Reviews
via Podcasts
Concerning
I wanted to support a thoughtful, female-led podcast, but recent episodes have become increasingly uncomfortable to listen to. The hosts claim to research complex cultural phenomena yet often fail to define what they’re examining, explain their methodology, or distinguish criticism from harassment before drawing sweeping conclusions. The influencer snark episode was particularly one-sided, overlooking serious issues of accountability and harm. The frequent, casual references to psychiatric medication as a way of coping also feel increasingly uncomfortable and deserve more thoughtful framing for a public audience. Personal opinions are absolutely valid, but presenting them as researched cultural analysis requires greater intellectual rigor. Lately, the tone feels more like mean-girl commentary than meaningful examination.
Read more
lienev
Meh.
There’s nothing informative here. It’s all opinion and it’s not worth listening to, but at least they mention it’s for entertainment purposes, it just fails to be entertaining or relevant.
Scrambledeggshells
Hate to ride the bandwagon
Long time listener and love to consume anything about cults. But the most recent episode about Mel Robins fell a little flat, and honestly, felt very mean girl. I mean, I don’t have an opinion about Mel Robins but this just felt like it was personal, not even funny and light. Chill
HeardThatTheBirdIsTheWord
Trouble accessing the hammer episode
I listened to half the day the hammer episode came out, I have not been able to finish it. Every other episode works tho 🤷♀️
Update:snark episode, hearing multiple valley girl voices is nauseating. The pod has not been holding interest in a while. Good bye friends.
lyzzardwyzzard
Still listening… for now
This show has a great premise but is getting hard to listen to recently. The take aways of the episodes are more the host’s personal opinions and less of the actual impact whatever this week’s subject is having on society. Pushing through the pithy gossip and hot takes is getting laborious, although they do a great job of selecting guests and do excellent work of prompting them to share insights. These hosts are certainly very intelligent but perhaps are falling into the trap of catering to more impressionable people than of the critical thinkers who tune in. I’m a huge fan of Chelsea’s effort in bringing the conversation back to what the latter audience members came for but if it’s just a numbers game, I guess they’re doing all the right things. Amanda’s impressions and accents are charming and unique, as the episodes have gone on, other hosts are also leaning that very unique way of speaking for some reason and it feels ingenuine. That being said, Im here for the research and hard work that goes into unearthing the underlying nefarious-ness of certain organizations that walk among us, undetected. Also, yes, men suck, we all know this, but it feels like they are ready to attack and put down any male mentioned, fanning the dangerous tire fire of separation between the sexes.
Read more
bailanda
Looks like gold can tarnish after all
This show was great. Was. Now it’s just garbage. If you actually have interest in the sociology, psychology, and impact of a real cult or cult leader, this is just a bunch of stoned girls with vocal fry giggling about why they think they’re better than people with different interests than they have.
There was a host named Isa a long time ago and the dynamic between her and Amanda was intelligent and thought provoking. They were fun to listen to.
Then something happened and it just rotted. There are no true cults or anything genuinely interesting to learn about anymore. (At least not on this show).
I’ve listened for years. Less so recently because it’s so hard to get into an episode or finish one. But the cult of dog people was so absurdly stupid I finally threw in the towel.
I’ve bought and read all of Amanda’s books. I’m not a fair weather fan. But she doesn’t seem interested in bringing anything worth hearing about to the table anymore; and seems hell bent on adding insufferable co-hosts.
These aren’t cults. They’re just blips in pop culture and American culture. Don’t suggest you’re exploring cults if you’ve fully given up the enterprise. You can spend 6 minutes in Oregon and encounter strangers from 40 different cults, the people who survived them, and the life experience they gained in doing so. The material exists in spades. But Gilmore Girls Goldendoodles I guess? Why should women discuss anything deeper than that? 🙄
Read more
Ngigusch
Sounds Like A Rant
Quality varies with this podcast. The latest episode about dog people is a perfect example. A chunk of the conversation was the two hosts going on and on about what they dislike about dog people. The interview wasn’t particularly revealing or well-done. Other episodes have been fantastic. YMMV.
Newsjunkie70
Was willing to look past things at first…
As someone who really loves cultures and had read Cultish, I really thought I found a podcast that can analyze the pop culture obsessions and break them down. However, I think the hosts often contradict themselves and have bias opinions on the topic. Then the sprinkled in man-hating got annoying. But sound quality is great!
JacobQ92
Good information and easy to listen to
The hate on recent reviews of this podcast sounds like a concerted effort. I find this informative and easy to listen to.
Chris Lamke
Sometimes great storytelling and interesting topics, sometimes meh
1. Listening to the episode on celeb wellness marketing, finding it increasingly painful to listen to the hosts’ paid and very fake endorsements of products during ad breaks… consider alternative financing options or do an episode on the cult of podcasting & ads
2. Wondering if all the recent reviews saying “this podcast used to be great but had declined so much” are incels or other recent episode subjects feeling personally attacked lol
Read more
tangerine171
Snarky, Lazy, and Willfully Uninformed
I have very rarely come across a podcast that is as low effort and judgy as this. I went into this expecting nuanced exploration of various “fringe” groups, and instead was met with essentially prejudiced and one-sided “yes, this is a cult and it’s bad”. I started by listening to the Waldorf episode and within the first few minutes they were writing their own definitions of what anthroposophy is to say that the indoctrination of children is the primary purpose, which is bizarre and irresponsible, but whatever it was probably a fluke. Nope. Every episode I tried was essentially the same. “Look how spooky and weird this is! Everything is a cult if it’s not mainstream!” Very disappointing.
Read more
MeghanAngier
Lazy Patronizing Elitist Takes
This pod has gone so downhill. Now it just seems like women trying to be as elevated from the rest of us as possible, with minimal research or compassion. Awful.
Scooching in Here
Eh
I just remember being obsessed with the show, then they announced they were ending the show? Then… the show just kept going/didn’t end? It just started to suck… then kept sucking more… and now it’s cliche and boring and predictable and I am bummed, I’ll be honest. I’ve given it years… and I finally had to unfollow bc I haven’t been able to even finish an episode in at least a year. :/ Instead of funny and clever it’s just… pretentious? It’s also… an overused word, and can sometimes be good/empowering!, but in this case, I just mean it in its truest form: cringe. This podcast is cringey now.
Read more
aylorbay
This used to be a really good show, I’m not sure what happened
This used to be one of my favorite shows, but over the past few months it just hasn’t been very good. I’m not sure what happened, but this went from a very funny and informative show to something completely different. Now it’s more of a snark podcast where they pick random topics and mostly insult or make fun of them. And please, Amanda, stop with the sing songy vocal fry…please.
MSWESL
Fun, Light Podcast
It took longer than usual for me to decide whether “Sounds Like A Cult” is a podcast for me. I typically fangirl passionately, am a bit of a completist (I’m all in or I’m not at all interested), and usually know fairly quickly whether something is for me, but I wasn’t sure about “Sounds Like A Cult” for a while, for a myriad of personal reasons, none having to do with the wonderful hosts. Thankfully, the audio quality is pretty great, which is my baseline for a regular listening podcast! During an extremely difficult time, when I just needed a background distraction to get through the workday, I ended up compulsively listening to every single episode of “Sounds Like A Cult.” Nonstop. So I think I am officially a fan! Now I am going back through and replaying the ones I especially enjoyed and considering joining their Patreon. I think “Toxic Relationships” is my favorite episode, as far as how enlightening and helpful it was. Thank you, Amanda and Isa!
Update: This podcast has really declined. I can’t put my finger on why, but it’s just not the same anymore.
Read more
SilkChiffonLeatherOn
Quality massively declined
I am a longtime listener and fan of Amanda Montell’s work, and I’m very loyal to the few podcasts I listen to, so I am very disappointed by the decline in quality in this show. It seems like Amanda has totally handed over the reigns to the other hosts, and it was her research and unique perspective that really enriched the discussions. It sounds like the hosts are reading straight off a script written by ChatGPT. I have given it several tries in the last few months, and legitimately can’t make it through an episode. It makes me sad because it also makes me question Amanda’s commitment to her craft if she’s willing to let this slip this far… will her other works also just become low effort cash grabs for undiscerning audiences? It gives the ick, I fear.
Read more
j.ess.
Im done
Guys the weird “intro speech” is giving 8th grade social studies report, not podcast. It’s possible to introduce a topic without a theater kid, cutesy speech for the first 20 minutes. Get to the interview and find a way to be conversational with each other and skip the weird intro.
Also whoever does the witchy, hocus pocus voice, I promise you, you don’t need to do that.
K8BTLR
Please do better research than wikipedia
this used to be an interesting podcast. lately the research on the topics has been lacking. they got so many things wrong with the sims episode and the sister wives episode. is amanda still involved?
teaseapea
Sister wives episode
Wow! I already loved this podcast but this has to be one of my fav guests ever. So insightful, thoughtful, interesting!
LisaIsc
Right? Right?
This is a really decent podcast, right? And it’s all about cults, right? And they look at issues with really interesting angles, right? But cult speak uses the word right alot, right? it’s like how they get you to agree without realizing it, right?
Just…please stop saying “Right?” After every statement. That’s a cult behavior. I can listen and have my opinions, I don’t need to be prompted to do so. It’s like…baseline. Please. Just say the statement and don’t ask me to validate.
Read more
cscisme
Basic and the Voices…
I was excited about finding a new, at least to me, cult podcast, but I think this one is for the basic girls out there. Not that there’s anything wrong with that, but the interviews and all the information is very “over culture”.
I have to admit that I still listen to it from time to time because the topics are but I’ll tell you something else that I find really grating about this show- the voices and the banter. I don’t see the point in talking in childlike tones with sing song rhymes when you have something intelligent to say. I feel like I’m listening to the Skimm. I actually have to slow down the speed to be able to tolerate it. Their voices are really
Read more
Plantspirit
Solo host episodes
Amanda, I promise you can have a fun and engaging show without doing the silly voices
Lexi99900
Feminism?
Why is sexism against men fine and heavily endorsed by this podcast, yet sexism against women is wrong? I’m a woman who enjoyed this podcast until I heard a few episodes that I find so hypocritical. It’s not informative or entertaining… so what is the point?
mowmowmoomio4989
Smug judgment of Book Tok
Wow. I actually had to get out of a bubble bath to shut this episode off. I am not on Book Tok and I don’t even read that much. But honestly the host sounds so smug. She literally isn’t even close to Book Tok and she made people sound so shallow and manipulative. So much judgment and so much disrespect for Morgan. I hope when you relisten you cringe at your formal self.
Boscorito
Smart and fun analysis
It’s such a smart group of women who get together and dissect some of the biggest stories and topics in our society - but presented in a way that feels like you’re hanging with your friends. I love it!
Acappellafan2234
So Inspiring!
This podcast has given me a total confidence that the next generation of women is going to rule the world! You are so articulate, intelligent, and inspiring to listen to. I absolutely love this podcast.
catwalkkelly
Some issues
Pretty interesting topics but the hosts drop so many gratuitous f-bombs that I stopped listening.
Flickster1000
Why bother??
The hosts tends to ramble. Why have guests on if you’re just going to talk the whole time??? I want to hear what the guest has to say not stream of consciousness from the person that should be asking questions.
Rnlink
Middle school aged hosts?
Are these people in middle school? They’re like Tik Tok in human form: psycho plucky and annoying.
Bunny Cub
New here
Thought I had found all the scam content. Looking forward to being here. I found humor in you guys have factor as a sponsor. Google the scam or cult of factor lol
rdoubleu
Always thought provoking
I absolutely love every episode because they delve into history, traditions, and the attitudes towards the specific “cult” they are discussing that day. It also makes me laugh!
kaedancer
One of my favorite podcasts!
I use this podcast to make myself do work, it's always fun and engaging, I love hearing different perspectives on popular topics and seeing how they can be considered culty! Love how fun all the topics are, and it's really easy to listen to!
Stargazer 89
Reasonably Good
Some episodes are great. Even for topics I don’t know anything about they can be good. I feel like the quality of the episode depends on the experts or people with first had experience that they get. Not always my favorite or well done but reasonably good episodes and a perfectly fine background podcast.
Z Dahl
I’m waiting for balance
Not a bad pod but the lack of balance is starting to wear thin. Sure, do shows on the Manosphere, MAGA etc but your bias is showing. How about covering the cult of progressives or trans I dare you.
Owyhee775
Rarely depth or research anymore
It has some strong episodes especially when they have a guest who has firsthand experience about the “cult” or if they do good research. Other times the guests talk about random stuff and I get nothing out of the episode except for a ton of ads. When it started, I listened consistently, but now it’s much more disappointing. Wish there was more consistent depth.
JuliK69851
Sounds Like a Cult may be a cult
I’d listened to a handful of episodes, and basically enjoyed them. However, I just listened to the manosphere ep, and it was a largely wandering, kjnd of mean, discussion about the inadequacies of all men, with borscht belt jokes about how we can’t live our lives without women caring for and feeding us. Maybe 10% of the ep was incisive, thoughtful commentary.
There were no men on the show about men, and it started me thinking about how many of the other episodes were in bad faith, but I just didn’t know enough to realize it at the time. There’s an audience for this, but it’s not me.
Read more
JeremyZNYC
Can you talk about actual cults??
Ok I’ve tried. The onetaste episode was everything this show should be. An in depth dive into something that’s actually culty. But then you go and do an episode about PANTONE COLORS?? Have you just run out of material at this point? Please talk about cults and culty things. You’re making your show a joke
Txzzzy
Keeping on man hating please
I rarely read reviews but the number of reviews complaining about the hosts voice (which is both a lazy complaint and misogynistic) is ridiculous. Turn the podcast off if it bothers you so much.
Also, Joe Rogan doesn’t get enough hate and deserves every ounce he does get so please continue with the “man hating” (aka women not just letting men get away with bad behavior).
save_the_animals_jb
ANNOYING VOICES
Guessing it’s the one other people mention - her voice is grating! Omg. If your listener count is low it IS your voice girl I promise you.
RenegadeGrenade
Mostly great
Just like any cult - there are people who will love this and believe every bit of research they put into it. Mostly, I laugh through the CrossFit/starbucks/etc etc stuff but when fact checking, this podcast has the same problem everyone does. Their algorithm. As a female who does listen to Joe Rogan and who lies in the middle of political lines (I love my gays and love my guns baby)- the shade they tossed the JRE pod is unfortunately exactly what I was afraid they’d do. There’s a lot of meatheads in the JRE sphere but we aren’t all mindless orcs (as they so rudely mention) and I kind of hate how one sided the hosts get on topics like this. The covid ivermectin stuff - calm down - also comedy is comedy, they are stories told by comedians to be funny. (One would think they would know that???) the Cult of Joe Rogan episode bothered me so much I may never listen to another. Opinions are fine but fact checking online isn’t always reliable and it’s clear this pod leans in to their algorithm. Do better babes.
Read more
DrDrea4Real
My fav lil podcast
I enjoy the new hosts and am glad Amanda was able to diversify the perspectives with these collaborative folks. Reese is amazing but Chelsea is my favorite addition. I know there is also a fourth person joining and I’m excited to hear their perspectives too! I also think this podcast so educated and well researched. And I enjoy how cults have different scales of culti-ness and how there’s a lot of calling in vs calling out when it comes to explaining difficult topics.
Read more
Nat-attack4412
Love this podcast!
This podcast has helped put to rest a lot of anxieties I have about culty subjects by picking them apart and shedding light on all the BS. I love being informed!! Now please do an episode on the cult of Rolex, because I’m hearing men talk of “grey market” value and all this other blah blah. Help!!!
Manta1895
Zoomer vocal fry
Podcast has great content, but you have to be able to tolerate some Zoomer vocal fry…
Bethincha
Cult of Stagehands?
You’ve covered a cult of theater, but a union of theater stagehands has got the be one of the most cultiest industries. It’s almost as if the old guard kinship of the union and the traditions of theater, combined with the skill hierarchies of a craft trade feed into each other, so much so that its segregated itself from broader industry norms in terms of safety and SOPs. Just a thought!
Gus_567
Funny and Entertaining!
I look forward to this podcast every week! I’ve been listening for over a year now, and still find the episodes fun and entertaining. The host do a great job of mixing in some more serious cult topics, and more fringe group, not-so-culty topics. We’re not here to write a dissertation, just ask questions about a possibly culty group.
Mirrandooo
Joe Brogan
Just coming here, as a man in America, to tell you amazing humans to keep up the good works I don’t ever miss an episode and I don’t plan too. Let the haters hate.
#liberalmob
What a dumb take
Ignorant and misguided take on Joe Rogan
Melllllllllllll24
Closed Minded & Men Haters
I used to kind of enjoy this podcast. It felt different at first. I didn’t always agree with how they rated certain “cults,” but that was part of the appeal… it gave me something to think about on a long drive or while doing chores.
But the Joe Rogan episode completely changed that for me.
It didn’t feel balanced. It didn’t feel curious. It felt decided before it even started. About ten minutes in, I already knew exactly where they were going to land, and not because of strong evidence or thoughtful breakdown, but because the tone made it obvious.
What bothered me most wasn’t that they criticized Joe Rogan. Criticism is fine. It was the way it came across, like there was no room for nuance, no effort to understand why millions of people enjoy the Joe Rogan Experience, no attempt to have a real conversation about it. Just dismissal.
It also felt heavily slanted against men in general, which made the episode hard to listen to. When commentary starts sounding more like personal resentment than analysis, it stops being interesting and starts feeling predictable.
I stuck it out for a bit… hoping it would turn. It didn’t.
If you’re looking for open-minded discussion, this episode isn’t it. Unfortunately, it made me lose interest in the show altogether.
Read more
TroyLoisel
Sooooooooo entertaining!
I always look forward to these podcasts each week! I love the cross between the exploring the psychology of people with pop culture. I feel like I learn a little more about myself each episode and those around me!
lijahloo13
That E Jean Carroll madlib tho
…Truthfully had me in tears with laughter. I have been majorly enjoying this new-to-me podcast recently… tysm 🙏
Linnea.grace
