Reviews
via Podcasts
Awful! Undermines its own quality content
I was so fascinated with the subject matter and even the content but the cheap cliffhanger are completely unnecessary & extremely annoying.
venice18idontwantanickname
Great History Lesson
I love this era of tennis but somehow, completely lost track of this incident since then and its legacy. Pretty impressed to have John, Patrick, Pat Cash, and Ivan Lendl participate and just as important, the officials who were there on that fateful day in Mac’s career.
JCat71
Still excusing bully behavior
Everyone-from the narrator to his admirers to his friends-are still blaming everything-balls, heat, officials, his genius (though not genius enough to keep up with the rules), for being thrown out of a match. This bratty man-baby was finally held accountable. Not worth a podcast to rewrite history. I’ve listened to two episodes and am thoroughly disgusted at the awe and admiration with which the narrator describes this childish bullying. Why is everyone still scared of him? McEnroe was, is, and apparently continues to be an arrogant, pathetic bully. Still excused by sycophants. This is deleted from my feed. Bye.
Read more
MysteryLoverCoco
Not 100% Accurate
In at least two places, incorrect information was given. The first was this:
“Whoa! The words echo through the stadium and then are swallowed by something unprecedented. 15,000 people going silent simultaneously.
Not the polite silence of a crowd waiting for a serve. Not the concentrated silence of a tiebreak. Something more raw than that. The silence of collective disbelief.”
Yeah, I watched and listened to the video, and there was no collective silence. There were whistles, groans, and ongoing discussions immediately afterward. Check it out for yourself. Seriously, there was no concentrated silence!
The second was this:
“First default in men's singles at a Grand Slam, John McEnroe, Melbourne, January 1990.”
That’s not true either! Willie Alvarez had been ejected from the men’s singles tournament at the French Open 27 years earlier, in 1963.
Read more
MH_in_Oregon
Passion this one
If this interests you, you’re probably more than a casual tennis fan. And if you’re at least a casual tennis fan, this is a waste of your time. Poorly written, overly dramatic (and repetitious) delivery and just no compelling info.
OthersWereAllTaken
History, Drama, and Suspense all in one!
Fantastic history, and very engaging. I played HS tennis in the mid 80’s so I vividly remember John McEnroe’s explosive temper on the court. But I never knew the crazy things going on behind the scenes that changed tennis forever.
Rainbow98
Decent
Pretty interesting overall but the script between interviews reeks of AI writing, shame
Dmck90
Not enough content
Valiant effort and what they have produced is well done, however, there is just not enough content to make this into a multi-episode show. Incredibly repetitive.
SBS1880
Fascinating
Fascinating hearing about McEnroe, a complicated genius if ever there was one, and what led up to his default at the AO. The near ambient background soundtrack is distracting to my middle aged brain however. The parts without this weird music are excellent.
3510yogi
