Reviews
via Podcasts
Shower Thoughts
Guys, I’m really enjoying this new format. Sure, I enjoy Magic, but I also enjoy video games, soup, good music, and carrying things in my pocket. There are plenty of places that I can go to get the most up-to-date info on Magic sets and formats, but where else can I find out just how great The Fugitive is? Count me in as a supporter of the show’s new direction.
Bryan JM
We’re updating the kitchen
Late to the life adulting shift in tone from previously niche Magic the Gathering podcast. The one thing they actually were subject matter experts on has been abandoned for the exploration of being a grown-up. As banal as listening to your co-workers discuss their heavy drinking and binging on media.
p0w
10/10
Dredge was my first modern deck bc of the old episode where Shane and the lads did a deep dive. His enthusiasm regarding the deck sold me on it, and I loved playing modern for the first time. I’ve listened to every episode since, and even though the content is shifting, I still really enjoy any time you guys talk about Magic. Thanks for the hours of entertainment!
Mcrisco
Not what it used to be
I used to love this show but they’ve gone away from their roots and everything that made them unique. It’s not really The Dive Down anymore
MrOwlS2
Informative and fun
The only MTG podcast I’ve been able to get into. Genuinely enjoy each episode and look forward to new releases.
I do wish for a little more focus on whatever format the RCQ season is but I do know that wasn’t the foundation of the pod.
Jungle96
In the Rotation
Entertaining and enlightening. This podcast should be in every active magic players rotation. They hit on all of the relevant current events and topics.
Randonomous
Da protest MTG show
My favorite MTG show hands down…I don’t know what any of you look like, but I’ve always imagined everyone recording in Brooks Brothers shirts and khakis….after hearing you all try to pronounce the names of your favorite tacos nothing changed except the khakis are now pleated
SoiledHobbit
Limited player secretly likes listening to a constructed podcast… don’t tell my LGS.
This show is that guilty pleasure that you know doesn’t makes sense but you do it anyway. It’s fascinating hearing about the world of constructed magic as someone who only plays limited. I’ve been drafting since 2006 but have never played constructed and have no plans to. Really enjoy hearing the speculation, metagaming theroys, deck choices, ban list thoughts, and how modern changes with new cards. Maybe one day I’ll put some draft chaff together and made a modern deck, but they also say you can rent cards? Renting cardboard? Who knew? Constructed is a strange place and one I’ll continue to avoid, but these guys are amusing and I like the peek behind the screen into a world I knew existed but never ventured into. Loyal listener since around episode 190 but who’s counting.
Ps. Now I have liked and commented, you win.
Read more
Telresfen
Shane please cry
Also i am that guy that occasional posts meow on the Spotify. Also great show!
Pixel lyfe
I’m doing my part
I’ve faithfully listened to this podcast since around episode 50. Easily the best modern mtg podcast and one of the best overall magic podcasts.
Jigqt
Great MTG Podcast
I really enjoyed the dissertation on ornithology this week. Keep up the great job!
cdmoon0810
amazing magic the gathering podcast
love the show! #bannadu #freeugin
henhen3k
A truly amazing magic podcast
Whether you’re new to the competitive magic scene or a seasoned veteran, The Dive Down is your definitive source for the latest in meta and tournament discussions. With such a talented group of well-spoken individuals and guests, you will always learn something new and walk away with a variety of information that will help you choose a deck for your next local meet-up, RCQ, and beyond! Thank you for giving us such a great podcast each week, and I look forward to many more episodes to come!
Read more
Mogren87
Dive Down
I don’t even play MTG anymore, but I still listen.
Krapface
The Authority on Modern Meta News
The Divedown was incredible before, but after the addition of Devon O’Donnell, aka d00mwake, the show is now my #1 listened to Podcast. I think the diverse views from the team offer spice, thoughtfulness, babies, and unique perspectives you can’t get just reading articles. Their comedic relief, dulcet smooth voices, and broad cultural palettes offer a soothing balm to an unrefined storm of reality. I love hearing about their love of Heavy Play gear, and their editing skills are top tier. If you’re going to listen to one Magic centric podcast, consider this one to be the one-stop, cool kids shop for detailed decks, trends, and entertainment. I am just waiting for them to break into MTG Tournament commentary to cement themselves as the titans of the scene.
Read more
Leil
Best magic podcast out there
I love this podcast and I just beat Stanislav’s Izzet ensoul on arena ggs from Waltermelon
Walt34573
Undisputed #1
My go to source for all things mounted warfare. The team digs deep into real issues. Is it the mount or the rider that truly wins the war?
Wesleyjhere
The Best Magic Podcast
The Dive Down is the best Magic podcast. It is always contains great information surrounding semi-competitive constructed formats. They team also does a great job being entertaining. Thank you!
Dyerwolf 916
LOVE THE SHOW!
Loving the show. Modern is the truth! Shout out from Austin TX
Chad Koss
Modern and Pioneer stuff!
Love the content!!! Listen to and from long commutes for work and rcq’s!
jonah 1999
Great show
Long time listener just want to see if they actually read these
carboardbhoarder
Great show for Modern Magic players
This show is great for anyone who likes modern magic. Devin coming on has been an awesome addition as well! I really enjoy the “sleeve believe heave” section of the show. The dive down also doesn’t jump on bandwagons quickly or often, so it’s nice to actually here discussions of decks while the internet is losing it over the emergency ban of the week.
Towntbenc
Not sure why
I don’t play modern nor pioneer yet I listen to this podcast. The hosts are fine but not sure why I keep listening. That Devon guy is cool.
AznNathan
If You Play Magic, You’ll Love This
I’ve been listening to The Dive Down for about two years now and can’t say enough great things about this show. Great insight, and hilariously fun to listen to.
Keep being awesome guys!
Also Shane, good game today! Tron is one heck of a deck.
Fiifeuijgte
40 yr olds try to use the word Based
If you like hearing about Magic: The Gathering, a digital and paper Trading card game and like hearing 40 year old dads struggle to use the term “Based” this is the show for you. Overall very funny and fun!
Connor Beyer
Good stuff
The best in men’s grooming reviews! Really appreciate their breakdowns of the best soaps and shaving creams.
Mycorrhizaee
Chili
MTG and Chili. Yum daddy.
PattyMcDaddy
Great podcast!
As a long time kitchen table mtg player who is new to competitive formats, this is exactly what I was looking for. All the hosts and guest hosts are great. Thanks guys!
Badst0ne
This is a review.
Love these goofballs. I greatly appreciate their positive and uplifting attitudes! Most magic podcasts are far too negative for my delicate ears.
el gordo666
Good
Just perfect for the modern meta and all the others 10 out of ten, and so funny
DarkShiva
These guys are cool, I guess.
Magic podcast with people talking about non-Standard formats. They’re good.
ChrisAbides
Great Combat Trick
Call me an Ixalan Merfolk because I just got +3 great hosts and Hexproof from bad takes
Ixalan Merfolk
“More in that in a bit…”
…should be the the motto of this show. They love the tease!
Great show, just a good chill MTG pod. Love y’all!
-the grundemer
gregmmi
Great pod
Great podcast, very informative and doomwake is excellent as a host.
A19373)2)2
Great MTG podcast
I don’t play modern, but I love this show! Their reviews of the tournaments has opened my eyes to the larger mtg community. Hosts are funny, engaging, and positive. Keep it up I love the content.
Troll404
Take the deepest dive into magic thru the lens of a casual spike
If you love to either find new decks or find new tech for your existing ones, look no further than this amazing pod! If you love modern and/or pioneer this cast IS FOR YOU.
Each week these 3 friends consistently deliver great MTG takes and engaging banter about the latest news and developments from the Magic: the Gathering metaverse. The three hosts — Dave, Shane and Stan —each bring their own unique strengths, wisdom and sense of humor to the show and each deliver top level performances every episode. The cherry on top is the deep pool of talented and storied guests that regularly add to the breadth and depth of both the educational and entertainment value.
Moreover, the Dive Down discord community is the best — a welcoming and diverse international community of intelligent and intriguing deck builders, grinders and casual spikes. Come join us and play some homes of paper/webcam or MTGO in any format from modern, pioneer, pauper or legacy and discuss the latest spoilers, decks, events and trends with likeminded players of every flavor. Follow this amazing podcast on your favorite platform and listen every week! You WON’T regret it!!
Read more
Auralox
Dope
I love rhinos. Not as much as turtles though.
z28384746
It’s Good
I’ve basically been listening to Magic Podcasts and only Magic Podcasts for a while, and truly, I forgot Podcasts can be both educational AND entertaining. These guys are funny and good hosts, and the episodes certainly don’t feel as long as they actually are. Would recommend to anyone who wants to keep up with the competitive scene.
Phillmatic19
Great pod
A mix of topics every episode lets you pick and choose what you’re interested in!
CastleOrange
My favorite podcast
This is the essential podcast for the casual spike.
Jackson G S
Three future divorced dudes killing it.
I’ve been listening to these guys since their first released. They started as three collective men of the people, and now—-now I listen to them while I slave away at dishes at 11:30 at night while my 18 month old attempts to pull out kitchen knives from the washer that I just previously put in the washing machine.
The custom patreon gifts is top notch. They bought specialized deck-boxes in the hundreds to put in optimized spots in their homes and risked their marriages to give us these items. That’s not just a deck box you’re getting people, that’s hope.
You wouldn’t even know that one of the hosts broadcasts from his closet in fear while the other has his future divorced bachelor pad to talk about magic. As an audiophile, I really appreciate the dedication these men provide.
I personally was one of those magic players that never showered until I discovered Barrister & Mann. Now I smell like lavender and have a neckbeard that rivals Reid Dukes head of hair. Get this product.
If you want the knowledge of Jarvis Yu with the good looks of Corey Baumeister whispering into your ear about a child’s card game…look no further than the Dive Down.
Read more
Spsiegel
Great podcast
Really enjoy listening to The Dive Down to get a better, more diverse, analysis on metas and decks in modern and some insight on pioneer. When the team also gets to have guests that are specialized are incredibly insightful.
Great job guys and keep it up!
FFFREAK2787
Good stuff
You keep the voices away. Thank you for your content
Thisappstinksworsethan my butt
Quality MtG Content
The Dive Down is just an excellent way to stay connected to Magic. You’ll learn how to play with and against the latest Modern/Pioneer decks and metagame. These guys make me feel like I have a fighting chance, even if I might spend more time listening to their show than I get to spend playing events.
It doesn't hurt that the hosts are just good friends with a passion for their hobby. Also, they know they could talk about soap and still be entertaining, so sometimes they just do.
Keep up the great work, guys.
Read more
Brandor83
Long time listener, first time reviewer
I feel particularly called out by this week’s intro. I do listen to the dive down in the shower, while out for a walk and doing the dishes. I’ve been listening since almost the beginning and I have appreciated every episode.
You three keep me up to date on changes to the meta and explain how new decks play and evolve. Keep up the awesome work!
pogu59
Good pod too
I have been listening to this podcast for over a year and only just realized that Stanislav is not the same Stanislav that won a Modern Pro Tour with eggs…
Good pod too.
Sacha'sHideousLaughter
Pretty Fly For Three White Guys
I don’t even play Modern, but this podcast makes me feel like that’s a personal choice instead of something I could never do. Keep up the good work, my dudes.
Mark Bobster
Best MTG Podcast for New Players
I’ve been playing Magic for roughly 9 months now. This podcast has taught me so much about the world of Magic, competitive playing and format/deck types. I’ve tried listening to other MTG podcasts but I keep coming back to The Dive Down. Keep up the great work guys, I look forward to new episodes every week!!
Mike Ayotte
Very informative
I love the podcast, I barely get a chance to play anything aside from commander due to work/life schedule. But I love listening to you guys and staying informed.
andrewwwcantu
Recommended with a Warning
This is the best competitive Magic podcast I’ve listened to, and the one I look forward to most each week. It strikes the perfect balance of spikiness and casualness. My only warning to potential listeners is to beware the deck specialist interview episodes. They have resulted in me buying into no fewer than four modern decks: Amulet Titan, Indomitable Creativity, Burn, and Living End. Thankfully, for my bank account’s sake, no one can make a Pioneer deck sound fun.
Read more
Matt in PA
