Reviews
via Podcasts
Literary Analysis
A perfect blend of literary analysis, friendship based comedy, and an emphasis on inclusivity and taking on difficult topics, allows this podcast to feel like a home for the losers(said fondly) who spent their lunch periods in the Language Arts Teacher’s room.
MementoMori365
Thorough and pleasantly surprised
If you want a deep dive and are missing ST, this is the podcast for you. They leave no stone unturned and give love to all diff perspectives. They’re also not afraid to be critical which is refreshing to say the least. Keep it up, ladies!
Leavesofgrass22
Welp, there goes that
I really liked this podcast, the amount of work, research, creativity and structure was incredible… the dragging of S5 review is getting exhausting though. I really couldn’t wait to hear about their thoughts as true fans as this show ended, well that was until they became very obvious Byler cult members.
Just a Person with Ears
Still Listening!
Best ST Pod in the game! 🧇
TheAlexVincent
Rule of thumb
Anyone who says “government name” without any intention of mocking the kind of people who say “government name” is too dumb to be taken seriously, even when discussing a fantasy series.
YUsucksobad
Greatest Podcast
This has to be the greatest thing since sliced bread. As a six day ST veteran, i’m highly influenced by the information shared throughout these episodes.
Nabisco88
The first podcast I’ve ever felt compelled to review — and for good reason
Starcourt Study Hall is one of the smartest, most engaging podcasts I’ve ever listened to. Marina and Amanda don’t just talk about Stranger Things—they study it. Their episodes blend history, psychology, and character insight in a way that turns each discussion into a fascinating deep dive.
They’re never shallow or gimmicky—their chemistry is amazing, their wit sharp, and their delivery warm and inclusive. Best of all, they have zero speaking static—no “ums,” “uhs,” or filler words, just effortless, thoughtful conversation.
I came for Stranger Things, but I’ll stay for Marina and Amanda—no matter what they discuss next.
Read more
TC-Mug
Love it
Great podcast!
KrispeeKream
finally!
praise our lord and savior, Karen Wheeler, that we finally have two witty female hosts intelligently covering Stranger Things! Wish I had found this pod sooner, but now I get to binge and catch up. Love your insight!
MKA1022
BEST Stranger Things podcast hands down!
I can’t emphasize highly enough how much I love Starcourt Study Hall! Amanda & Marina thoughtfully explore so many aspects of Stranger Things in the most interesting and creative ways. I didn’t think it was possible to appreciate this show more than I already did, but they continue to prove me wrong. I look forward to hearing their new episodes every week — if you love Stranger Things, you owe it to yourself to give this a listen.
Read more
Ellen SF
They Won me over
My first review of their podcast was overly critical. Since then, this has become my favorite podcast each week. These ladies grow on you like tentacles from the Upside Down. They are funny and clearly prepare extensively for each episode. Looking forward to Season 5 coverage. Keep up the great work!
CapCenterJoe
Love this pod cast!
I love Byler and i think it’s so cute. I just finished part 2 and it gave me such a good perspective. You guys did a really thorough job. Also tbh i did think you were together lol.
💙Miwi💛
Needs more Amanda
I enjoy the topics and theories covered, but I’d like to hear more from Amanda. In one episode, Marina literally said, “Amanda had this theory…” and then proceeded to explain said theory instead of handing the mic to Amanda for to explain her own theory…there just isn’t enough back and forth for me. It’s not conversational enough.
Stuffybuddy
My favorite ST podcast!
Helping me stay sane while I wait for S5. A deep dive that is so well-researched. I am here for it all!
MerNc
Stranger Things galore
In the deep dark void between seasons, nothing makes me happier than listening to Amanda and Marina’s thoughtful, in-depth recaps and analysis of my favorite show. Their friendship makes their dynamic even more enjoyable, and they go above and beyond to be accurate, interesting, and entertaining. 10/10, no notes except please never stop!!
alaskaaaa
Zero Squelching
Sometimes I just want more Stranger Things in my life without having to hear The Upside Down “squelching wetly” and Amanda and Marina thoughtfully recap each episode so that I don’t have to. They are also both english majors and have really great insight into things like character motivations as well as what likely was the Duffer brother’s intentions on themes and symbolism. I absolutely love how deep they go but everything is balanced out by their humorous banter. Honestly, there is so much here and so much intentionality any Stranger Things fan could likely relisten (and I am!)
Read more
moviehag
Too much fluff, not enough substance
The ladies have great chemistry and I enjoy their witty repertoire. However, this podcast is 95% commentary and about 5% recap and analysis. I’m disappointed because I thought from the description they would be breaking down and theorizing about the show: episodes, characters, plots, etc. Instead we mainly just get critiques on everything like the characters’s hair, clothes, dialogue, etc.
ricesky007
A mess
This is a mess of a podcast.
Acadia beer hunter
Insightful, genuine, fun podcast
I just discovered your podcast, and can’t wait to listen to all of the episodes! Thank you for the insightful entertainment that is helping me get my stranger things fix while waiting for season 5!
racinganew
LOVE THE PODCAST
Hey guys, so I just love y’all’s podcasts, I listen to them like every night before I go to bed and I laugh sometimes to them and I just like love them so much! Thanks for doing this it’s so much fun!! Can’t wait until the next episode!!!!!
trynoah
What a great friendship
I love listening to Amanda and Marina. They are so thoughtful and so funny. The amount of work they put into their podcast is impressive.
Ashbashmymashpotaters
Stranger things max and eleven
It the best and funniest podcast of stranger things I love it so much it my favorite
Stranger things 3368
He Likes It Cold
I am super picky about my podcasts and must have dismissed at least three other Stranger Things pods before landing on this gem, and I am so happy I stuck with it!
Not only is listening to Marina and Amanda like hanging out with friends, but the randomly educational episodes in between ST discussions are so clever and fun! The fandom brainrot is real, folks, and you’d be hard-pressed to find a more entertaining podcast about such an amazing show than this one. Thank you, ladies!
- Chelsea (@halloweenjack)
Read more
HalloweenJack7
