I found this pod on tiktok and OMG I am ever so happy that I did. I have been reading (and sometimes writing) fanfiction since I was 14 and 14 years later, I’m still doing it. So to hear Erin and Alan review fanfiction on a pod and to have it be an actual discussion on good fanfiction is a breath of fresh air! I binged this pod in like 3 days and am loving everything so much. I adore this pod so much and can’t wait to hear what is next!

So fun and cozy! Feels like I’m discussing fic with friends :). Also, I’ve never watched The Magicians, and now I don’t have to!

Alan and Erin have great chemistry as co-hosts! Their discussions about fanfiction and fandom is so authetic and respectful, you can clearly tell they come from this world. While some podcasts are about making fun of the really bizarre fics out there, Alan and Erin are here to praise fanfic and talk about why people love it so much and why it's so popular. Even when they're talking about a fandom I'm not in, they explain it in a way that's very accessible. And it's also a great source for new fics to read! Definitely give it a listen for all you fic readers out there!

I came for The Magicians fic discussion (and the episode where they talk about Something Good is incredible) but they make every fandom accessible to people outside of them.

I love the way everything is explained. Really fun and immersive. Great chemistry between the hosts and always keeps me laughing

Clear, accessible as a non-fic reader and like listening to your best friends in a coffee shop.