Reviews
via Podcasts
Fascinating!
This series explores fascinating topics. Things you thought you knew about and lots more about things you have never heard about. The hosts provide in-depth research that brings the stories to life through storytelling so you won’t fall asleep listening to a narration.
The hosts have good chemistry with each other which on occasion comes across as bro banter, but that’s a minor failing to an otherwise superb show.
I have gifted this series and recipients have been delighted.
Read more
Poleinshole1
Great show, but
I love David’s novels and clearly he’s an experienced guy, but I’m disappointed that the Jensen Huang episode seems to be based in large part on reporting from the New York Times. I have to say that’s not why we tune in. It’d be much more compelling if the boys were leaning on current informer intelligence operatives to get real insight into whether or not MSS is running her and whether or not it was a honey pot. Just a parroting the New York Times reporting is disappointing to say the least
Read more
Spyder2323
Kim Philby
Great show, keep up the good work guys. But I beg you can we get through 1 episode without Gordon mentioning the name Kim Philby? I beg you.
MK or the Q
History behind the scenes
I love the way they blend in firsthand accounts to bring these stories to life. They've sort of humanized espionage, put history in context, and given me a new perspective on global politics.
kalexkalex
Good Analysis and History
I enjoy this podcast immensely. It examines intelligence history and policies with color and right amount of detail. The moderators are easy to listen to and have good chemistry. Their different backgrounds expand the programs perspective.
impish1
Moderate
It’s the throaty with American which is boring
Boovie first
Very informative
I’ve been listening for a few months now and I’ve learned a lot from this podcast. I’ve always been interested in espionage and spy craft and geo politics and this show has been very informative. I’ve bought a bunch of books based on the hosts recommendations. Keep up the good work!
PhilConsequence
Yikes
The recent two chapter novel excerpt shared was brutal. The writing was bad and the voice actors were not for this work at all. Run, don’t walk to the unsubscribe button.
W.AlanRose
The Rest is Classified
Topics, info and knowledge are intriguing, BUT the hosts….between the chronic nasal congestion of one and the other ending every single sentence with “in’t it?” it’s really hard to listen to.
potato_farmer25
Vocal Fry
The voice of the American host makes this great of cast almost impossible to listen to.
BBetz1985
Binary, credulous thinking
Nuclear physicists give their take on biological sciences and super secret spy stuff.
mad overlord
Good show
This show is really good and very eye opening I. Some things . The only thing I have to say is quit with the vocal fry voice it makes it hard to listen to and a lot of the time it’s not there so I wish he would just give up trying to sound whatever he thinks he may needs to sound like
Binebootoo
So insightful
I have learned so much on topics I thought I was informed on before. The recounting is fair and factual. And the perspective these guys bring from their prior experience is gives it a depth that I haven't heard on other podcasts. In the lead up to 9/11 I started with that series. I haven't been able to stop listening. I can't recommend this series enough!
GA-B B
Biased
Tried to listen to this again, within the first 2 minutes of rise of bin Laden they have to mention Trump. Let it go.
c2hicks
Too much talking about themselves
The first episode was supposed to be about an operation in Iran. If you didn’t already know about it you could never follow because all these two did was jabber on about themselves and random parts of the story! Ugh
Devoted The Spy Who listener
Worth your time
Strong overall. Good host chemistry and humour. Occasional choices are puzzling, e.g., Battle of Mogadishu, where they seem to have little to add to the literature (fine work but seemed outside their core competence of espionage). They’ve been killing it for last several weeks! I’d be happy to have that level every 3-4 and still be impressed, but wow.
Nico de Piemonte
Great intelligence podcast
Some espionage/spy podcasts can get a little dry, even when discussing interesting topics, but I like these hosts. Pretty engaging. I like it even more now that I’ve seen Trumper tantrums in the reviews!
MarciGSD
Unfollowed!
Great idea for a show, unfortunately ruined by the hosts’ unbridled political bias. Episodes covering historical topics, such as the Cold War, are typically very well done. But anything from the modern era—especially anything even tangentially related to President Trump—is borderline unlistenable.
McCloskey, in particular, seems far too willing to carry water for the Intelligence Community and rarely bothers to seriously explore competing perspectives or alternative explanations. I don’t expect the hosts to share my political views, but I do expect some degree of intellectual curiosity and an honest examination of all sides. Unfortunately, that seems to disappear whenever modern politics enters the discussion.
Unfollowed.
Read more
Loader240troops
Great Podcast, but…
The American has to cut down on the vocal fry. Holy cow, it’s like nails on chalkboard.
David60517
Overall, quite good. One complaint.
I’ve been interested in the world of espionage for many years. I find this podcast pretty interesting and well done, overall. But I would enjoy it more if both hosts could tame some of their annoying verbal tics (Don’t the producers listen and provide feedback?). Today’s example: “Well, welcome to The Rest is Classified.” Drop the first “well”.
Pod Fan in VA
Wikipedia Slop
Research was lazy on origins of COVID-19 episode and commentary largely ignored credible and vast evidence of a lab leak. You also largely ignored the widely accepted criticism of the fact that the Chinese government has refused to release related data or allow for independent investigation committees to conduct analyses of the lab leak evidence. Disappointing that you would choose to prioritise leftist political grandstanding over factual scientific evidence. Don’t get your information from Wikipedia, which exclaims that asking for transparency from the Chinese government is “xenophobic”. There’s a reason wikipedia can’t be cited seriously in any academic work.
Gordon, as usual, is insufferably ignorant of the fact that political bias motivates misinformation on BOTH sides.
Read more
Original_Owl
Fantastic idea…but less political slant required
As a former IC professional, now on the outside like the Mr. McCloskey, I love the idea of this podcast and have greatly enjoyed certain episodes and series. However, the credibility (and enjoyment) suffers when their political viewpoints enter in, most noticeably on current and recent events. Bias, omissions, and a double standard in some cases have led me to stop listening mid-stream to some episodes. This podcast is a fantastic idea and I do enjoy listening to the hosts, including the inspired approach of the trans-Atlantic “special relationship.” However, Mr. McCloskey in particular— as a former intel analyst— does the intelligence profession and listeners a disservice by falling short of checking politics at the door and practicing sound analytic tradecraft. I will continue to listen with my radar up, and hope the hosts are willing and able to improve in their presentation of current events in particular. If not, I propose they limit themselves to spy stories of old, where their political viewpoints aren’t as vested in coloring the story. Thank you in advance for your openness to hearing my feedback.
Read more
AMBergie13
Five stars! And I wish I could give it ten.
Best spy podcast going and it's not close. David McCloskey was a real CIA analyst. Gordon Corera did 20 years on the security beat at the BBC. So when they walk you through a case you get the actual tradecraft, the screwups, the people, and it grips harder than any thriller. The Litvinenko series is unreal. Their run on how Russia hacked the 2016 election, the Prigozhin and troll farm and GRU stuff, is the clearest version of that mess I've heard anywhere. Start there, or just start at episode one.
Then read the one star reviews for a laugh. Same crowd every time. Some MAGA guy melting down because the show covered Russian disinformation and wouldn't call it a hoax. Which is beautiful, actually, because the episode literally explains how the troll farms worked, and then the trolls show up in the reviews to prove the episode right. Free live demonstration. Ten out of ten commitment to the bit, comrades. Send Prigozhin my regards.
Ignore all that and subscribe.
Read more
OkDokayDokay
Love the show
Do you have any episodes or plan to do episodes of the network of spies during the American revolution? Happy July 4th!
ACMilan17
Good Topics
Show does a great job of choosing fascinating topics to cover. I also appreciate the updates on the current intelligence environment between the US and UK with the chaos caused by Trump.
Norman1995Pit
Lots of potential
This could be an excellent and informative podcast if Gordon didn't so blatantly force his political narratives down the listener's throat. I've long listened to their sister podcast, The Rest is History. While those hosts surely don't come to the microphone lacking political beliefs, they are much more measured in approaching topics with clear political divides, without expressing disdain for people who might not agree with them.
Read more
Blazerfan23
Started strong but falling off quickly
I enjoyed the show when it was about espionage and historical examples. I have issues with the way David has an “everything in US intelligence is done by the CIA” approach but can get past it usually. However, the podcast has become entangled in conspiracy theories. The CIA poisoning of the English goalkeeper was an awful mini series. I get it, it is World Cup season, but how hard they tried to make loosely affiliated topics fit into a coherent story was laughable. Hopefully they recover, but this podcast is close to falling out of my rotation.
Read more
Ebalsman
Origin of Covid
I was really starting to like this pod and I’m a RESTis member to other pods, this completely irresponsible and obvious click bait subject on the scientifically proven origin of the virus couldn’t be more disgusting. The battleground that is vaccines and the real life dangers to real people as a result of conspiracies around them. I have lost all respect for whatever they say.
People die when they believe this kind of nonsense,creating an environment of mistrust, when it has been proven over and over IN THE SCIENCE.
Read more
Hey_linder
Easily my fav pod
I really enjoy the banter between Gordon and David. Secondly if you enjoy the free episodes I think the subscription is totally worth it. Probably the only pod subscription I will renew. #proudsquirrel
Westwind4466
Another ideological podcast
I tried to make it through multiple
Episodes but this is another left wing podcast and they struggle to hide it. I can’t listen to the right wing podcasts either. If you’re a lefty, this will definitely make you feel smarter
David Dwayne
It’s:
nuc-le-ar not nu-cu-lar
all of a sudden not all the sudden
nuc-le-ar not nu-cu-lar
champing at the bit not chomping at the bit
nuc-le-ar not nu-cu-lar
milk not melk
nuc-le-ar not nu-cu-lar
Bjorn B Leif
Lost Credibility
This was my favorite podcast until the hosts lost credibility by regularly disparaging President Trump, even when he is not the subject of the podcast.
W. Greg Webb
Israel nuclear weapons and doctrine, please
Great show. Any chance you might venture into the Israeli nuclear program and Israeli doctrine for use of those weapons? Your listeners would be particularly interested in the freedom of military action weapons convey onto Israel, and how its monopoly on these weapons in the Middle East challenges, others to seek similar deterrent. Hope this topic isn’t too sensitive for your show. Thanks!
X-blank-X
Good show but less filler
14:43 into the 1st Iraq WMD episode and the episode has yet to start - just talking in circles about everything that will be talked about and what guests will be on
rnr1097
Awesome Podcast
This is one of my absolute favorite podcasts. Super interesting content. McCloskey and Corera are both very knowledgeable and experienced, as well as superb storytellers and funny!
Kingman358
Great concept. But host bias makes it intolerable.
I love the topic matter and would subscribe in a heartbeat - but can’t get past the host bias. Sure they are savvy and experienced. But it is difficult to abide the political bias (surprise!- a decidedly left wing slant) that comes across as condescending. The pod would be perfectly interesting and just as funny without this bias.
It is of course their show, so I’m sure they will carry on, biases and all. But they’ll be doing it with at least one less listener.
Read more
MiramarJ
Speak more clearly
Hosts voices is too irritating to listen to.
Mel Morrison
mumbles
Listeners usually cannot understand Gordon because he does not enunciate his words. Every sentence is interspersed with string of mumbled words that are incoherent. Please speak more clearly and try to enunciate better.
Dizzy420
Russia con’t
Missing (?) is how we got Putin put-in and the 1990s in ex Soviet Bloc with larger theme of regime changes US and others may want but backfire for far too many people. If our global assessments of the arc and agendas of foreign leadership is incorrect then one wonders why: intentional reckless negligent? Is intelligence gathering and reporting itself compromised by being tethered to other opaque interests? I believe I know how Putin was initially financed by US interests and it went downhill from there.
Read more
Natasha no Boris
Pretty Obvious Psyop
The “former” CIA operative cohost is really interesting, but is also pro cover up? I guess I appreciate when the psyop is this obvious.
Patrick Sobecki
Meh
Decent information but a little too anti-Trump for my liking.
Bulletpruf
John Sipher
Mr. Sipher, how you managed to work Mr Trump into topics not about him at all, so many times, was remarkable - but not as remarkable as the blindness reflected in your statement that his “weaponization of the DOJ” has cost Americans their trust in their country’s institutions. No sir, that train left the station years ago, helped along by your own actions and fully-refuted allegations just one election cycle ago. You need to get past your broken heart and own your faults.
Why were you on this usually excellent pod, anyway?
Read more
Harpo the Marx
POD idea
When are you going to do a series on Richard Sorge? The research and perspective you bring to each topic would really bring that story to life.
alejandro lobo
Trivializing Serious Subjects
Badly presented and dumbed down for the not-very-bright targeted audience.
Mac an tSionnaigh
Emergency pods
Love, love, love the emergency pods. SO helpful
anje_b
Berlin Wall
Just a thought but the Wall’s history could use your touch!
Dave McSquirrel
Basic Boring Propaganda
Typical “Ex CIA dude” propaganda. Not based in reality. Totally unwilling to mention even well known controversies involving intelligence agencies, especially Mossad. Like another reviewer said, if you want anything more than a Zero Dark Thirty-esque/red white and blue/Israel=honest good guys look at the world of intelligence, you won’t find it on this pod.
Deadassh
Emergency Pods
I love these. They have really great information. You two are spectacular at presenting your information and back grounds
sfd43
Emergency episodes
I’m grateful for the emergency episodes- please keep them up
BHinChiTown
Iran and Syria
I usually enjoy TRIC, but the session addressing uprisings in Iran (part 2) I found exceptionally interesting. I remember the 1979-80 uprising and have worked, side by side, with several Iranian petroleum engineers who left Iran in that time frame.. I also enjoyed McCloskey‘s discussions of his time dealing with the Syrian uprising, which is the subject of his excellent novel dealing with Damascus. I traveled through Syria in 1975, saw Damascus, including the Blue Mosque and the tomb of Salad Al Din, went out to Palmyra, Hama, Homs and Aleppo early in the Assad regime, before ISIS and long before the uprising documented in McCloskey’s book. It’s by far my favorite of his four books. I think this session dealing with current events in Iran is very insightful and I appreciated hearing McCloskey‘s background in terms of the way he understands Iran today. Thank you. (Forgive typos.)
Read more
AintWhatIUsedToBe
