Reviews
via Podcasts
Fantastic… until Goshawk.
This would have received 5 stars, however the Goshawk sequel series was underwhelming. Part of the charm of the first 5 seasons was the mystery and the unique presentation by the narrator reading letters and sharing audio/video files. It allowed you to hear the inner thoughts of the characters and limited revealed information to just what was written down or recorded by the characters. Goshawk completely abandons that for traditional audio-only storytelling without any narration or unique perspectives from letters/notes etc. There was also significantly less mystery aspect. Don’t get me wrong it was still a well-done production. The voice acting is great as usual, however the main 3 actresses have very similar voices so it’s very difficult to tell them apart and leads to a lot of confusion. Overall the whole show is absolutely worth the listen and has really unique world-building. The first five seasons are deliciously suspenseful and so well done, but if you’re hoping for that to continue you’ll be disappointed if you listen to Goshawk.
Read more
EvanEllis7
Batman
Why…does…that…guy…speak…like…he’s…Batman?
cristwutters
Very very good border line great.
100% recommend. First three episodes are a bit of a slow burn. However it really picks up and is captivating immediately after. Hard not to binge. In 2x9 there is one scene with an annoying hum, it’s intentional but too loud. That’s my only complaint. The characters a great and diverse. I love the diverse nationalities.
WhydoIneedaNickname?!?!?!??!
Brilliant!
Terrifying, compelling, smart and deeply relatable. The creators have effortlessly woven in capable women and a global cast into the show; Hollywood could learn so much from them.
loquist
This is so petty but
I was really getting into the shores of the silver thrum but there is this nigh incessant tapping used in the background mix that I can’t ignore or get past. Really cool story, but please creators have your most misophonic friend listen to the last draft before you send it
Shsjdjajajaj
Great!…0up until goshawk
The climate change theme was like a giant metaphorical kick to the nuts, especially for those who listen to fiction for the sole purpose of avoiding our cultures obsessive nature of interjecting politics in everrryything.
Subtract that last star for me
Love this podcast ❤️ But the ending needs to be rounded out ✨
I loved the white vault and don’t mind cruxmont. However, with all the love in my heart - You need a true writer that can drive, feed and finish your stories. The endings just leave me, my friends and family that follow your shows super frustrated. All that work and time put into the sound quality, research, cast building etc etc and then the endings to white vault and sealskin rock just fizz out. You have to know how to finish a story. Leaving things just “up in the air” is sloppy writing, it takes a well rounded writer to pin that ending down (you can still have your mystery and punch and land that well rounded ending- sometimes even managing to introduce a delicious nugget of new information that opens the world you built in a new direction while still ending it) You make beautifully orchestrated sound and put so much care in your research - find a writer or even student writer that has that momentum and capacity to bring that story to the end it deserves! It will certainly pay off ❤️
Read more
Louisa Lorenzo
Sigh
This show started off absolutely amazing i loved it and was excited to see where it would go. And then its like they just gave up rushed a end ing and just left me disappointed. Gave it 4 stars cause i really did love it at first but had to take a star off for the disappointment.
no names8433
Too scary
Have to take breaks now and then - so well done. The acting is great. Only listened to season 1 so far. Will go slow.
Danermal
Raised the bar for me
It’s a slow build for sure. Every arc takes at least 2 seasons (10 episodes per season) before concluding. The slow horror of the first arc sets the tone surrounding the mystery of the White Vault for the rest of the show.
That being said I was disappointed by the way the show ended. Not only because I’d totally love another season, but also the method of ending the story…is that really how it’s going to end?!
All the other audio dramas I have, will, or am listening to, I keep comparing to this. I’m relatively new to audio dramas, this ranks in my top 2.
Read more
Jam-a-fram
One actor
I’ve listed to audio dramas my whole life and this is a great story…. But .. Graham’s voice takes me out of the story every single time he talks. His voice and tone are so unrealistic and do not match the tone of the rest of the actors. He sounds like he’s trying to be an anime protagonist or something. I was genuinely disappointed when he showed up in the 4th season. I rarely leave reviews, just had to say this
Read more
Ethan, it's Mom
#1 audio drama
Best. Audio. Drama. Ever!!! Unfortunately this was the first one I ever listened to so every one since has been a disappointment😓!
Z0mberry
What a waste of time
The first season just built up to nothing you keep waiting for something to happen but nothing does. I am so disappointed in the time I spent
opuoju777
My favorite podcast
My favorite podcast, and I don’t even like horror as a genre. I’ve listened to most of the seasons more than once. Also cool that it wrapped up in my home state! Thanks guys.
_reverencia_
Amazing
I know I’m new to podcast and probably don’t have the best idea of a good podcast. But this one made me actually feel what I was listening to.
Welcome to the masquerade
Lowkey unmatched to this day
On what’s probably my 5th relisten of this podcast and figured I’d leave a review. In terms of narrative (non-anthology) horror podcasts that feel like true horror, the white vault is simply unmatched. I have never listened to a podcast that instilled such a deep sense of dread and unease as this one did. I can’t speak for the later seasons as I have adhd and cannot finish anything for the life of me but seasons 1-4 are fantastic. The tension is always high, whenever you think the situation can’t get any worse it does, and the main characters are completely defenseless in the face of their oncoming doom. 11/10 Deserves to be as hyped as the likes of Magnus Archives and Malevolent
Read more
kev1n.e.1even
B-O-R-I-N-G
Took 5 season what could’ve been done in 2-3 seasons. Very overrated
Neens_21
Wow
I loved everything about this audio drama! It was my first one ever and dang it was a good one.
Earthchildxo
Nothing missed after Season 5
The first 5 seasons of the show were very fun the first 2 being the best of the bunch. The Goshawk arc is where the series takes a sharp downturn. Voice acting is worse, looses the found footage premise, and the story draaaaaags on. First 2 seasons are gold, listening to season 5 gives you a good conclusion to the story, listen to the last 3 season if you're really invested in the lore.
Durains
Goodbye dear friends
I am so sad the show is over. I can't begin to fully describe how much I enjoy listening to the series. I have looked look forward to every new season and episode for years now. It is my comfort food, and as grateful as I am to have been able to see how it all wraps up I'm at a total loss knowing these characters stories are finished, for now.
Neal Crisp
Season 8 is a hot mess
Disappointed in this last season, up till season eight it’s been great and I highly recommend this podcast. But enough of that whining and hysterics inside the cave, get on with it.
VaStarr27
What a great listen!
It’s funny. I just stumbled on this series right before its final episode and I’m glad l did! What a ride!
The characters were all so fantastic and the audio was top notch. I felt like I was there at times, like I could feel the cold.
The mystery was great and I love how much mystery there still is even now that it’s over.
AshenElder
__Meh __
Leaving me in limbo. At times I like it and others I’m like… uhhhh…. I have been listening since they first started producing. I keep hanging in there hoping for one more best. 1st and 2nd season were great.
Update from last review…. My opinion stays the same. The ending was a downer but at least the produces were honest about not having a “happy ending “. I just feel more like the first 2 seasons would have been just as good of an ending as this last season. But this is my peanut comment.
Read more
calarky 4k
Arctic Horror!
I lived the Svalbard seasons! Ever since I was a kid, arctic set stories aways intrigued me.
Probably why I love Scandinavian mystery and detective shows.
But you kept it going.
I have to say when the reason for the heart and teeth is revealed, you could have knocked me over with a feather!
Looking forward to whatever you do next.
Sean Huxter
Mostly a great show
Well done modern horror that reaches into the past. Well paced and constructed. I would have given 5 stars, but the actor voicing graham played him like Clint Eastwood in a western. Distracting as a listener and pulled me out of the story.
The dual language translation is a bit tiring at times. It delays the storytelling without being super relevant.
Over all very well done.
LongTallMe
Seasons 1 & 2 are excellent
The plot meanders in Seasons 3 & 4, and from Season 5 onward it just feels like we’re winging it as we go. In any case, I appreciate the effort and coordination involved in producing the show, these things aren’t created overnight. Thanks!
radiophilia
Details
Love the show, small annoyances are having to speak one language and repeat in English and is Graham really Batman?
Tamahoney
Amazing!
Absolutely one of the best winter horror podcasts I've ever heard! This channel is literally the only Patreon I've ever paid to subscribed to because it's just been that good! I am amazed over and over again at the production value of this show!
Ambydae
Artistic Powerhouse
I love this series beyond measure! It was the show that got me into horror podcasts and continues to be on my relisten list. The international mystery vibe is just so engaging and every time I listen I have new questions and theories. Can’t recommend it enough!
Darrowsamis
Horrible writing, unintelligible dialogue, and even worse editing.
I don’t even write reviews but felt I had to speak on this. It’s a mess.
Jim217
Undecided
I loved Magnus Archives and especially Malevolent, and the writer of that show recommended this so I am giving it a try. Almost done with Season 3. He said something like White Vault contains the scariest kind of horror in nearly every episode. So far, I strongly disagree. Mostly quite boring. My primary complaint, though, is the accents spoken in by most of the main characters and narrators. *Especially* season 3 good LORD the female lead is so annoying with her accent it distracts from the plot line. My opinion seems to be unpopular, as most seem to adore this show. I am committed to finish regardless.
Read more
CrudeAtlatl
Went downhill
First 2 seasons were well written and well performed. Now, the voice acting is very fake and unconvincing. Script just a drag... all of sudden decided to go all unnecessarily Progressive and Woke which sound unauthentic and forced, deliberately shoved into the script to pat yourself on the back. Behhh
JustCuriousAgain
Amazing show I listen every spooky season
I love this show so much. I relisten every Halloween time for sleepy time. Also, on of their first sponsors being coffee is spectacular. The voice acting is good, the story is incredible, the sound design really helps bring in the goosebumps 🖤✨
LizzeeFreitas
Been listening since season 1!!
I love the podcast. From the characters to the every twist and turns in the plot, the story is so rich. Just when you think you have it all figured out you truly don’t. The sounds are so rich and the actors are amazing. It so nice that they actually use actors of the dialect to act in this podcast.
Swagger28
HUUUUUUUGE Let down in the final plot….
6 1/2 seasons of incredible story telling and mystery only for (get this)…….GLOBAL WARMING to come out 2/3rds the way through season 7 as the “real villain” of the story……. Absolutely disappointed the story took that hard of a koolaid dive….
Predator4golf
Awesome podcast!
This podcast is wonderful! I’ve only listened to the first season, but the characters are so interesting and have so much depth! The acting is wonderful, and the writing even more so! Will, almost certainly, listen again!
Row-Row223
Eh.
Voice acting is terrible. Some of them are fine but Karina was so unbearably whiney and every single time Graham spoke, it took me out of the story. AWFUL. Story is interesting but slow moving.
Sailor_d00m
The Best
This is the best podcast story ever! I can’t wait for more. All of the stories by Fool and Scholar are the best. I’m so glad I found The White Vault!
YLesaMarie
why is simon?
simon is THE MOST irritating character i’ve ever listened to. the actor needs to dial it back x100. beyond that unfortunate choice, this pod is amazing. great writing, production, etc. i love ‘vast’, too.
sastrauss
Bloody He__!
Get on with the next season already, gits!
(Walter55)
phenomenal!!
Amazing writing! Amazing voice actors! Amazing sound editing! Amazing story! Just so so good! Relistening for maybe the fourth time
Brandishing1991
Excellent!
One of the few podcasts that sucked me in so fully I practically ignored my entire life to binge listen to all seasons. Fantastic story, phenomenal voice actors, this kept me interested, engaged, and anticipating each and every episode. I’m gushing, I know, but it’s so very good!
Mich B
When you hear it, it hears you too.
The first two seasons are so great! Season 3 is a dip as everyone mentions, but by Season 5 it’s back to being pretty great!
OhPeaches
Great stories
Really original and twisty. The writer pulls together different timeliness, characters and countries weaving them into a gripping tale. Look forward to be stories!
Lct1900
Top shelf storyline
5stars and shakas 🤙to all involved. One of 3 of my faves. Listened to this many times and it’s awwwwsome! Great job! Thanx to all. I’ll surf some waves in your honor! 😎
da kiter
I’m hooked!
Not sure how I found this but glad I did! The story immediately hooks you and being a huge fan of isolation horror this is all me. Great listen!
Jony Gonz
Amazing!!!
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this podcast. Great characters and storytelling. It keeps you on your toes. Sad to know that coming October it will be the final season. Great job everyone, two thumbs up.
Zylktastic
Sensational
I loved the first two seasons and got so attached to the characters. AND THEN THEY DIED. It was hard to get attached to the new characters but I got there eventually. I was so happy when Graham hadn’t died.
Phoenix ^^
Any suggestions
Looking for another podcast to listen to like this anyone have any suggestions??
Libra76$!
Amazing
I took a listen to this podcast on recommendation by Scott Sigler, whom I am a huge fan of. And he was right this podcast is fully immersive and leaves me wanting the next season! I would highly recommend this podcast to anyone who enjoys good horror stories.
LPSP1989
