Reviews
via Podcasts
Wikipedia
I gave it a shot and listened to the boy in the walls. Unfortunately it seemed as though the presenter was just reading information off Wikipedia, with no research done on the case. I recommend working on your storytelling.
Atomic_M
….
…..
ShelleyPulls
Melissa Gosule
I really did not appreciate the laughter when talking about my childhood friend’s murder. And no, you did not pronounce her last name correctly or really say anything meaningful.
Nikkii12436
Okay
Kate really needs to stop interrupting stories for random not really necessary tangents.
ksudhjsisnsbisnsbsj
Libs
I was ready to dive into the Bridgewater Triangle series they have but all the victim blaming and liberal propaganda like “Cause white people” statements when talking about the name of a war. Not to mention the main girl comparing her beliefs to the same as the Chief who wanted the land back. Guess what native Americans stole land from native Americans. So did they feel the need to “recognize “ the pervious tribes land like you are telling your listeners… Yikes.
Read more
poorpicks69
Victim judgement
Lots of victim blaming such as "if you can be influenced in leaving your children you're a bad person" lol they need to take a more scientific angle to their stories. Otherwise it's just silly girls talking about real people who have suffered.
Groomieswkris
Easy Listen
I genuinely like these girls. I’ve read that some of the reviews say they have no chemistry. I beg to differ with that. I enjoy the banter and their insight. Not everybody’s always going to get it right. So maybe that’s something they need to be more mindful of.
My only bit of advice would be leave the politics out of it. With the Rockefeller episode, they kept yelling about white privilege and colonization.
Read more
Stank1969
Missing context
Sorry but your summary of Brian Cohee lacks major context. For example, his car was in the river the evening before not stuck in the mud as you stated. And his story as to why was questionable at best. You state you don’t want to delve into gory details but there is a way to do this without sensationalizing a tragedy. You missed how chilling the initial police body camera footage is. Your disclaimer about how reliable the YouTube documentary is was interesting because it was actually in my opinion very well done in that they rely mostly on the police body camera and interrogation footage to speak for itself. The point being this guy was textbook psychopath and your rambling presentation doesn’t shed any new light on the facts of the case, plight of vulnerable unhoused people and the glaring systemic failures of mental healthcare in the US.
Read more
adrum1000
Nancy Drew girly
Silly goose!!!! (POV episode 55) I’m a Nancy Drew & Hardy Boys kinda girly at heart so this podcast is right up my alley. Although I do really love conclusive cases, and who doesn’t, but I also understand that it’s not always realistic so I appreciate the sobering notion and reminder of how terrible the world really can be, it’s a good reminder to always be aware and alert for yourself and others around you. I love the these three girls and their back and forth banter, I often find myself listening to episodes, and internally yelling, “Omgosh that’s so crazy what about ABC?! What if ABC did XYZ!!” And then two seconds later one of the three blurts out exactly what I was thinking. It’s also just super fun that they are the same age as me, I feel like it helps me relate better to their thinking and season of life. This is a great podcast and I will continue to binge until I’m caught up!! And my only negative review is that in the same week I was going to watch “gone girl” for the first time, it was the same week I listened to the episode where they completely spoiled the ending without a spoiler warning🫠😩Soooo sad… Also a warning to new listeners, the episode about the girl dying from abuse by her family and literally the whole town is really devastating and disturbing, so if you carry stories with you like me, and deeply sympathize with the victims. Do your sanity and heart a favor and skip that one❤️ But regardless of that, be prepared to check behind your shower curtains on the regular, be encouraged to buy a defense weapon, and get unintentional jump scares by your husband just existing in your house while you are bingeing with AirPods like me🤣 Sending love from Michigan girls!! Stay safe!!🤍🤍🤍
Read more
RangerIid
Tedious
For me, the storytelling, banter and even cadence of conversation are really tedious. I appreciate the background to the stories and some personal insight but even setting the speed at 1.5 didn’t move them along quick enough.
lelemerv
Love this podcast so much
I love listening to this and the banter and opinions make it better. Without that it would feel like all the other true crime podcasts.
The Duck*
For the three lady are amazing!
Thank you for the podcast! I know in my heart, this will help people find their loved ones! Thank you again I really enjoy listening to ladies and always making me laugh! 💕
jessilight28
Really good
Not sure what all the other reviews are complaining about, I find the childish banter and cussing makes it more interesting. Keep it up!
420💵💵💵420
I’m a male
Hey this podcast is pretty cool, 5 stars, thank you.
Heitman11
Love you guys
I personally love you guys! I truly enjoy all the side commentary and how off topic you get sometimes. I find it really hard to stay involved in a lot of podcasts but you guys just make me feel like I’m sitting in the living room with a bunch of friends eating popcorn and talking true crime. Great job!
Bkoop1406
Small tweaks
Good stories, great potential, too much stopping mid-story to go into personal opinions/reactions/discussions. I lose track of the story, often fast forward to skip the personal banter and end up losing interest since details are missed. As listeners, we care more about the stories than your personal opinions, reactions and descriptions of your facial expressions.
JessySnitz
Maddux case
Disappointed when I heard them say brother Zach was 28. It’s verifiable he was 18. Not huge but their relationship context was important I think.
Snickas bah
Almost good?
I gave it a listen as I’ve heard people say good things. Podcast content itself was good. Lots of details. The chemistry of the hosts is a little off, though. Like, are they friends? Is this just business? Are they mad at each other? Lol. I don’t know. Will try again but it’s been a couple episodes where I was genuinely wondering if they hate each other. Awkward.
ChristinaRipp
I like this podcast but please minimize the unrelated unimportant facts
I like this podcast and enjoy the dynamic between the 3 friends. I will say that some of the banter and unnecessary facts (not referring to the updates given at beginning of case- those are awesome, more so referring to telling us the city is the 12,456th smallest city in the state) can get a bit annoying and find myself skipping through a couple sections of minutes of the show because I’m just ready for the story to get on with it. I am listening to older episodes so maybe it’s gotten better since then. Otherwise it’s a good podcast and covers lesser known stories which i appreciate!
Read more
Boomboompow111
I tried.
Oh boy. Unlistenable. Pretty big topics for what sounds like 12 year olds. Childish banter, reading the script & not adding anything new or interesting to the true crime world.
NannyRA70’
Too Much Foul Language
Come on! Just stick to the facts, an occasional though filled input and less giggling like teen ages. And lose the valley girl a accent- totally annoying
Ccr9217
Love it!
I binge the whole thing, definitely my new favorite podcast
Going@up
It’s a NO for me.
I tried, but I can’t. That’s the review. 👎🏾
Stylyst
What in the world.
More facts and fewer trivial and emotional reactions, please. At the moment more speculation than facts/ insight.
sblathe
This podcast is amazing!!
You guys all do such an amazing job, please never stop making episodes!!
Gleek :)
Very enjoyable
These gals are doing a great job! The rude reviews are just that; pay them no mind.
I’ve been enjoying the podcast’s story selections, funny banter, and the intelligence the hosts speak from. I like that they throw in fun topics like cryptids and spooky places like the Bridgewater Triangle. Keep up the great work! :)
waxinggibbous
Like the podcast but one note
Like the podcast. One thing I noticed, when mentioning Black women under the age of 18, you refer to them as adults or women (this is in reference to a missing 17yo). However you refer to white women that’s 21yo as babies (George brinkman case). Please be mindful of that.
BossShay1102
So Judgey
I started this while mowing my lawn, I literally had to stop and find something else. The three of them… Not only are they judgmental they drop the F bomb constantly. The podcast is very unintelligent.
Shell6262
Worst Podcast I’ve ever listened to
Girls, you need to be more professional! Your podcasts revolve toooo much on things NOT EVEN RELATED to the stories. By the time you gals get back on track I can barely remember where the story left off. Just go back to your days jobs, what are you gals 18, 19 or 20? Sound like 15 year olds. Sorry not Sorry
Gina Kilgore
Amazing, incredible, 10/10
Highly recommend this podcast. 3 amazing and hilarious hosts. I could listen to this all day. They are victim based and caring while also making it light hearted. 10/10 listen to this podcast, you won’t regret it. Rachel, Cate, and Kristine are amazing!!!
261836292618826~
Probably not
This was rough. The research into the stories doesn’t seem to go beyond googling the wiki entry. One of them really loves to hear herself expand on nothingness. You can tell it drives the other host nuts. My favorite was when we all learned what a corral was👀. The best part of this show is the name.
NORT14
Voice and listening quality BAD
These girls can’t even read from their own script. The audio is awful. Example - the Jameson truck was found abandoned, slight laugh Why? Do better
readingrenee
Great podcast
I just caught up on all episodes
I really enjoyed all of them and can not wait till the next one.
Reni5619
Love it
Love it
Emilia8746233
Maren Milford
I enjoy the podcast.
FYI a Milford CT woman was murdered by her ex Dec 2022 after obtaining protection order. It’s so sad so many women are murdered by their partner.
Mama G & 3
Every sentence goes up
Every sentence they speak goes up on the last word of the sentence. Very irritating. Very immature.
Mesndblues679
Needs work
There’s literally a cricket chirping in one episode and it was making me so insane I had to turn it off. 🥸 Also frequently factually inaccurate.
Kzawisl
Kate is great
She’s great and so is the rest of the podcast.
Cubcubs
This is for Kates dad
It’s a good one, You should be proud.
mcgillagull
Love this podcast!
I stumbled upon this podcast and have been binging it recently! I love that while they are discussing difficult topics, you can still get some funny moments from three totally relatable friends, which makes it a bit easier to hear. I also find it super important that it is victim-based and that there is information about missing people to hopefully help spread awareness to seek information.
truncg
Great show
If you’re looking for a show that is funny, sad, and just a great time with true crime!!! This is the show for you!!! Love this show!!!
james sumski
