The Professor Is In
The Professor Is In
The Professor Is In
Reviews
via Podcasts
Those who can’t, grift
Failed academic who has parlayed her failure into a multi-media grift based on misinformation and scare-mongering. Stay away, don’t pay!
podcrust
Vague and not practical
They talk so much with each other about the things that are clear to them but not to others and they don't try to explain them further! I wasn't feeling good listening to them. Something is wrong with this podcast….
Nora_The_Psychologist
No!
Karen and her team’s views are not all correct and some of them are outdated. Sometimes they just want you to buy their service, which is quite expensive. I listened to her podcast and bought her service but very disappointed. My sincere suggestion is that finding senior or junior professors or cohorts in your field and ask their opinion. Believe me—that’s way more helpful and correct!
Struggling PhD Student
Essential for academics
Karen and her team offer practical, insightful tips and advice for ABD and nontenured academic professionals. Listen and learn !
Cmc22368264
Real talk about academia
I started listening to this podcast in my final year of grad school and am really glad I did. Hosts Karen and Kel, as well as their interviewees, bring a grounded, self-aware, realistic, nuanced, and generous perspective to various topics related to surviving and thriving as an intellectual with ethics, whether inside or outside the academy.
chime714
Essential listening for academics
Great podcast! Karen and Kel talk straight and to the point. . .very useful. They helped me to be okay with leaving academia. Thank you so much for that!!!
Ericjc
Helpful but rambling, not well delivered
This is the first podcast I listened to that helped me come to grips that I needed to leave academia. It was helpful and nice to have “people to commiserate with”, but I have a hard time listening to it because the delivery seems very unorganized. They repeat themselves a lot across episodes, interrupt each other, and go on tangents that are not always related or helpful. It’s an ok podcast, but not a favorite.
Read more
laurasia11
Much needed content, terrible delivery
The questions raised and the ensuing detailed discussions between the hosts contain much needed and hard to find information for graduate students. However, the delivery is awful. The constant (and at times excessive) excited sounds take away from the in depth conversation. Worse still is the constant interruption of one host by the other. I really wanted to continue listening and tried, but just couldn’t after a point since I would be annoyed at having to focus extra hard to listen to and make sense of the actual content and having to filter the unnecessary ups and down in the voices and the interruptions.
Read more
JainUrvashi
Holy Guacamole this is good!
People people people. What can I say? this show is so amazing.It is empowering people to take a hard look at the Academy, their trajectory, their health and well-being. And the hosts are so funny, and so generous and so vulnerable and strong. I mean it’s a real gift to get this kind of unguarded insights into the Academy.Plus, it’s super funny, because Karen and Kel riff and roll -with a wide range of things to pull from to make a point. I would suggest that they have an opportunity for people who want to donate to the show, but may not want to do a monthly thing. and, one more point about the toxic relationship with the Academy. I would recommend the Buddhist saying, “let go or be dragged.”
Read more
Lolabaird
Highly recommend this podcast!
I’ve been following Karen’s work since I read her book “The Professor Is in” when I started my PhD program. Although I’m lucky to have a supportive advisor and a community around me, it’s still eye opening and very informative to listen to the podcast. I especially recommend it to anyone who is on the job market as they discuss the undeniable impact of COVID-19 pandemic on the academic job market and how candidates can navigate these unprecedented territory. Karen and Kel are honest and well-informed, and they’re genuinely interested in helping folks. Thank you!
Read more
Theprofessorisalmostin
Helpful information in a Conversational Format
I’ve enjoyed following the Professor Is In in multiple formats throughout my graduate career. The podcast is a wonderful addition to the resources provided by this crew. Karen and Kel don’t sugarcoat and they give such good information in their podcasts. My only qualm with the series overall is that the conversational style has a tendency to go off-track regularly. I would love to see this evolve into more of a structured podcast in the future!
Read more
karlily42
Promoting self-reflection
The Professor Is In podcasts were a breath of fresh air given this year we’ve had. Having my tenure application denied was huge professional blow and prompted some deep reflection on my relationship with academia. Feeling betrayed by my department and the whole enterprise - Karen and Kel are like the mentors I never had - telling me the dark truths about the system I dived head first into without a map to guide me. Hopefully, with this second go around on TT, I’ll do it with more insight and awareness of my self worth and value in the academy and beyond.
Read more
second go around TT
Highly recommend this podcast
I liked the recorded episodes, you can listen to it while driving. This is recommended for all in the academic job market.
Basileusz
Highly recommended$
I highly recommend this podcast to any grad student in the job market!
Katty MA
Highly suggest all services from Professor is In
Every time, I learn a new thing from The Professor is In group that moves me positively in my path in academia!
mmary2021
So grateful for Karen's advice and the podcast!
I wish every PhD student, postdoc and TT prof had the opportunity to get Karen and Kel's advice. After listening to the podcast, and after Karen's edits to some of my documents I feel prepared to apply for new positions. I listen to the podcast on my way to work, I smile when they joke about the mistakes people make during the interviews (I made the majority of those mistakes the first times (couple of years) I interviewed as a postdoc. Now I think that perhaps I could have gotten my dream job if I had already followed their advice. I don't miss any podcast episode now. They are gold! Thank you Karen and Kel!!
Read more
AssistProfAbroad
Honest and to the point
I gained so much insight of the academic job market from Karen and Kel. They are honest, direct, and open. I would be spending more time to learn from mistakes without them. I recommend this podcast to anyone trying to get into academia.
adjunct looking for full time
Much needed information for any academic!!
The Professor is in, hands down, is the best advisor I’ve ever had. Listen to this podcast, buy the book, and really listen to all the advice. I’ve been a fan for years! Thank you so much!!!
Drake DogCB
The advice you need!
I started listening to this podcast when I was admitted in my PhD program. Some colleagues had told me Dr. Kelsky’s book was awesome and I wanted to know more about the kind of advice she gave to graduate students. I find the podcast episodes very informative and insightful. The topics covered are not usually discussed in academic programs (unfortunately!), and I appreciate that Dr. Kelsky’s advice is always direct and honest. I would certainly recommend other graduate students to give it a try!
Read more
IH Ruiz
Honest truths
I look forward to new episodes as I’m currently navigating the job cycle. They provide honest and helpful information that makes me feel better but also prepares me for the worst. Thanks for providing an outlet during this crazy, unprecedented time.
MA BCBA
Can’t Support Karen
Her model is to make you feel like you need her help to succeed- this isn’t true. Listen to Syracuse University’s GradCast podcast instead. And then also go to your own university’s career center for help.
Jennifer686
The Advice and Straight Talk You Need!
I would be totally lost in the job search process without these podcasts and The Professor is In webcasts and services. The podcasts are a welcome part of my day, gives me a break but also helps me prepare. The straight talk about the academic career is such a great help, fills in all the gaps left by getting so little advice on these matters and it highlights things I need to consider and prepare for that I hadn't ever thought of.
Read more
GradStudentOntheJobMarket
Helpful and Honest
Karen and Kel pull back the curtain on the academy and show you forces are at work to undermine you and strategies you can use to counteract them. Along with this podcast, I recommend Karen's book and Kel's Art of Productivity coaching. This podcast is an easy way for me to consume the advice in a more relaxed setting; I usually listen while doing the dishes. :) Thank you, Karen and Kel, for all you do to make the invisible visible and bolster the knowledge base of non-dominant groups.
Read more
PHDCOMPLETE
Exactly what I need
Whether you are trying to get an academic gig, survive academia once you’re in, or leave to preserve your sanity, “The Professor is In” is the podcast for you. I first found Kel and Karen five or six years ago as a grad student. I used Karen’s book to write my successful proposal to get a postdoctoral fellowship. I joined Karen’s webinar on interviewing on campus before my first job application and enrolled in one of Kel’s first versions of the class online “Unstuck: The Art of Productivity,” which helped me think through academic work of multiple kinds. Now, as an accidental academic, I live by their weekly podcasts. Kel and Karen draw on their own experiences, their work with clients, and ongoing evolutions in academia and its political contexts to guide listeners through the river of life. What I love most about Kel and Karin is their candor and kindness, how deeply they listen to others and reflect on their own practices together. Such a pleasure. Can’t recommend their podcast—and all other products—highly enough. —Jen Henderson
Read more
DexterT
LIsten to this BEFORE signing up for gradschool
Their advice is what Gradschool does not want you to know not only once you are in there, but also before you join. Had I listened to this podcast before joining gradschool, I would have had a chance to stay put where I was instead of thinking that those three magic letters after my name would have redefined me and given me intellectual satisfaction and a better career. Maybe I would have stayed put where I was, and never gotten a phD. Fine--it would not have made me any worse to be less specialized. Or maybe I would have done it anyway, but I would have been on the driverseat in deciding the skills to learn.
Read more
panirani
Even if you don’t want to, do it
This is the good part of this—Karen and Kel tell you what you don’t want to hear, but not what your supervisor will tell you. As a grad student who just couldn’t get the untold rules of the academic market, the professor is in spelled them out for me, even those I didn’t know I needed to know. As an ex grad student who still has a lot to learn, now for me AND for my students, i find so important to break with the custom of the implicit academia. But I do not have the luxury of browsing blogs, so I am glad I can listen to you!
Read more
ex grad student
I Recommend this Podcast and Book to ALL of my Academic Friends
When going on the job market the first time, I did not use Karen’s book, even though I technically had a grant writing chart that was written by Karen printed out waaaaaaaay back during my master’s degree education. I just didn’t know who Karen was at the time. My original job documents were fine; I got a tenure track position, but they certainly were “weepy” about teaching and were not presenting myself or my accomplishments in the best way possible. Fast forward to my second attempt at the job market, during the COVID-19 pandemic no less, and this podcast has been INVALUABLE. The updated job documents, interview, and campus visit podcasts have been SO helpful along the way. Karen and Kel speak from their experience along with that of their clients in a way that is relatable but also provides the hard facts of what happens at each stage of the job search process. Single Best Segment: The Kayaking Metaphor. IFYKYK.
Read more
leapin_lizzard
Listen to this Podcast!
Perhaps due to being inundated with the ideology of rugged individualism, I was skeptical about asking for help beyond what my university professors taught me. I am so glad that I got over myself. This podcast (and the accompanying services) are absolutely invaluable for those on a graduate school trajectory with eyes towards a related professional career. Waste no more time, if you have the idea that you want a job in higher education: listen to this podcast.
Read more
MJ Kiran
A supportive and no-nonsense take on all things academia
I started listening to this podcast after I finished Dr. Kelsky’s book and I appreciate the candor in both the topic choices and the discussions within. At so many points in their discussions, I feel seen and heard. I thoroughly enjoy and appreciate the frank and realistic pep-talk theme throughout episodes and also all the resources and support provided.
shlayman
I look forward to new episodes every week
This podcast has been a great resource during the pandemic. But even the old pre-covid episodes are great.
podcastshelpmesleep
Thankful for this resource!
As someone who is in the final years of her doc program, this podcast (as well as all of their web resources!) offers excellent advice. The practical solutions and realistic situations Karen and Kel discuss help demystify academia and make it more inclusive. Not to mention, they have a great chemistry that shines through the podcast along with their expertise.
PhoebesMama
Informative for postdocs
This podcast gets what it’s like to be in academia for the right reasons, and gives us the savvy to navigate the politics. Two thumbs up.
GoingForTenure
Dr. Karen has been very helpful
I am an international doctoral student looking for an academic job. I bought Dr. Karen’s book a year ago and it was extremely helpful. I have also been a follower of Dr. Karen’s Facebook page for a long time, and now I am listening to her podcast now. Just two week ago, I passed an online interview and I am moving onto the next step: campus visit. That’s why I am checking this podcast and her webinars again. Her knowledge is solid and her advice is professional.
Read more
Nicknamecanbetough
Amazing resources!
Amazing resources! Each episode of the podcast I’ve found so helpful in navigating different stages of the job search, application, interviews, and beyond. I love listening to the episodes to give myself a break from reading after a day of writing and just being in front of a screen between dissertation writing and work. And it’s so enjoyable, which is a plus!
dana_nyc
It’s the only thing out there, but
They have a market cornered, and their advice can be helpful. But their dynamic on mic is super weird and distracting. It’s good they disagree sometimes but it can get cringe-worthy.
yiddishistke88
Poorly Organized, Talk About Themselves TOO MUCH
I am over eight minutes into episode 28 and you’re still advertising. I can go to the office of any white male professor in my department and have a conversation about academia with less self promotion and self absorption that this — and that’s saying something. I know and respect what you’re trying to do and that you need to make a living. That said, you need to take some of your own criticisms to heart because at this point you’re no different from the people you’re criticizing. Focus on your audience, not yourselves. Second, your episodes have become increasingly difficult to follow. I think this is likely because you don’t edit enough. Instead, listeners have to try to follow tangent after tangent. Figure out what you want to say and then say it. A conversational tone is good, but the message has to still be discernible. It’s not, and although I think that what you’re trying to say is probably valuable, I can get the message in a much more straightforward way from other sources.
Read more
Theodora548
Thank you for this exceptional podcast!
Academia is so stressful and is riddled with gaslighting, unspoken expectations, and oppressive hierarchies and power dynamics. This podcast helps uncover the “hidden curriculum” of academia. This is a must listen for early career academics!
podcast obsessed grad student
A must-listen for current or recovering academics
I was an university instructor for 13 years and my partner is tenured. This podcast is gold for both of us in being able to understand that what we’ve experienced and plan our lives moving forward. I listen to it every week while I’m sweeping the floors and it’s a balm to the part of me that wonders: “Was all that dysfunction just me?”
Nicknamenicknamenicknam
My weekley tether to sanity: Pure podcast gold!
For any academic, this is pure podcast gold. Karen and Kel bring enlightenment in an age academic gaslighting, and the podcast is the latest medium through which their font of academic career wisdom burbles forth. (The [free!] blog, the book, the webinars, and the YEARS of their indescribably helpful archived Facebook Live videos which are only available to subscribers--these also are pure gold). Their advice was indispensable to me getting through graduate school and building a CV that could turn my PhD into a job, and as a newly minted PhD from the Class of 2020, their podcast is now my weekly tether to sanity. The entire point of TPII from its inception was truth: truth about how academia works as an institution of late capitalism, truth about how the tenured university professorship is disappearing, and truth about how academia menaces new academics' mental health and financial security. In every episode, Karen and Kel lay out the unvarnished truth with compassion and with the tools for the listener to better confront the realities of academia and career transitions beyond academia--and, now, the surreal world of total system collapse because of the COVID-19 pandemic in the face of merry university chancellors' rosy denial of that collapse. These "wise aunties" complement each other in this crusade of truth. Karen often focuses on telling the truth about big picture power structures in academia, while Kel often exhorts us to tell the truth about ourselves as writers and workers. Together, they make visible the holistic human being that the cult of academia and the corporatized university have transfigured into a machine cog, and they empower their scholar-listeners to reprioritize themselves as people and as professionals instead of internalizing the subordinate dependency that PhD programs can inculcate in their students. These truths emerge organically in the podcast through the dialogue between Karen and Kel (and between them and their subscribers' and followers' questions and comments). Even their conversations' most whimsical meanderings frequently end up tracking down new profundities like pigs sniffing out truffles. This benevolent, acerbic duo was already terrific, but their podcast is all the more important a beacon of truth in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. Karen and Kel confront head-on the uncertainty and anxiety gripping everyone now, and for me the podcast has been the closest thing I wish to experience to listening to the BBC during the Blitz: Everything is not OK, the old normal will not return, and here is what we can do individually and collectively to survive. Whether you're a grad student now or already have your degree, whether you're pursuing an academic career or are transitioning to a new career, you have come to the right place. The compassionate real talk from this podcast and from all of TPII's media will help you reclaim your sanity, complete your PhD, plan your career, and put your experience in higher education in service of YOUR own interest instead of your advisor's, your program's, the academic cult's, or your capitalist overlords' interests. Thank you, Karen and Kel!
Read more
Dr. Jeffrey, PhD
Insightful and generous podcast
Karen and Kel are the wise aunties every academic needs in their life. This podcast (and all of their resources) includes K&K’s insights from vast experience in their own academic careers and helping so many other academics navigate theirs. Their compassionate and realist takes have been indispensable for me as I struggle with finishing my dissertation, get on the job market, and raise a toddler. That they are looking for ways to make their knowledge and wisdom more accessible to all through free venues like podcasts and Twitter speaks to their generous spirits. Highly recommended listening!
Read more
Tori rose p
Cheaper than therapy
But the same conclusions! These women are so insightful. This is helping me get clarity on the last ten years of my life and I am so grateful. Also I want them to adopt me.
post PhD
How to Academia 101
If there ever were a syllabus on How to Academia 101, this podcast would be on it as required listening. The episode, “Why You Need a 5-Year Plan,” alone is revelatory. If you want to learn how to protect your time from the admin abyss; identify how fear and shame operate in academia; and get a better grip on the unspoken expectations of the PhD and tenure-track system, give this a listen. Plus their banter makes the whole experience feel like you’re attending the office hours of 2 trusted, wisecracking advisors who have Seen It All and aren’t afraid to tell you the truth. I hope this class never gets dismissed.
Read more
BartlebytheScrivener1853
wow
could episode seven be more condescending to people who have no choice but to adjunct or ... work at Target?
heartsparks
Eyes Wide Open
I just listened to the “Adjuncting is Bad” episode, and it spoke so true to me. My work, time, and focus as an Adjunct have changed as a result. Thank you SO MUCH for painting the picture so clearly. I’m so happy I found this podcast!
Endangered Peace
The Professor is In just keeps getting better
I love everything TPII puts out and this podcast is no exception - I started listening at the beginning of my PhD and I’m now at the end with lots of first author publications, fellowships, and a clear head as I work towards post doc and TT positions. The hosts are the perfect complement to each other - honest, compassionate, and with a great sense of wry humor.
Bmr.1111
This podcast helps you take charge of your academic life
I am so happy when I listen to this podcast each week! I am a tenured associate prof, and I have actually saved almost all of the episodes to re-listen to later. Karen and Kel consistently provide helpful information that is applicable at any stage of your career, and they do it in such an insightful, smart, funny, and empathetic way. I can only imagine how my trajectory might have been different if I’d known about The Professor Is In as a grad student.
Read more
msspanish
Very Empowering Podcast!
This podcast is awesome! I’m wrapping up my PhD and currently applying for postdoc and other positions. The episode on Mastering Your Messaging for an Interview has been very helpful as I am getting ready for my first campus visit. It’s helped me feel empowered to communicate clearly and effectively about my research and how much I have to offer to the department. I also really appreciate how real Karen and Kel get about life in academia. It helps to know I am not alone in some of the challenges I’ve faced in my PhD. Wherever I end up (academia or alt-ac), I am going to do whatever I can to create a space where people can challenge the system, the biases, the problems without fear of reprisal. And knowing there are lots of people who want this and that we all have resources like this gives me hope!
Read more
Fissionary24
Immediately helpful information
I found my niche in academia in a staff position without a PhD and even after only listening to a few episodes this podcast helped me! First, I got a nice reminder that I can engage in scholarship no matter where I am and I don’t have to listen to the nagging voice that says I have to complete a PhD to be valid. Second, the first episode I listened to was the five year plan which happened to be the same week as my annual review planning session. By taking K and K’s advice and sketching out a few longer term goals I was help to much more clearly define for myself and my supervisors what I needed out of the next year to get closer to those goals. It already makes me feel more purposeful and less stuck in a rut. Thanks for all of your work!
Read more
carrolca
Love the Professor is In and Love the Podcast
The Professor is In is the most important podcast you’ll listen to if you are at any stage of the academic life. Both Karen and Kel help you through so many different experiences that academics deal with. If you are a graduate student, going on the job market, or in academia, you must listen to this. :)
Alexi L
Karen and Kel Offer the Best Professional Advice
Loving the podcast! I just wanted to let you know I have already implemented your advice from Episode 3. Someone reached out to ask if I was interested in putting together a teaching presentation for a conference in just a few weeks. I have a good personal and professional relationship with this person, and I know they are in a bit of a bind, but I did not have the time. So instead of getting caught up in my emotions, I thought back to what I heard you both say as I was driving to and from campus yesterday, replied with a thank you and followed your advice to say that, "I will check my calendar and get back to you tomorrow." I said no to the presentation, and then (using the same technique) said no to putting together a workshop at my institution in the fall with a colleague who is pleasant but unreliable and honestly, not good to work with. A few days later, a friend at a different institution reached out to see if I wanted to co-author a short paper with a quick deadline on a topic of great interest to me. Because I said no to those other things, I was available to say yes to an interesting project I really want to work on that has a quick turnaround. Really, this is life changing advice for academics. Y'all are wonderful!
Read more
TPII Fan
Load more