Reviews
via Podcasts
Fascinating!
Makes me want to learn something new. But while being taught with DI instead of left alone to struggle.
SweetestEvil
A fascinating look into American educational dogma, and a better way.
This has been one of the few podcasts that really made me want to pick up a book on the subject and dig deeper. Why is a demonstrably effective education method so controversial? What can I as an individual and future parent ensure my child can learn despite what might happen in the classroom?
Perpetualletdown
So enlightening. I want my kids in direct instruction!
I’m so amazed listening to season 2. I would have benefited so much from this type of teaching when I was growing up. I want to understand more about why people oppose direct instruction - it seems like a slam dunk.
GO_SF
Blowing my mind! 🤯
I’m a teacher of 15 years! As a new teacher, I was absolutely clueless, and like many other teachers on this podcast, I just did what I was told because I didn’t know any better and trusted my district to do what was best! I’m so embarrassed as well and now can’t wait to bring this back to my coworkers and classroom! I’ll be teaching phonics to 5th graders and will be proud to do so from now on! Thank you so much for your work and sticking up for teachers everywhere! I have loved listening to this podcast and did so every free second I had! It’s a must listen!!
Read more
Crauert
My lived experience
This is an amazing podcast! It explains my childhood education and why I struggled with reading so much. She’s talking about my lived experience of learning to read in the CA public education system. I was in 6th grade in the 95-96 school year.
DHart9
GREAT SHOW!!!!!!!!
I’m 10 years old and I’ve been taught using phonics, but sadly, some of my friends haven’t yet learned how to read. This is a great show. it’s very informative.
A Super Important Person
Amazing! Would love to know the impact this podcast is having in our education system
This has been very eye opening for me as a parent of young children. I purchased Zig’s book on learning to read and it’s been incredible to see the results in my own child. He is a toddler, he’s picking it up so quickly and he is so proud of himself. As a parent, it is fool proof - the scripts tell you exactly what to say. Incredible! I would love to know whether and how this podcast has had an impact on a larger scale.
Read more
AMS2222
Powerful and True
As a retired first grade teacher, I recommend all stakeholders listen to this podcast.
Elizdenise
An educator MUST listen
As someone who has worked in a school that implemented DI school wide, I’ve seen first hand the positive impact it had on our students and instruction. As a mother of a child with dyslexia I pay a private tutor to provide Reading Mastery to my child each week because the school does not. I believe whole heartedly that DI would change our student outcomes if it were implemented correctly. Thank you for saying what so many people have said for decades. A must listen for any educator or concerned parent.
Read more
Jenny from the coast
Great Podcast!
Great podcast! Highly recommend it if you’re interested in education!! Thank you for making this.
Kinzley Yang
Thank You!
I love your podcast because you are showing me the behind the scenes of my education and also that of what I’ve been working in for over 30 years. Thanks for putting it together in such an interesting and informative way. It’s kind of like seeing the scandal and conspiracy that has ran our system for years.
biggsbert
Everyone should listen to this!
Anyone who has or cares about a child’s learning should listen to this podcast. Truly eye opening!
Mari12106
One Begins to Wonder
One begins to wonder after having listened to both seasons whether our education system is inept or genuinely had an interest in dumbing down our children. I worked in the classroom for years both in the public education system middle school through high school and in private classical education for primary school that takes a direct education approach. The difference shocked me, and now I know why. 3rd graders at the classical school read far better than most students in the high school I taught at, and it isn’t the children’s fault. One set learned phonics through direct education the other site reading through student lead lessons. As a 41 year old who couldn’t read until 2nd grade because I started out in a site reading public elementary school who finally learned phonics through direct education in a 2nd grade private school, the method reveals itself beautifully. Great job to the host and the crew who produces this exceptional podcast.
Read more
EastBound85
Louder For The People In The Back
Listening to the first episode, I heard myself saying, “I knew it!” I felt angry, emotional, sad, yet inspired. Thank you for this.
Jan Squyres
Imperative for every parent!
This is the bravest most thorough podcast I’ve ever spent time listening to. Learners need to understand the building blocks before they can figure out creative ways to use those blocks. Our schools have tossed out the tried and true methods that created this great nation and are destroying us!
Every parent needs to know this information! Every school district needs to be reevaluated! Our children are in trouble which means our nation is in trouble!
Read more
VH_loves podcasts!
Childhood
Shod for a man
Rvtvgr
This explains a lot
As a science educator in title I schools, I’ve always wondered why there was so much hate for direct instruction and this explains it. I was trained under constructivist theory but always knew that the population I taught needed to be taught. How does a kid who is in school poverty wonder about stoichiometry? They don’t, they have to be taught!!
Teyonda75
Do I get the chance
Conned by a man with
My hm jux
Hm c
Just posted wort
Nightgjgh5
V cool but not really
I’m just going home now
56722tyuf
Complicated Issue
Well explained. Hard to be balanced when requests for interviews are denied. But at the end of the day we all need to pay more attention to the education of our children. They are the future.
The FirstofMany
Historically interesting but still not the answer
I find this series incredibly interesting, but it only confirms that there is no “perfect model.” While data can be found to support direct instruction (and that may have been the case during a time where compliance and uniformity were vital to the national economy and identity), this no longer seems to be true.
COadvtrer
Great Expose’ on Education
I like the reporting of both season 1 & Season 2. I find it fascinating to read the criticisms of Emily Hanford’s reporting. We have a baked-in hatred by longtime teachers that have bought into the broken school systems of American education for decades. The grip of their unions and blind allegiance to whatever their administrators tell them to do is madness. The bright future of education is in parents getting honest information and making the best decisions for their children, often pulling them out of failed schools. Honest, thorough, intelligent reporting is one of the most powerful disinfectants to improve education. Both seasons of “Sold a Story” podcasts is what we needed.
Read more
Fireprogram
My Favorite Podcast By Far
I have never looked forward to a podcast more than I look forward to Sold a Story. My wife and I are both educators, and we can’t stop talking about the ideas in this series. Keep it up!
than-lee
Season 3
A lot of teachers are going to be upset that this podcast suggests the curriculum teachers make up the night before class can’t compete with a studied and tested script. And they seem to be confusing direct instruction with never asking kids questions or to do inquiry. The point is that we are asking kids to try to solve the problem of sustainable energy and write to their congressmen when they haven’t even learned what the most efficient energy producing materials are. Or asking them comprehend a book without teaching them how to read it (remember that philosophy in season 1) inquiry without the knowledge to support it is worthless.
And direct instruction does allow for students to answer questions. A a pace tens of times faster than inquiry based instruction.
I really hope season 3 looks into classroom management.
Season one is one specific subject, season two is the best teaching philosophy. And season 3 should look at the insanity of PBIS and how we shift all accountability away from students and remove all consequences. To such insane levels that some schools actual call themselves no consequence schools and give children cookies to redirect them from hitting. Betting they would land on something like smart classroom management.
Read more
Bharmswilliam
A bunch of bologna!
As an elementary math teacher, I’m disappointed by the direction of Season 2 so far. After listening to Episode 2, I’m concerned about the way math instruction is being framed and the emphasis on direct instruction at the expense of inquiry-based learning.
NCSM’s position statement, Strengthening Research-informed Decision Making for Mathematics Education, addresses many of my concerns. It cautions against misinterpreting research to promote a narrow, one-size-fits-all approach to teaching math. While explicit instruction has an important place, students also need opportunities to explore, reason, make connections, and develop their own mathematical thinking.
One of my biggest questions is this: Where do students develop their mathematical reasoning if we are always showing them how to solve a problem? Students need opportunities to try strategies, make mistakes, explain their thinking, notice patterns, and make sense of why the math works. They need more than the ability to follow steps and arrive at the correct answer.
Good math instruction isn’t about choosing between teaching students and letting them figure everything out on their own. It’s about knowing when to model, when to guide, and when to give students the space to think. I worry that presenting direct instruction as the answer overlooks the complexity of teaching math and the importance of developing independent mathematical thinkers.
I want students to leave my classroom not only knowing how to do the math, but understanding it well enough to reason, make connections, and apply what they know in new situations. That broader vision of math education is too important to dismiss.
Read more
Mathgal45
This is not reporting
Hahahahaha, scripted curriculum is your big suggestion? Why is this one guy who once taught at a preschool being given so much credence, while mountains of research belie this approach?
Pumpkin Song
Eye opening
Thank you Emily Hanford and team for your important work. As the parent of 2 dyslexic kids, I loved season one and now am loving season 2. It’s so validating to hear out loud that I was right about what my kids needed and all those educators with advanced degrees were wrong. It’s also heartbreaking because my children already aged out of secondary education. One is doing great. The other dropped out of college after one semester and is convinced he’s not smart. I once had a conversation with his principal where she said “direct explicit instruction is not best practices”. The principal! I’m still angry.
Read more
cdenes
15 years in education
I LOVED season 1. I was so excited to see a new season. But really? You’re sponsored by one of those scam MRI machines? Unsubscribe.
Astoria Katie
A whole lot about very little
Perhaps this is revelatory for people that are not teachers? Or at least accurate or interesting? For someone like me who has been teaching for twenty years, some anecdotes about a preschool teachers methods and the attitude like teaching kids things is brand new, or “new again” is ridiculous.
We as teachers are incredibly dynamic and use many different methods of instruction; at least the good ones do. Trying to simply teaching into “this method is best for all kids of all ages, all abilities, all interests, all subject matter…” is just asinine and likely only speaks to people who know nothing about what true educators do each day.
This podcast really depresses me by what appeals to the masses, and what passes for well researched. If people think that direct instruction is not as common as white bread, they are idiots.
Read more
golden1692
Former teacher
As a teacher trained in the early 2000s, this fits my memories. I drank the kool-aid. I believed kids would learn at their own pace. I was wrong. So so wrong. I learned, but it was a hard turn. There was a reason why “Hooked on Phonics” commercials were running 24-7 when we weren’t teaching enough of these skills in the classroom.
Midwest jess
Much Appreciation
This is a fascinating and honest investigation into Direct Instruction, a method of teaching that is highly effective and widely ignored. Education leaders, pay attention!
Bill Sower
I teach
This is very interesting especially because I am a teacher I would 100% recommend this podcast
Clown lbghhg
Thank you for bringing light to this issue
I am an 8th grade math teacher in a large urban school district who is required to use a popular problem-based math curriculum. The people who write these curricula are enamored with ideas of student discourse, productive struggle, collaboration, class discussion, and teacher-as-facilitator.
In a classroom, these practices look good. Students are collaborating and appear to be engaged in math like high level academics. Now, there is nothing wrong with students working together to solve problems. However, these question remains whether these students instead are learning math well through these practices. According to the research by Kirschner (2006), the answer is probably not.
We need to continue to expose these ineffective instruction practices and implement math educational practices that work.
Thank you taking on the story being sold about math education. I hope the message reaches as wide of an audience as the first season!
Read more
spendtoomuchtimeontwitter
Thank you!!!
I am so glad you are covering this topic! I learned to read through phonics and still use those skills
to this day when facing challenging words. Especially scientific and other languages. I really hope you move onto math next. I feel the same duping has occurred. Thank you again !!
madroneleaf
Please define the problem season 2
Season 2 is taking a long time to lay out their case against math teaching. Like many people, I found season 1 to be a game-changer in the educational space. Season 2 is not making nearly the same amount of headway. As a math teacher, I’m not quite sure what is meant by “discovery teaching.” I am familiar with “problem based teaching.” Is this what the journalist is arguing against? If so, please define the issue. I finished episode 2 and you still haven’t gotten there. It’s just 3 teachers complaining about their math teaching expectations.
Read more
neen1982
Let them be little!
Can we please let go of this notion that earlier is better? Preschoolers do not need to be learning algebra. They do not need to be sitting through direct instruction at all. I'm going to try and get through this season but if this theme keeps up, let's hope this podcast doesn't influence early childhood education to the extent it did reading.
Nattles19
Bravo!
I’m so happy you’re covering Direct Instruction in Season 2. It’s so important. For the people who have left negative reviews, you must engage in systematic and timely data collection to determine what works. Terms like ‘guided strategic feedback’ lack a clear definition, but I am really happy everyone is learning about Zig’s approach to effective instructional design.
UpNorth7
Season 2 should be called, “We Are Selling A Story”
It should be a crime that you are misrepresenting research and should fact check the information you’re spreading. You claim that students today do not begin algebra until sixth grade. Have you looked at the grade 1 standards? Students are expected to solve equations and story problems with unknowns in all different places. I do not see discovery learning happening in classrooms. I see a shift from direct teaching, which has not worked to guided inquiry combined with guided strategic feedback and strategic coaching. Our country is mathophobic and it’s not because the adults in our world experience discovery learning. It is the result of the story that you’re trying to sell.
Read more
MooreIntoMath
Failing Forward
What a crime that so called professionals disregard the science over politics. Phonics and decoding are akin to teach a man to fish vs supplying him with fish. The catholic schools always taught phonics and decoding. They know it works
migney moo
Too many decades for this problem
Finally someone gets what I have been saying since the 90’s both my children in the 90’s went to a good public school but I couldn’t believe what I was seeing when I would go in the classroom to help, by second grade most of the kids were expected to read and write but it was ok if everything was spelled wrong or they couldn’t read it . I am only on your first episode but I am curious to see when you found this issue of teaching reading and writing as a whole language had started which was what was being used at the public school my children were attending. I think it started back in the 70’s! When I was in school, good or bad for me, I had been out of school due to illness, and while at home I had a neighbor teach me what I was missing and taught me phonics and how to read. My siblings didn’t seem to have the same level of phonics as me because I remember sitting and helping them read especially my sister who was 8 years younger than me. I can’t wait to hear the rest of the episodes. I have shared this podcast with my daughter who is also a teacher. Even before I learned of your podcast I have started to teach my 5 year old grandson how to read using phonics. He doesn’t like it sometimes because I make him actually look at the word and sound it out and not guess. I think so many parents just expect the school to be doing their job which they are based on their curriculum, but even teachers should question their curriculum if they are not seeing results for their students. For my two children, I had ended up pulling them from public school and put them in catholic school where they were still teaching the fundamentals of reading and writing using phonics and actually making students spell correctly. Now can we talk about the next elephant in the room Math!! I think that should be the next podcast once you are done the reading podcast. Thank you for bringing such an important touchy subject to the forefront of parents and grandparents.
Read more
The Bookkeeper Repairman
Everything I already knew… but I thought I was crazy.
Watching your child guessing in Kindergarten, skipping over words. Saying sound it out, over and over. I knew my mom said, once they go to Kindergarten you don’t know anything. But I didn’t expect the American school system didn’t either. Luckily our small school has involved parents, but I also think that hurts our kids too.
Traci 513
No blame game
The critics of this podcast claim that it places unfair blame on teachers. I had the opposite impression. They claim that it exaggerates how widely used the cuing system was, when in fact it explains why using phonics was less effective when only used supplementally, and gives examples of the many reasons these not just less effective but harmful strategies became more popular. The critics strike me as having reasons to be overly defensive, in ways that feel disrespectful to the honesty of the educators who aren’t, and to the many people who know their education was compromised because of vibes-based educational theories. I will say the writing stretches this out to more episodes than were probably needed, and the cohost should have stuck to helping with research; he has absolutely no speaking presence and the episodes with him are hard to listen to.
Read more
ninety6tears
FACTS
Open, transparent & insightful. Thank you for the affirmation of science and data over political influence and money.
The state of our education system is criminal.
Nesorneb
so interesting
i started this show on a whim and was truly amazed by how well researched and well presented it was. i've already told everyone i know that they need to listen - super important for all americans to understand how issues like this arise and are perpetuated in our institutions. it's amazing that emily was able to make a difference through her reporting, thank you emily so much!!
Phoebeeeees
Does anyone else find it ironic
that the cohost reads his script with poor fluency? His phrasing is so stilted.
E Jam
Thought Provoking
This podcast explains so so much.…it’s so sad. I’m surprised parents all over are not rising up and demanding action but just allowing these teachers to put their children at such a disadvantage. I cannot imagine a life without the joy of reading. What really is appalling is the evidence…if readings scores are continuously falling wouldn’t that speak to the fact that this method of teaching is failing?
Read more
12Mo67dr
Powerful
I am veteran teacher of NYC public schools in grades 3 to 6. I’ve gotten training on the balanced literacy, Clay, Fountas, Pinnel and Caulkins curriculum/framework. I was thrown after bingeing on this podcast. Then I sat on my couch in the dark as I processed what I heard and reflected on my career. I’m still processing and reflecting. Is teaching decoding the magic bullet? I’m not sure but so much of what I think I know has been thrown into question. Thank you for this eye opening reporting.
Read more
Betsy27
If you have kids, you must listen!
This is an awesome podcast! I listened to episodes 1-13 in less than a week. Emily presents a problem clearly in episodes 1-6. Then, in episodes 7-13, she presents a case study for a possible solution. This will inform how I teach my toddlers to read, and it will inform how I pick schools for them in the future. I would recommend this podcast to anyone with children.
Mr. Caleb S.
This explains so much!
Wow! I pulled my daughter from public school during Covid when she came home and I realized what she didn’t know. They had been passing her through because she was a ‘good kid’ and she would ‘get it’, eventually. She had reading recovery. What you explain is how I remember her reading recovery classes and books she would bring home. I have such a mix of emotions, mostly anger and sadness. I’ve worked hard catching her up in homeschooling blind to what went on in school … if I had listened to this earlier I could have helped her more purposely … it seemed odd to me she didn’t know how to sound something out and honestly I’ve blamed her, no idea she didn’t have this instruction at school. I’m so angry! Her spelling is horrible although her reading is good. It’s been odd to me that she can read but spell so horribly. She never learned the phonics… we are going back to phonics this year! She will be an 11th grader! Her reading and comprehension is great I’m hoping with this realization I’ll get her up to speed quickly on spelling. Thank you so much for this reporting. My 4th grader who was taught in homeschool only (phonics) spells better than her at new complicated words. Wow wow wow everything makes sense.
Read more
Tiffiney
