Reviews
via Podcasts
feels like home
this is the one podcast where i don't mind the crosstalk and overlapping conversations. even in the early episodes where the audio quality is not as good it still feels like i'm sitting at the table with my friends while they play dnd, just like when i was in college. don't miss out on this one. there's lots of excellent bird facts also.
starrilynight
Great Podcast
This is an awesome actual play podcast. The group has made a world that draws you in and feel the stress that the players do when things go wrong. Everything is done with a good balance of humor and drama. The world they have created is full of detail and the group does a great job of using different games to ensure the world develops just as much as their characters. Overall an awesome job.
Victorious Timelord
SIncere Actual Play!
One thing that I look for in actual plays is chemistry. Believe it or not that is a lot harder to find than you think. In a scene where new table top roleplaying games are coming out left and right. Very few have chemistry because most aren’t there to play games, they are there to cash in. That is not the case what so ever with The Room Where it Happened. The Room Where it Happened is recorded at a table, and you can tell the main mission is to have fun, and the group works hard on that. The interactions with the player characters and NPCs is superb! I highly recommend this if you are looking for a great Dungeons and Dragons actual play with a group that is sincere and there to have fun!
Read more
Christopher Zacher
A Fly on the Wall (of the Room Where it Happened)
The Room Where it Happened is an excellent podcast for listeners who want to feel like they’ve taken a seat at the table of a great group of friends. The players have a lot of fun with one another, and the GM facilitates a great environment where everyone feels like part of the fun, listeners included!
Deckelodeon
The show
I started listening because I heard there was going to be some LGBT stuff, and there is some, just not what I thought it was going to be. The show is still super good.
how is then name taken
Feel like you're in the Room Where it Happened!
I love APs with the group all in one place. There's an energy there that's hard to replicate, so I was happy to find that energy in The Room Where it Happened (and the musical nerd in me loves the title reference too). The homebrew setting is filled with interesting details and NPCs, while still having plenty of recognizable D&D 5E in the playstyle.
Angela_Craft
Fun actual play
The Room Where it Happened has a deep and interesting world being built. Learning about it as the players explore is loads of fun. Good table chemestry but there is some cross talk that can be disorienting at times.
Medic611
A very interesting world!
The world of Lumme is obviously very detailed and very rich. It incorporates elements from a half dozen different genres and manages to build something original from all of it. The group playing is obviously very comfortable with each other and with the game. There's some laughs, but also a great deal of focus on character development and exploring the world.
DM Nick
Great!
A fast-paced mystery, The Room Where It Happened had me on the edge of my seat. The players think on their feet, making for a high-speed chess game vibe as they chase down monsters and criminals through a world that seems like ours.... but not quite. As a fan of D&D and sci/fi in general, I'm hooked!
Frycurious
Strong Narrative, Could Use some Clean Up
The Room Where it Happened has one of the strongest group chemistries I’ve seen in a podcast yet. It’s a shame that constant voice overlap makes it difficult to listen, at times.
Overall the story is a modern take on fantasy tropes; Cars instead of Horses, for example. A refreshing new takes, on old expectations. As I listen in to more episodes, it’s clear this story shares more of its DNA with Shadowrun than D&D, which I’ve always felt needs more love. The players involved are clearly fans of each other, and the GM has excellent judgment by letting them get involved in the narrative beyond merely stating what they do. Often they help dictate the results of their successes and failures. A mark of true trust among tabletop rpg players.
I hope that future installments of this podcast will see the audio edited in order to avoid the overlap, where it not for it, I would certainly award it 5 stars.
Read more
Dulenheim
The Table Where it Happens
There's a lot of cross-talk aand overlapping conversations, to the point that it's hard to keep track of who's talking and what they're talking about, and the group's occasional use of props at the table doesn't gel all that well with an auditory medium.
On the other hand, it's interesting to listen to this type of collaborative roleplaying and it's clear that the players have been playing together for a long time, so their back-and-forth feels really natural. The story they're telling is also very interesting, and I enjoy the way they tell it. It's also a unique setting, and that adds a certain zest.
Read more
Lemiel
Good alternative to classic fantasy
If you're the type to enjoy table-feel actual play RPG's, this show is for you! The show takes classic fantasy in D&D 5e and adds a modern twist. Using vehicles, doing chase scenes in the city, updated spells, you will see they are having fun with the game and the players are enjoying being creative. If some of the audio quality early on bothers you, do keep listening because it does improve. Give it a listen!
Read more
Bapperson
Great start to the show
I’m only a few episodes in but I am enjoying the show and the world of Luume a lot so far. I have played a good bit of dnd 5E but some of the other rules were new to me, but spicing up the vanilla of 5E is something I’ve thought about a great deal.
The world is great and the players are a lot of fun. My only concern is that the microphone placement in some episodes makes a few players a little too loud and others a bit too soft, so listening with headphones is hard.
I can’t wait to d/l and listen to some more and hope your Luume arc continues!
Read more
DungeonMaster4President
Great new RPG podcast, albeit with some blemishes
The Room Where it Happened is a fantastic podcast which manages to shine, despite some of its rough patches.
I love that the DM seems so passionate about what they're doing and the narrative and story setting are cool. They do a really great job of keeping things together. Unfortunately, at times I really struggled to follow what was happening or what the active player was trying to do because there seemed to be a lot of cross-chat between players who were not active, that overlapped with the player whose turn it was or sometimes even the DM.
I really enjoyed the idea behind the shows intro, with it being a narrative from a character's perspective, but I feel like this could also be improved if the music was faded out much sooner to make it snappier. A vocal transition could really help with this too, to make a clearer distinction on the intro and outro going into game time.
The group obviously has fantastic chemistry and listening is like sitting in on an in person game. With just a few small improvements (rigid respect of the turn order being the strongest!) this show has potential to be all star.
Read more
Firx Muldar
Great Energy!!
First off, I loved the chemistry the group has. The podcast seems to be recorded at an actual table where the game is played and it really brings out the personalities of the players and the relationship they have outside of the game. Great energy and it really pulls you in and makes you feel invested as if you are watching them play within a game shop.
The DM seems passionate; like his sole purpose is to make sure his players are having fun. You can tell by the way he runs combat, and doesn’t get too stuck on details.
The NPC Wyatt, and the characters’ interactions with him are well done, another factor that made me feel pulled into the game.
One thing that was really awesome was the frigging intro. It’s a narration done from the perspective of a character and it really pulls you in, almost like how it is done in movies and such. The only thing I would say could be done to really take the introduction to the next level is by maybe have over the music a narrator explain what game is playing, who the characters are, and who are playing the characters. I think it would even make the introduction even more awesome. Even the channel description could have something similar too.
Overall an awesome experience and I highly suggest everyone check it out!
Read more
Twin Cities by Night
