Reviews
via Podcasts
My mother had CJD
My mother had CJD and I’d like to tell her story. It took her in 9 weeks and left my family with a life time of pain.
Clea Dee
What happened to the Show 😭
I love this podcast! I have learned so much! Please come back!
E Greenough
Where did y’all go??
This podcast was so good!!! I sure hope to hear more episodes in the future!!
hillmarla
Miss the podcast
I really enjoyed this podcast, wish we’d get more episodes:(
SluethGurl
Platform for patient ranting, but otherwise no helpful information
As someone who is graduating medical school shortly, I have so many problems with this podcast.
While I appreciate that it gives patients a space to talk about their experiences, it leans heavily towards the patient’s side, the “doctors did nothing for me” side. Your primary care doctor didn’t diagnose your very rare disease the first time they met you? They didn’t gaslight you or brush off your concerns. They did the best they could with the information they had at the time. Also, I’ve worked in an ER for years before med school and you’d be surprised how many times I hear patients say “they did nothing for me in the ER last time” and I look back at the records and they had labs, imaging, medication, etc. So as much good as this podcast tries to do by giving patients a voice, there’s absolutely no nuance and I’m truly shocked that Dr. Nance barely has anything to add, never standing up for her profession in a way that validates the guest but also helps listeners understand why certain medical decisions were made at certain times. She does pop in randomly to define medical terms, but it’s like she’s not even on the podcast, she just randomly records bits and they get dumped in the podcast.
Additionally, I would like to direct your attention to the YouTube video “The Debate Around This Fat Disorder” by Colin Mockery. It’s a very well researched video about lipedema, and some of the (in)famous lipedema influencers who are actually problematic (Anna O’Brien). She is spreading misinformation about this medical condition, notably that lipedema fat is non burnable and must be removed with liposuction, and that weight has nothing to do with lipedema. That’s completely wrong and it’s so harmful and also disrespectful to the lipedema community. She spends a lot of time on this podcast talking about herself, attempting to relate to the guests, but it just comes off as rude.
I appreciate that this podcast tried to give a platform to patients and help others understand what it’s like to have certain diseases or go through the process of diagnosis or navigate the healthcare system, but it really just feels people ranting and no helpful information. And also a host actively spreading harm and misinformation.
Read more
Naomi ^_^
Addicted!
I am hooked on this podcast! So much better than similar ones that have wasted chit chat. Y’all let the guest talk almost the entire time about the problem and how it was solved. It’s also made me realize I need to always go with my gut feeling about medical things and not to be afraid to get other opinions. Keep up the good work! I can tell y’all put a lot into each episode!!
Sparker300
Great informative podcast
I found Dr. Nance on social media and knew I had to listen to her podcast. It absolutely does not disappoint. The hosts help to think about how we can be empowered in our own health journeys.
BrandiS1
Love this podcast
I absolutely love this podcast! Please continue making content. You are my go to and I’ve listen to every episode at least nice.
Lm_inthesun
Come Back
I look forward to your pod cast, I’ve listened to everyone of them, sometimes more than once. I’m really hoping that there will be new ones soon!
TLWelsh1958
Come back!!!
I just discover your podcast and see it has been almost two months without a new episode. I need you guys to come back!
1975zttn
Awesome podcast
My husband and I are veterinarians and love your show. The human healthcare system is nuts!!! Please make more!
Reeeebz
What’s going on?
Great podcast! I hope everyone is ok. Please let us know what is going on. I miss TMD.
Mother Hen of 3
Please come back!
Mr. Ballen ended his medical mysteries show, leaving a void you need to fill! Please don’t give up. I’m a YouTuber (chemistry, Xenon and Friends) and I know there’s competition but if you quit that’s it! Please come back!
coo coo cah choo
what happened?🥺
i listened in every week & it helped buffer when i listen to TDD😭 please come back :(
maggie🦉
Where did they go?
What happened? No episodes since November?
Nurse1961
Missing ya’ll
I am missing ya’ll and anticipating the next episode. Is everything ok? Did I miss an announcement? Thank you for all you do!!!
Unlicensed medical diagnose.
Anna has no business passing along medical advice
Anna O’Brien is seriously contending that she is a medial mystery with “no burnable fat” despite losing nearly 100 pounds on Wegovy because she’s not a mystery - caloric deficit works. She advocates for dangerous surgeries that no doctor of good standing would allow for a patient who is still 300 pounds overweight. And comparing obesity to some of these other serious illnesses is beyond tone deaf. It is time to hang up this ridiculous podcast.
I am editing my review to note that it’s downright comical that so many folks dismiss the correct criticism of Anna’s dangerous misinformation as “fatphobia.” Nope, try again. 🙄 So much coping happening here.
Read more
SadieHawkins85
Love your podcast!!
Where is next story? I am waiting for the next one this week.
Anyway I listened to all your podcasts and got hooked. Some people really have to fight for their life!! Thanks for sharing.
everyday girl
Great podcast!
I look forward to this Podcast every week. I’ve had somewhat of a medical mystery so I really appreciate these stories
garddog14
Everyone here is fatphobic
The main issue everyone with giving low rates is the fact that Anna co hosts. I’ve followed her story for a while outside of the podcast and it’s still a work in progress. Not sure why everyone’s tearing down this podcast specifically because I’ve heard way worse podcasts with amazing reviews! I personally love this podcast and as they said, you shouldn’t take anything as medical advice. They literally say that several times. It’s up to you as a patient to use your common sense to look up anything you’re curious about or ask someone credible. Don’t blame podcast hosts sharing stories for medical misinformation?? They weren’t diagnosing you anyway. I find the hosts very validating especially with the current average patient experience
Read more
Sir Paulrus
Such a great show!!
I started listening to the podcast from episode one. I love it so much. I didn’t even realize it was Dr. Nance hosting until I saw a short on YouTube. I used to watch Dr. Nance in IG and TikTok all the time. She got me hooked on medical cases that were truly crazy. Both hosts are so amazing and I keep telling all my friends about you!! Thank you for all you do!!
FanOfSugarRay
Murine Typhus
I want to extend my heartfelt thanks to Mollie, the producer, Anna, and Dr. Nance for giving me the opportunity to share my story. They were so welcoming and compassionate throughout the process. I truly believe this podcast will make a meaningful difference by helping doctors, nurses, and patients recognize and diagnose challenging cases. Thank you again for allowing me to be part of this important conversation.
Read more
92832
So helpful and educational
As an RN, I love this podcast and have learned so much. It's valuable to have the information and journey from the patient’s and families’ perspectives. As a patient with an autoimmune disease myself, I appreciate the long and convoluted path that finding a diagnosis as well as an effective treatment can be.
D_is_the_bee
Love this show!
I have learned sooooo much from this show that is helping me with my own medical journey!!!
Erin Lorraine
Too judgmental
Used to enjoy these and there have been so great and interesting stories but the last few I’ve listened to and especially this last one now the hosts are totally gaslighting the medical community and making assumptions on what the providers were thinking when obviously the involved parties did not communicate well with them all that was going on.
Arosebok
Narcan and Naltrexone are not the same
Very irresponsible comment by the doctor host. These drugs are very different. Narcan is used as an emergency drug for overdoses. You could lead someone to believe they are interchangeable. Please correct!
Mandi Wray
Love the pod
I enjoy your podcast so much. God bless the woman with the esophagus issue, for 12 years. My son had a tracheo-esophageal fistula at birth, which was repaired, but has a narrowing due to scar tissue. Food gets stuck there and he’ll not be able to swallow anything until it’s scoped.
KendraM61
Disrespectful
Dr. Nance needs to take a step back and show a little more respect for general practitioners. It's great that she is so specialized and wonderful that she has that education. She obviously has no respect for family practice and it shows. When speaking about a family practice physician she said "she wouldn't have had the capacity to understand the symptoms." The stories are interesting but the hosts are trash.
Read more
Yesthatsmyopinion94
Informational
Very informative and makes me more conscious and aware as I visit doctors!
I have a coworker that was suffering from hand/feet numbness & after listening to all the stories her symptoms sounded familiar (heard on this podcast).
I recommended that she ask her doctor to test her for peripheral neuropathy- she still has tests to be performed but so far her neurologist suggested that is most likely her diagnosis based on previous imaging sent over from another doctor.
Read more
Kelsey✨✨✨
Shameless
I was so excited to potentially find out what is causing the swelling in my left ankle! Too bad for me!!!! The only difference between this podcast and a visit to any specialist is the cost. Shame on every one of you.
Bellamammal
Love this show!
Just listen to part 1 of the most recent episode aired. As a medical speech pathologist for over 20 years, I really appreciate how both the hosts explain things to people in non medical terminology. Great job!
LaKav8
Anna’s lies
This is more a review of Anna, one of the co-hosts, and what she has said in this podcast and in her social media
Anna regularly lies and changes her history many many times. Now she keeps claiming to have multiple autoimmune diseases and refuses to name them. She pushes medical misinformation, goes to see less than ethical doctors, and refuses to take actual advice from professionals. She is harming a community that she claims to be in and wants to speak for. But she refuses to use her platform to o anything. She is just faking.
Read more
RealSpoonie
Brought me hope
As someone currently navigating my own medical mystery journey- I LOVE this show! I have learned how to advocate better for myself, understand the 7 steps so I don’t get stuck when I feel like giving up, and I’m learning how to research & prepare better for my dr appointments. I appreciate the knowledge, detailed stories, humor, and empathy in this show. Thank you for creating this show!
Tiphanyk
Anna is a liar.
Anna has been changing her story for years she’s not credible, she doctor shops for quacks (imo) and this screams a bid for attention from a new audience that wouldn’t recognize her from anywhere else. She tries to take over episodes that aren’t about her when people should just be able to tell their stories.
Mck-L
So many things I didn’t know
This podcast should be listened to by all women. To learn how to advocate for yourself, when doctors aren’t listening to anything you’re saying
MindysCustomVinyl
I love Dr. Nance
I have followed her on TikTok for a while. She responds to almost everyone. Thank you for listening and thank you for giving us a voice.
MrsGinaGio
So interesting!
This is one of my favorite podcasts-I look forward to new episodes each Wednesday. I learn something new each time.
kitty4flit
Interesting stories BUT
Interesting stories but there are some obvious biases and political leanings. I find the victim mentality grating (I say this as someone with multiple chronic illnesses). There are some great conversations that happen and the stories take you on a journey. So there are pros and cons to the show. If you can overlook some of the shortcomings, there is some thought provoking stuff here.
lmd0137
Great show
This is a great show but it can be hard to get through. It’s emotional and heavy but very informative.
Absolutely worth the listen.
ThatAisFace
One of my new favorites
Great show
KG2purplegirl
Amazing highly needed podcast!
So far I have had three of the conditions they have covered. Trigeminal neuralgia, optical neuralgia, hEDS & POTS. Luckily I am annoying persistent and since I broke my neck in 2003 had four I spinal and brain stem surgeries- I do not use opioid based pain medications, I was always taken very seriously. Listening to these stories I feel very lucky.
Missy Scarlett
Eye opening and educational
Thank you for doing this podcast. My dad and I listen to this every week together, and we learn something new every time. Sadly I am not surprised by how broken our medical system is and it is so frustrating how many people are dismissed because they don’t fit a certain “criteria “.
CollinsonClaire
Stay away
While the subjects deserve sympathy, the producers of this podcast picked the absolute worst hosts, especially Anna O’Brien. She has no medical credentials whatsoever and is mainly known as a super morbidly obese social media influencer who believes that her condition is the result of a range of rare diseases and genetics. It’s insulting to truly sick people who are looking for answers.
The Adipose Knows
Another snarky Dr
Erin, drop the defensive attitude. These people came on your show, western medicine is a terrible system. You come right up to the edge of empathy and compassion and then hide on your Dr defensive safe space.
AlisaMarieBDP
Great show!!
I’m a pharmacist, 22 years on the job and I love listening to these stories! Sometimes I have an idea of where we’re headed and sometimes I’m along for the mystery ride. Dr. Erin has a wonderful way of explaining things so everyone can understand.
MackpharmD
Eye opening
Thank you for sharing the stories of patients that have lived with these conditions for many before receiving answers. You are bringing awareness to issues that so many face but struggle to be understood.
Knsbatten
Super Interesting
I really look forward to this show every week. The stories are detailed and well told and I am always fascinated by the amount of rare diseases there are. It’s always interesting and informative. One of my favorite podcasts!
JusssstMeee
Fellow Lippy Sister
I was brought to tears listening to Anna bravely share her story. I am in my early 40’s and dealing with a recent-ish Lipoedema myself. This disease is so misunderstood and blamed on the person suffering with few solutions offered. Shame does not help anyone. Compassion does. Thank you for sharing, Anna, and to you and Dr N for providing a platform for other who have felt abused/gaslighted by Big Medicine and Big Pharma.
Read more
ReaganlovesMommy
Mystery & Medical all in one!
I am absolutely HOOKED! If you are a fan of mysteries & were ever a fan of Grey’s or ER this is the one for you. I love that each show explains REAL medical mysteries, by the people living with it. Anna is the majority of us asking “wait, what is that?” This show also teaches you to persevere in being your or a loved one’s medical advocate.
crewof9
Important
This podcast is so important for everyone to hear. It’s heartbreaking and beautiful at the same time.
Vazquezzz6
