Jeffery MacDonald has been accused of being a family annihilator since his wife and two daughters were found both beaten and stabbed to death in their home in 1970. According to Jeffery it was a home invasion gone terribly wrong. Nevertheless, Jeffery was found guilty but continues to maintain his innocence to this day. Listen as the girls discuss the evidence, circumstantial evidence, and more! 

Christina Sanoubane was found brutally murdered in her bathtub on September 4, 2000. Carlos Robinson was convicted of the crime based on evidence obtained from a hamburger bun. Listen as the girls discuss the facts of the case and more! 

Kaeleigh and Mollie discuss another case sent in by a very special listener: Kaeleigh's dad! Harrison Graham was a serial killer in Philadelphia from 1986-1987. Listen as the girls discuss the facts of the case and more! 

Mollie and Kaeleigh discuss the (somewhat) unsolved murder of Martha Moxley. 15 year old Martha Moxley was brutally murdered right in her own backyard. What makes it only somewhat unsolved? Listen and find out! 

Mollie and Kaeleigh discuss a case sent in by a very special listener: Mollie's dad! Arthur Shawcross was just a normal guy living in Rochester, New York, or so people thought. Listen to the girls discuss the case that took place right in Mollie's hometown! Disclaimer: graphic content

Mollie and Kaeleigh discuss another case sent in by a listener! 19 year old Rachel Cooke went missing in January of 2002 and her case remains unsolved to this day. Listen to the girls discuss the mystery and what they think may have happened!

Mollie and Kaeleigh discuss a case sent in by one of their listeners! Lori Vallow Daybell was once a loving and supportive mother of kids Tylee and JJ. Everything changed when the kids were found dead in her yard. Listen as the girls talk about the case timeline and discuss key factors! 

Mollie and Kaeleigh discuss The Beatrice 6: 6 individuals forced to remember a crime they did not commit. What does that mean? Listen and find out!

Kaeleigh and Mollie discuss the solved but unsolved case of Tommy Zeigler and a quadruple homicide. Listen to their takes on this tragic case and give them your two cents on the controversy! 

Kaeleigh and Mollie discuss the unsolved murder of Betsy Aardsma that happened right on Penn State's campus (which just happens to be their alma mater)! Our introductory episode where you get to know the girls and what this podcast is all about.