The Looking Glass
The Looking Glass
The Looking Glass
Reviews
via Podcasts
Contra Mr. Karpel
Host Matthew Kraig Kelly here. First, thank you to everyone who left a nice review, including all those who kindly gave us five stars. I notice that in the two cases where someone left a negative review, one reviewer listened to a single episode and the other to a single mini-episode. Neither, that is, actually listened to the podcast to which they so hastily gave a one-star review. I find that encouraging. I do feel the need to address the more substantive of these two reviews, which is that left by Richard Karpel, who claims I make numerous errors of fact in Mini-Episode 1 –– which, perhaps tellingly, Mr. Karpel mistakenly refers to as Episode 7. Let’s reviews these alleged errors. First, Mr. Karpel writes: “Podcast host Matthew Kraig Kelly says Malcolm did to Joe McGinness [sic] precisely what she claimed in TJATM he had done to Jeffrey MacDonald –– present himself as a sympathetic chronicler while planning to assault MacDonald in the version of events ultimately published in Fatal Vision.” The qualifier “precisely” is Mr. Karpel’s, not mine. What I do is quote the famed journalist Bob Keeler: “Listening to Malcolm’s sympathetic conversations with McGinniss, it quickly becomes clear that she did to him what McGinniss had done to MacDonald: namely, ‘worm her way into the confidence of somebody and then turn around and screw him,’ to paraphrase the journalist Bob Keeler.” Did McGinniss “plan” all along “to assault MacDonald”? Did Malcolm plan all along to assault McGinniss? Neither I nor Keeler says anything of the sort. Rather, we say Malcolm gained McGinniss’s confidence and then destroyed his reputation just as McGinniss had gained MacDonald’s confidence and then destroyed his reputation. No serious person disputes this fact. Mr. Karpel goes on to state that McGinniss’s relationship with MacDonald was more “extensive” than Malcolm’s with McGinniss, a fact to which he attaches an importance he neglects to explain. He then says that Malcolm’s whole “POINT” was that journalists invariably betray their subjects. But then I make the same observation. The sentence in Mini-Episode 1 immediately following the one quoted above reads: “We might give Malcolm points for consistency, at least, since she clearly believes that this is just what every journalist does to their subject.” Clearly, then, this POINT was not lost on me! Next, Mr. Karpel writes: “Kelly also dishonestly claims Malcolm says she is too smart ever to consider empirical evidence and confidently draw a conclusion in a dispute over facts like those that lay at the heart of Fatal Vision. She said nothing of the kind. She merely said she wasn’t interested in delving into the details of the MacDonald case because it wasn’t relevant to her thesis.” Who is being dishonest here? Put another way, who actually quotes Malcolm, me or Mr. Karpel? I do, as follows: "I have read little of the material [Jeffrey MacDonald] has sent –– trial transcripts, motions, declarations, affidavits, reports. A document arrives, I glance at it, see words like ‘bloody syringe,’ ‘blue threads,’ ‘left chest puncture,’ ‘unidentified fingerprints,’ ‘Kimberly’s urine,’ and add it to the pile. I know I cannot learn anything about MacDonald’s guilt or innocence from this material. It is like looking for proof or disproof of the existence of God in a flower –– it all depends on how you read the evidence. If you start out with a presumption of his guilt, you read the documents one way, and another way if you presume his innocence. The material does not ‘speak for itself.’” Does Malcolm say the evidence MacDonald sent her “wasn’t relevant to her thesis,” as Mr. Karpel claims? Not at all: “I know I cannot learn anything about MacDonald’s guilt or innocence from this material.” Her words, not mine. *She* claims looking at the evidence is a relativistic trap: “It all depends on how you read the evidence.” Finally, Mr. Karpel states that, because MacDonald sued McGinniss for fraud and breach of contract, his standing to sue the author did not hang on a line in the contract stipulating that the “essential integrity” of his life story be maintained in Fatal Vision. But of course this is false. The entire reason MacDonald’s attorney, Bernard Segal, added that line to the *contract* between MacDonald and McGinniss was in anticipation of the possibility that McGinniss would produce a book that implicated, rather than vindicated, MacDonald, thereby breaching said contract. In sum, and ironically, Mr. Karpel appears to have made as many errors in a handful of paragraphs as he thinks I made in a 14-minute episode. I retract nothing. And I humbly advise Mr. Karpel to take a beat before pressing “Submit” next time around.
Read more
Matthew Kraig Kelly
Willful misrepresentations
I listened only to Ep.7, and I did that only because I just finished reading Janet Malcolm’s The Journalist and The Murderer, which is the subject of the episode. But I found misrepresentations so egregious I felt the need to write this review to warn those who may be considering listening to this podcast. Podcast host Matthew Kraig Kelly says Malcolm did to Joe McGinness precisely what she claimed in TJATM he had done to Jeffrey MacDonald — present himself as a sympathetic chronicler while planning to assault MacDonald in the version of events ultimately published in Fatal Vision. First, Malcolm‘s relationship with McGinness wasn’t nearly as extensive as McGinness’ was to MacDonald, and her misrepresentations, if there were any, don’t come within a country mile of the fraud McGinness practiced on MacDonald. More importantly, the dilemma and potential immorality at the heart of the subject-journalist relationship, and the near certainty that the author will ultimately betray the subject, WAS THE POINT OF HER STORY. Kelly also dishonestly claims Malcolm says she is too smart ever to consider empirical evidence and confidently draw a conclusion in a dispute over facts like those that lay at the heart of Fatal Vision. She said nothing of the kind. She merely said she wasn’t interested in delving into the details of the MacDonald case because it wasn’t relevant to her thesis. I’ll end by noting that Jeffrey MacDonald sued Joe McGinness for fraud and breach of contract, not for libel or defamation. So Kelly’s contention that a line in the contract between McGinniss and MacDonald provided the “standing” MacDonald need to bring the lawsuit at the hear of TJATM, was also mistaken. That’s a lot to get wrong in a 14-minute episode with two or three minutes of commercials.
Read more
Richard Karpel
Fabulous
You do not show up when searching for Macdonald you might want to change that
121664
A lot of trust in a convicted triple murderer
I know a lot about the McDonald murders, and this guy makes the exact same mistake Errol morris does: he focuses on nearly everything besides Jeffrey McDonald, the implausibility of his story, and a many, many, many lies he told. (He told people he killed one of the killers!) Not everything is a conspiracy. Not all cops are bad cops. There are many people in jail for the wrong reasons. This white upper middle-class douche bag is not one of them.
Read more
mplnpyt
Awesome
Great writing and production. Loved a new perspective on one of the most interesting unsolved cases in history!!! Thank you Matthew!!!
lindseywilma
A wonderful listen
This podcast was recommend to me by a friend and I’m glad she shared it. The case is well-known but I’ve never heard it presented in such a thorough way before. Loved diving deep into this mystery.
Furliciouspodcast
Love it!
Very well done podcast! My new favorite!
Brittneycx
Fave new podcast!
Great storytelling on a case I thought I knew everything about. But after the first episode, I can already tell we will learn more. The hybrid way in which the story is being told (through actors reciting transcripts and our podcasters perspective) is very refreshing. I’m hooked!
kellyannbrown