This podcast brings so much joy to me week after week and I’m not even a huge sports fan! I love their banter, I love their opinions (woot woot Chicago!), I love their feelings about the current climate thrown in, I love it! There’s not an episode I don’t find myself laughing out loud (or learning). 10/10 recommend!

The Greatest is so. Much. Fun. Megan and CJ are hilarious and they always have great guests on. I admit that I’m not a major sports buff but I could listen to the banter on the podcast all day. Love y’all!

This podcast has gotten me through this terrible summer. I could listen to entire episodes of just the preshow banter. Every guest has been funny and insightful, and the chemistry is always fantastic. I am also a lifelong Colts fan from Indy, so I love the Colts stories and Patriots drags. Please keep them coming!

Love the show. My only bug-a-boo: Megan doesn’t yell at CJ enough.

I absolutely love you guys, thanks for another great episode! This may be too close to greatest sports duo, but I think an episode on the greatest sports friendships would be fun!

I listen too your podcasts and have loved everyone of them, and I love listening to your voice as you talk Megan. I do not wish to upset you or make you jealous CJ, but your wife’s voice, is truly one of the most sexist voices I have ever listened too. Megan You keep me totally interested, and listening to the topics you both are talking about. CJ You are a very lucky man indeed to have such a wonderful wife. She is a keeper. 👍 I wish You both the ever best, keep up the great work and keep this podcast going. As I have said I love ❤️ your show/podcast. And as I travel ✈️ throughout the World 🌎 I will keep listening. Best wishes The Flyawayman03 ✈️ Wally Z the 808 😎

Megan Gailey is a really talented comic. Her husband CJ Toledano is just as funny. Together, they love sports, and they have great guests who hold their own on the subjects. Highest recommendation!

Look, I get how the business works, but maaaan they’ve got too many ads on this. The content is fine, but every time they start getting on a roll conversationally, they take an ad break. It’s gotta be either twice as long of a podcast or half the ads. It’s just too chopped up

The married couple Megan and C.J. always have great chemistry together and with their guests. I love their discussions about their top three greatest athlete mother, sports press conference, stadium food, etc. Binging The Greatest has helped me survive the shelter in. And I can not wait consume more sports when this is over and go to a game to get some stadium food.

Firstly, apologies for the botched rating (I swear I updated it to 3 stars before sending. I hate that Apple doesn’t allow multiple reviews). Latest episode: Greatest Reggie Miller Moments Leaps and bounds improved and I couldn’t be happier. I waited an extra episode just to be sure it wasn’t a fluke lol (I loved the Greatest Sports Movies episode) The Reggie episode has it all though: they jumped straight into the discussion, acknowledging personal favs, great chemistry, engaging points, and—above all—a professional athlete/legend making a guest appearance for his own moments!!! Wow!! It was a joy to feel your excitement permeate the podcast as you interviewed your favorite player. Great questions asked and the respect/admiration Reggie mirrored back was amazing. Starting to think it was the previous guests that held you guys back (no offense to them). Keep it up guys!!

Wish they would have touched on The Cutting Edge in “Best Sports Movies” (figure skating movie from the 90’s) but their takes on literally everything are hilarious and amazing!

In D2 it was the Goodwill Games, not the Olympics! Maybe your wife would treat you better if you weren’t so wrong about everything!

I will be honest that I was almost afraid to listen to this episode. Would CJ just pick Space Jam 3 times because Jordan and Basketball seem to be the only sport and player he cares about? But I was pleasantly surprised. I agreed with EVERY SINGLE PICK. Even the honorable mentions. I want to especially call out Moneyball because as a teenager growing up in Oakland during this period you could say it’s my Space Jam and good for you CJ to pick something outside of Basketball. A league of their own, Remember the titans, Major League, Moneyball, the Sandlot, and the Mighty Ducks are the best sports movies of all time. Great episode! Five stars.

Energetic and funny podcast, great topics, very engaging. A few ideas for later episodes would be, biggest choke artists and athletes you love to hate.

For the past episodes they talk bout topics I don’t care about, like sports cameos, sneakers, etc. Talk about sports fans really care about like greatest NBA or NFL player of all time. Greatest teams all time. Come on so much debate and they choose C topics, I mean greatest cameos? Lol really.

I absolutely love this podcast. I’m a huge sports nerd and I love discussing sports and making lists about what I feel is the greatest as well. CJ and Megan would be awesome friends with Megan being the hot friend who talks sports. If they ever do an episode with a subscriber as a guest I hope they pick me lol. I like to think up my own list during their episode and see how it compares to there’s. Can’t wait for future episodes!

Great for even a casual sports fan!! Love the banter

I was in because of my love for David Gborie. But I’m out after only 25 minutes. The shoe obsession had me on the verge, the Doing Molly at your own wedding cemented it. Please seek marriage counseling immediately, good luck with your lives & priorities.

There are moments when this podcast is fun but those moments are few and far between. It appears they know a lot about basketball and very little on other sports. Their lists, no matter the topic, are 85% basketball. Greatest athlete cameo Charles Barkley in Space Jam? Greatest coach omitted ALL of the greatest coaches in every sport except basketball.

I do really enjoy this podcast. It’s more of a realistic conversation and banter that you and I would have on our favorites sports teams and players. I love listening to sports radio, but gah... sometimes it goes on and on about current topics or addressing yesterday’s news about Antonio Brown. I love being able to reminisce about all types of sports. It’s relaxing and fun and I find it completely relatable. Side note: How was there no honorable mention of Jimmy V..? C’mon guys.. Madness is right around the corner. Megan, I need more NCAA!

Great even you dgaf about sports!!

Really enjoying this podcast, even just as a casual sports fan. As a fellow Indy native, I find myself agreeing with most everything Megan says 😂 can’t wait for more episodes!

The bias of the female host towards the Patriots is a little strong, even so that none of them included him on their greatest list, when he’s sign widely as the best coach of all time, and actually a good and entertaining show, they talk a little bit too much about politics for my liking but nonetheless a good listen

It’s a solid podcast. As a sports fan I enjoy the conversation of who or what is the best in a given sport. However I wish they would get more to the point of what their podcast is about. They have like 15-20 minutes of banter before they actually start talking about main topic. Most of this is them reminiscing between some experience they had with their guest which probably doesn’t need to be recorded, because it’s really not that interesting. Other than that it’s a solid pod.

This show is fun. I asked my wife to listen. Guys that get way into sports want to talk matchups and X’s and O’s and it important to understand that isn’t the only way to consume sports entertainment. I think you guys hashing it out together is a great example of how to enjoy it all together! Thanks.

I do not even keep up with sports at all and I am in love with this podcast. Megan and CJ are absolutely witty, relevant, and their banter will keep you glued until the end and excited for the next episode!

This podcast is so good. Dives deep into the stuff you don’t think about - or highlights the stuff you already know but want to hear again!! Subscribing!!!

Literally been recommending this to all my friends. Love it so much

Such fun to listen to Meggie & CJ discuss with Anthony their greatest sports beefs. These hosts know LOTS about ALL sports plus enjoy great stand up careers so they can think on their feet & it’s FUN-GOATS!

Really didn't know what I was getting myself into with this show, but I'm hooked! Big fan of CJ and Megan. And of course the sportsballz too

Just discovered this show via The Herd. Had a few good laughs, I love the fact that Cj and Meagan rag on each other but are also married so it’s fine.

Love the concept of the show and thought it was a great blend of sports and comedy. Would love to see how an episode goes if CJ and Megan have a fight right before taping!

These are two of the funniest people ever. Someday there will be a GOAT episode of GOAT that will have to mention the GOAT pod because it’s a GOAT.

i like this crap :)

So funny! A much needed hilarious sports cast that anyone can appreciate- can’t wait to hear more.

I love their knowledge of sports but also how funny and natural they are. I’m not a sports nut at all and enjoyed it so much! I’ve been a fan of their comedy and internet videos for a while and love that they’re doing something together!!! Can’t wait for more!

Love this pod and I'm not even a sports fanatic!! Not only fun to listen to but also informative! Can't wait for more eps!

This podcast rules! Megan and CJ have great chemistry, I want to be friends with them. I don’t even love sports that much but this pod is too funny to miss!

Really looking forward to this one! Megan and C.J. are awesome.

A true power couple! Really looking forward to hearing the back and forth on these topics. Speaking of... Would love to hear about the greatest draft busts or greatest brawls!