Reviews
via Podcasts
The Greatest Review Long Overdue
I am usually disappointed before too long in any podcast, but this one is the exception. Ed, Ron, and Producer Bill bring the right combination of thoughtful analysis and having creative fun to really “make a stew.” Followed Ed since his Screen Junkies/Movie Fights days (he deserved at least one win over Dan) and followed into both Reboot It (YouTube) and The Greatest Pod. Their approach to the “greatest” as a plural instead of the singular gives their subjects a breadth that allows their conversations to meander in fun directions while still staying on point. I loved the thoughtful analyses of the Overton Window, Comic Art (history), and the theoretical side of making art in its various forms. However, it is also the pure fun of two comedians and a producer, who is funny in his own right, having fantasy drafts and creative battle royals with comic characters or action heroes (Dutch thinking Apollo is Dillon was great). Perhaps throwback Nerd Goats about man-of-the-people Skeletor or Magneto are the gateway you need. There is variety for everyone and it is pure fun at the end of the day. Come for breakdowns of fandoms, tokusatu, and deep dives into genre, storytelling methods, or character types. Stay for Dusty Rhodes, Night Wing*, and John Peters. In addition, they have a great accompanying Patreon library and YOU SHOULD GO WATCH REBOOT IT ON YOUTUBE (it is amazingly fun and quasi-predictive). “Long story boring…” find your niche, expand from there, and enjoy the ride. I am as happy to see an episode of this drop as I am my favorite tv shows or films.
Read more
Dr. Barefoot
Listen to this podcast.
I followed Ed and Ron here from their hilarious appearances on the Goods from the Woods podcast - I wasn’t too interested in most pop culture and had basically never read a comic book, but those guys rule, so I had nothing to lose. I ended up enjoying this podcast immensely. Fast forward a couple of years to right now and I’m more invested into why movies are great, and I picked up some of my first comics last year (I’ve now read tens of thousands of pages, mostly due to inertia from this pod).
Ed, Ron, and Producer Bill are not just analyzing comics, movies, screenplays, writers, artists, ART - they are using those pieces of entertainment media to explore what makes HUMANITY great. They’re pulling apart bits of our culture to shed light on the triumphs, tragedies, complexities, and idiosyncrasies of the human condition. They’re cutting slices of Spawn, Princess Leia, Jack Kirby, PTA - putting them under a microscope, and seeing bits of you, me, and all of us. They are turning their analysis into capital-A Art. It’s all so sharp, witty, confounding, endearing, and occasionally frustrating (that’s a compliment). This podcast is funny on about 20 different levels - the type of deep humor that rewards your intelligence over and over. It’s a beautiful thing.
If you’ve somehow found this review and have continued reading until this moment, then you’re absolutely the type of person who would like this podcast. Pick out a few episodes which might interest you - listen. Give them a REAL chance. Your brain will enlarge (not dangerously), you’ll feel more media literate (a weapon in modern USA society), and you’ll emerge a better person (hopefully). This isn’t your 2nd cousin’s surface level comic book podcast (though they would probably like it too - Art is for everyone).
Ed, Ron, and Bill are a Cerberus of greatness - they’ve built something quite special with The Greatest Pod. Thanks, y’all, sorry it took me so long to leave a review.
Read more
sam t. a. in VA
Geez Luis, what a Great Pod!
This show is Good enough for Tyler Durden to give a Ninja review in a Furniture Store!
Alex321Contact
Long story boring
You will never be bored listening to these stories. Long time listener, first time commenter, I love your content, I’m still Charlie Brown moping about the Nerd Goat being inaccessible but these talks are always so insightful. I prefer when all three of you are together ranting and laughing, that when you got a stew, baebaay! Also, if I could get a shout out from Night Whayng, that would be epic! Cheers!
Read more
Eternal_Sight
Review
Great conversations.
rvovelazquez00
Fun insights, with the occasional head scratcher
Lots of great insight into various different topics they choose, but mostly, these guys just have fun and are a lot of fun to listen to. But, Logan not being good? That’s a weird hill to die on. Extremely disagree.
EDITED: Changed my star rating. Even though I still disagree with them on that point, it shouldn’t affect the amount of stars these guys, their podcast and it’s musings actually deserves. Sincere apologies.
Read more
StillWynning
There’s nothing to debate, this podcast is great!
If you’re new here, the gist is, go listen to this pod. Ed, Ron, and Bill never fail to provide insightful conversations about a variety of topics ranging from pop culture to real life lessons. Each episode always has a couple laughs, and the banter between the hosts and guests can be very funny. Each episode is unique, and I truly believe after a couple episodes, this podcast will hook you. Also, like many others, I HIGHLY recommend investing in their patreon. It has a wealth of episodes that will keep you busy for hrs. It was the very first patreon I ever subscribed to, and I don’t regret it. Much love to the Greatest Pod crew! Keep up the good work fellas, and you, reader of this review, GO CHECK OUT THIS POD!
Read more
Zander_Z
Fantastic Podcast - especially if you like comic book based media
I started listening to Ed, Ron and Bill back during their Nerd GOAT podcast days and, while I enjoyed Nerd GOAT, this new podcast format really allows the fellas to shine. They’ve totally hit their stride! For any fan of comic books and comic book based movies, I strongly recommend the 5 part Greatest Comic Book Movies by Decade series. Also, if you’ve seen Wakanda Forever, listening to their podcast on the film increased my appreciation and enjoyment of it! Keep it up, guys!!!
Read more
McSnikt!
Geez LOUISE! This Pod is The Greatest!
If you have never listened to this Podcast, or You are a listener who doesn’t get the Patreon Feed, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE…. 1. Subscribe Enough to get the Bonus Pods. 2. Listen to Bonus episode about The Greatest Animals. 3. Listen to The Episode (Probably 2 - 3 Weeks After the Namor Episode), where Ed Ron and Bill will read this review, and explain The TRUE NIGHTMARE That Wakanda Forever has alluded to… The idea of MANY KILLER WHALES, Trained by an Underwater PRO WAR Society, To be their War Horses / Attack Dogs!
Read more
TylerDurdenS0AP
Another home run
8/28/22 - Since Apple wants to save server space by only allowing one review per podcast per author, I’ve decided to hack this space by building a running log of reviews. Anything to show my ongoing support for a cackling goblin, an illiterate, and a single nerd whose work doesn’t preclude him from getting laid 😜
11/9/21 - Listening to podcasts created by Ron, Ed, and Producer Bill has been my most consistent hobby pre-, during, and “post”-Covid. I know this is your chosen career but thanks for all the entertaining, creative content.
Date unknown - Replaced comment about not wanting to win a contest as the umpteenth (500th?) commenter, and literally only writing a comment to help someone else earn the prize.
Read more
ameerhuman
5 Star Show
Came to hear them from one of their previous podcasts Nerd G.O.A.T. that featured a great guest each episode. Love this new premise for them to explore. Also this is a show that you will want to become a Patreon member. The content included in their extra episodes really rivals their main show. Thank you Ed, Ron, and Bill for all your hard work.
Radtober
Truly, Truly the Greatest
Boys, boys, boys....
Long time listener (came over during Ed’s SJU days) and Patreon subscriber.
Left a review and rating on the old show and had to hop on the new joint.
When you read that review over 2 years ago, you guys rightfully roasted my old username I made up as a kid and basically forced the rebrand of my online persona; hope you approve.
I love your takes and opinions on how these characters and this art impact real world politics and beliefs. I don’t necessarily agree with you, but I enjoy nonetheless. You guys are like my echo chamber anti-venom (sorry that my use of strained metaphors can’t live up to Ed’s).
This Hoosier Libertarian is hooked and a fan for life. Keep up the great work.
Read more
The Vulcan Bard
Love this show and its spin off!
Got into this crew's stuff with Reboot It! and it even prompted me to start my own nerdy podcast about video games that aims for a similar "passionate but critical" vibe,
timrtabor123
A fantastically insightful podcast.
I love it. Ed and Ron are incredibly insightful. They make me want to listen to a podcast about a subject that I don’t care about in the slightest. They’re great!
The Fif’ster
Love this pod
Ron and Ed are the best. Give their podcast a listen and subscribe.
JeremyAroundTown
A must listen!
It always amazes me that I can listen to these guys every week and still find something unique and interesting in every episode. They come at their subjects with wit, analysis and depth. I recommend it to everyone!
Chuck The Mountaineer Fan
The magic of this team continues to delight & inspire!
I love the creative team on this show so much. I’m coming in from the Reboot It side of things, and I’m so glad to have another avenue to get analyses & opinions from these guys. Always great to hear how Ed, Ron, & Bill find the magic inside of the things they love, and how they inspire others to explore with the premise of their show.
Alden Diaz
Like Grandma’s Chicken Soup
I’ve listened to every episode of these guys previous podcast, and missed it a lot since it ended.
I’ve been watching them Reboot It on the YouTubes (and you should be too).
But this podcast dynamic is where they truly shine. So glad to have them back!
Way to go boys. You kicked this off without missing a beat.
Can’t wait to hear more!
Matt
P.s. The last 10 or 12 seconds of this episode made me laugh so hard I cried.
Read more
mrobinsonnd
