares his views with support. I’m catching up on some older episodes. Just listened to the 2023 series (5 episodes) on progressive presidents Roosevelt and Wilson. Very informative and nice summary of their legacy in the last episode.
Read more
Brad#90
Good Teacher
I feel like I learn a lot when I listen to this podcast. More details and recent revelations about historical events that I learned about in school long ago, but I’m finding a more nuanced and dimensional perspective.
Llallall
Excellent Podcast
Despite some of the other reviews, I have never felt this podcast was biased. I believe this is a solid podcast history that does so well at present history. I have learned so much from this podcast and the guests are so engaging. The guests on this show have diverse perspectives that really help me see history through different lenses.
AvidLearner96
Trumpy
Didn’t realize until this last episode
Richardnam3
For the history buffs!
I’ve loved US Presidential history since I was a kid. I’ve learned so much, and am constantly astounded. Listening to this podcast, which makes the 5-year-old in me and 20-something current me very giddy!
CRHisry
For the US history enthusiast
Excellent guests, interesting topics, historically accurate without appeasing to extremist and revisionist opinions.
marcusp75
A must
This podcast is a must for any Presidential or American history enthusiast
Joe 1616
Very biased trump vs Biden Harris
I listened to some of your earlier podcast versions while jogging and liked them. I wondered where you stood politically so I jumped to Biden trump and realized your representation of events were extremely biased, unbelievable so. You missed so much of really what was going on and focused on the MSM and democratic interpretations that I started to wonder about the older podcasts Within the next 6 months, the real truth will come out and you will be like another lichman. I beg you from the bottom of my heart to re-examine your bias and give a fairer representation going forward
Read more
Seattle1947
Just another red pill
Having bill o Riley on ur show really just says it all. Any illusion of unbiased was quickly thrown out the window. Glossing over some of the world’s most vile acts caused by presidents wasn’t enough, this man contorts himself into pretzels trying his hardest to justify or redeem the worst of them. Podcast like this seems to have one aim, poison the minds of young men by pushing the illusion that America is some shining beacon. No matter how polite or endearing u try to make ur rhetoric won’t disguise the fact that ur a red piller with a gentler tone than Joe Rogan, at least Joe Rogan pod cast won’t put u to sleep.
Read more
zombinlond_boneyboy
Outstanding Presidential History
Excellent and informing. History presented with no political bias. Very well done.
THP 2024
Unfortunate Direction
The recent shift platforming alt-right and Lost Cause propaganda has lost me.
Nick's Nick Name
Excellent
This is an informative and interesting podcast, perfect for anyone with an interest in history or any American patriot for that matter.
i hate tik tok ads
Alt-Right Contamination
I used to really enjoy this pod, but recent interviews of extremely biased alt-right “historians” killed it for me. Unsubscribing.
Andy Sandy Eggo
So much information!
I have truly enjoyed this podcast for the wonderful stories of our presidents and the outstanding interviews that Richard brings each episode.
Dean in MD
Solid history podcast! 👏🏻
I love this podcast!
It is a very informative podcast with a humble host! This podcast is not aggressively political. It is here to provide the public with well researched facts and is presented with an open minded view of history AND politics!
Five stars!!
Thank you! God bless!
DebbieWilde
Assassination Attempt
None of this was informed or helpful.
Norwich42
Best One
Whether you’re playing trivia, watching the news and/or a game show U.S. Presidents comes up very often. I have learned about U.S. Presidents when visiting its sites and reading about them, but there are some facts that I have never heard of. To me this is one of the best podcast.
jv152309
President
I love this podcast
got uuuui
Covered Reagan Welll
The episode on Ronald Reagan was done very well. He was very fair.
Textdgh
Excellent
Very well researched and presented without an agenda which is truly refreshing. Please don’t submit to those with an agenda.
Rocking Rick 8185
Horrible! Worst historical podcast.
In Episode about Ulysses Grant an author throws up nonsensical hypotheticals repeating Lost Cause propaganda. 🤮Poorly researched.
Straightiron
Love the deep dives
This show is the vindicator of the lost presidents - those we don't remember well, or who didn't have sensational terms in office. Richard brings out the significance and richness of each administration in an engaging and thoughtful way. I'm always better for listening. Thank you!
AyWenz
American exceptionalist propaganda
I have no patience for podcasts about American presidents that do not take their entire careers and relationship to slavery and the genocide of native Americans.
CompletelyLogicalTotallyInsane
This American President
Have only listened to one episode, the James A Garfield, but it told me more about him than I had known before. Most shows about him only speak about his murder, not about how brilliant he was
Eddie Ginsburg
Not reliable
I tried liking this as I love history podcasts. But after listening to a few episodes I started getting suspicious. This podcaster is not interested in well-researched history. He has an agenda, and he is eager to spread it. Plus, his method of presentation is boring. Fortunately, I quickly found a podcast that is well researched and has interviews with interesting and knowledgeable speakers (“Presidential”).
Read more
Rouxwife
Great podcast and greatly delivery.
In a time when history is being rewritten, it was such a pleasure to find this podcast. Keep up the good work! Thanks!
JoycieAnne
Enjoyable and Informative
This American President podcast is a great gateway into the history of our country and the world. For those who believe history to be dry, try this show.
Billy GP
Would be a decent podcast but..
I know you and Rank are weird conservatives, but if you could not have outright bigots who snicker about pronouns off your podcast that would be great. I know you guys think its cutesie to whine about pronouns and be snowflakes about the taking down of statues of white supremacists but you’re not fooling anyone. You’d think historians who claim to understand the values of the Civil Rights Era would have a little more understanding of the recent push for liberty and respect by a minority group but I guess that’s a little too much to ask. For historians its weird to watch you and rank be consistently on the wrong side of history.
In other words, stick to the history and keep your retrograde political opinions to yourself. Same goes for Rank too.
Read more
fuzzbuzz215
Like Finding Gold at John Sutter’s Mill!!!
I remember in college, taking a Psychology class & the subject of the lecture was memory. As an exercise, the Prof asked the class to name as many POTUS’ as we could in a specific amount of time. As a self-professed history nerd, I instinctually started with George Washington & moved forward, chronologically. Without a single exception, every other kid in the class started with the current president & worked their way backwards. So when I heard This American President for the 1st time, l knew l had found a kindred spirit in Richard Lim! The fact that his 1st episode was George Washington - arguably our greatest president - shouldn’t surprise anyone (especially given Richard’s connection to Mount Vernon!), but his 2nd subject, Andrew Johnson just blew me away! Choosing one of the most controversial (and, dare l say, despicable presidents ever) as the follow up to GW, was a complete & bold statement. I knew I had found something special - and it consistently is special. The way he unveils Johnson’s beliefs (flawed as they are), Lim exposes an infinitely more complex individual than l had ever considered. Lim also has a deceivingly low key, natural approach that belies his intellect. His interviews are brilliantly executed conversations with his well-chosen guests. I never get the impression that his guests are just trying to ‘pimp’ a new book, but just want to have a conversation with the host. Built for both the casual history nerd & the more serious-minded historian… Well-researched, stunningly informative and yet, remarkably entertaining - what else could you want in a podcast? Keep it up!
Read more
LClark2691
Top Notch
Well-researched. Great content. Richard is a great host. Nerd out on presidential history with this gem of a podcast.
millardchillmore
Compelling content
This is my favorite podcast - the combination of history and storytelling is wonderful. The conversations with authors and experts are so interesting. I’ve learned so much and appreciate this very thoughtful approach to the presidency and those who have served in the office.
Anonymous12345678909887654321
The Title Should be "The Republican Presidents"
This show deep dives into Republican presidents. But Democrat presidents are only mentioned in passing.
Szabinasnape
