I like standing with pastrami.

My first listen was Murder of a Bad Man. I laughed so hard about fast food novelty hats that I had tears in my eyes. Everyone here is rally nice & tight nit. Update: I’m listening to old episodes & loving every ibit of it. Review updated for the algorithm. Yayyyy choooo chooo PS: I love the overview of the small towns.

I really like this podcast, but for the love of god stop speaking 25 minutes about the average household income and square footage of homes in these towns.

I really wanted to listen to this because it was out of my home state. But your criticism of the people and the land was so offensive that I’m not listening to it and you deserve a one.

The true crime content, and most of the humor is great. If you're a long time listener, you have noticed that James is getting more and more arrogant and treating Jimmie worse. He definitely takes advantage of Jimmies self-worth issues from his childhood. This poor treatment escalated the second they got on Netflix. James now just repeats how awesome he is and how he does everything. When the best humor is usually Jimmies authenticity and opinions. Months ago they called everybody who likes high school sports a Pedo. I wrote a review saying the same thing about them and they had it taken down. Looks like they're the ones who can't take a joke.

.

Freaking love these guys! They’re the best. They find the wackiest murders. 💜 u James and Jimmie!!

I have listened to this podcast for years and I love it. Grim Karen, Pocket Robin. I’m feeling nostalgic.

Great job as always

I just listened to the one where James does southern and Italian accents and refers to The Godfather and The Wire. Do not panic if you’ve heard this production because there are 800 more just like it.

Way too much unnecessary swearing. Making us sound like we have a regional accents and Kentucky hallow mentality. We don’t. That is so offensive

Teriyaki 🐓 chicken

I’ve listened to every episode, but I’m just over them. 1) James is a contrarian toward Jimmie. No matter what Jimmie says, even when he is making the exact same point, James has to say, “No, it’s not so much that but….”. You know what a contrarian is. He’s just oppositional and annoying. Yes, I’m aware there are threads on discussion boards about how the guys love each other and that’s just the relationship they have and James would defend Jimmie with his life, blah, blah…So understand this. I’m not questioning their friendship or feeling sorry for Jimmie. I’m pointing out a character flaw James has. It’s a personality defect to be such a damn contrarian. 2) They make disgusting breathing noises knowing full well they are recording a podcast with highly sensitive mics. Jimmie laughs so hard that all we can hear for a few seconds is the clicking noises in his throat. James has a habit of aggressively sucking in air through his nose right before delivering his next line. 3) We can already tell by your behavior and the abyss behind your eyes, James. You don’t have to announce you are Godless and soulless. This, and when you hint at politics, of which you have about the same comprehension level as a 2nd grader, is off-putting. 4) James spends about 1/4 of the show educating Jimmie and the audience about things he obviously knows nothing about. “This was how they did things back in the 70s,”….”In Louisiana they do things this way..”. Again, I’ve listened to every episode. I saw you live in Seattle. I can not fathom how anyone classifies either of you as a comedian. Of course, when you did stand-up you didn’t achieve any level of success. For the last year I’ve only listened out of habit and because your show puts me to sleep. But I’ve realized being lulled to sleep isn’t worth gagging at your throat and snorting noises.

As this story was beginning I thought it would be like A Beautiful Mind, that he would end up being paranoid schizophrenic. Did that ever come up in the list of possibilities you just didn’t have time for?

You guys are unhinged, hilarious, and I am here for it. Jimmie, you have the best laugh! Just hearing you laugh makes my day better! Thank you, guys!

Loved this episode, I live in upper Michigan (not the Yoop-I’m a Troll-live just under the Bridge) and was impressed with your pronunciation of Ontonogon! Anyway, I too live in a pretty small town, Benzonia Village in Benzie County. We’ve had a few rather interesting murders ‘round these parts and it’d be grand if you did a bit of research on Beulah, Honor and Frankfort and of course Benzonia (there is the township and village-both Benzonia). I looked up the population of the entire county, 18,568. (It gets larger in the summer, as it sits right on Lake Michigan. Tourists galore!) It’s the smallest of all the counties in The Mitten-including the Yoop. There are more demographics online but I’m danged sure you guys know where to find them so I won’t belabor those facts. Just thought I’d maybe tease you a bit about checking out our ‘quiet’ tiny town and its really beautiful environs, and not always so beautiful residents! Again, I love your shows, all but the sports ones, haven’t had a chance to listen to those yet. Just subscribed a few weeks ago! So as our president would say, Thank you for you attention in this matter! ~penelope…. But you can call me ~penny🤗🦋

Please tell me that’s the name of the weed shop in Massachusetts!

columbus does have decent pizza i promise. try artisan pizza cafe!!

I love the way they bring humor and common sense into everything. I listen everyday while I’m working. I’m happy they caught Brad’s killer guys! Great job on telling the story. I recommend their shows😊

Very Good. Worth A Listen

Awesome

We love your show, listen whenever we go on road trips. However, Jimmie, all of Texas does not suck!!!

The best dick jokes in podcasting. Also period jokes. And all things pee-pee and poo-poo.

I love this podcast and now they’re on Netflix!

Great content, working my way through this playlist.

Her name is Bree and she is a huge fan. Please give her a shout out.

I absolutely love love love this show!

Guess I have to watch The Wire

You guys are the absolute best! I love your style of podcast and your humor. I appreciate the time you take to get these stories together! I work from home and your podcast keeps me entertained!

I just got sent a clip from Episode 135 where you guys were talking about how much you wanted to call it the Funk house. Well that is my last name, and that is indeed what we called our house growing up 🤣

This is was I turn on every time I get in my car! Whether I’m driving the grocery or on a 2 hour drive. Time flies on long drives and I’m entertained the whole time. These guys interact incredibly with each other! Craziness and laughter-what’s better?!?

I listened to this show almost every day while I work. It makes my day go faster. I crack up all day! You guys are the best!

My aunt was the nurse on duty that night. You mentioned her in that episode. I mentioned to my cousins to watch.

Kids now days don’t understand

I LOVE these guys humor together and his story telling. I’ve been listening for a few years now and would love to see them in person! Great podcast, I love the long episodes, also fun to throw in an Express! Thanks guys for being my go-to!

Clouds are pretty. IYKYK

My husband and I love listening to small town murder! We call it listening to “the guys” and they do a great job balancing the telling of these tragic stories with entertaining perspectives. Solid podcast 10/10

…and give me real estate reports!

You guys kill it! Thanks for all you do to keep us entertained.

Crazy but interesting episode❗️

🤢

Just what I needed!! True crime with a side of comedy. What more could you ask for?! Pretty sure these 2 are my spirit animal. ❤️

The amount of research, time, and energy put into these is absolutely amazing. The comedic touch for it being a Murder podcast keeps it lighthearted and easy to enjoy while doing activities.

Longtime listener. I love the show and have never had an issue with the dark or vulgar humor. But lately, James comments about young girls who are assulted/raped/groomed have been hard to ignore. It’s not coming across as edgy or funny anymore. You can hear Jimmie trying to push back or defend them, and it gets shut down. James, he has a teenage daughter. Don’t be so obtuse. We hear it. It’s an issue. I really hope James becomes more aware of it. Jimmie, we hear you & agree with you!

👍🏻⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

My favorite pair of guys to have narrate facts about terrible people doing horrible things. Dark humor- but with respect for the victims- for the win!

Y’all are so funny. 😆 I enjoy Netflix and podcast. Thank you 💜

Always so much fun, thank you for being a bright spot to my week!

These guys are great! The show is even better!

!!!