Elton and Scott provide a very entertaining and humorous environment for fans of the show to dive back in and relive all the greatness and complexities of the show. They are both funny and witty and I enjoyed listening!

Well thought out & unique perspectives. Really enjoy the two hosts.

Just found this great podcast. A great listen.

I just wish I had found them sooner. I love listening to their theories, I am glad they spend time on creative ideas and not just recaps.

I discovered this podcast recently and it became my favorite after the first episode (and I think I tried every Lost podcast out there). If you still have doubts after reading all the other reviews, I can help by suggesting to ignore the only negative one, as it is probably addressed to another podcast. There has never been a Katy on this podcast. Furthermore, the listener who wrote that review should know that Katy is still a guest on that other podcast he probably refers to. He just needs to listen to more than two episodes. But I guess the most important thing is to remember the name of the podcast, especially when you decide to post a review. To conclude, this is a very insightful podcast, done in a very professional manner. It is way above what I thought was the best before I listened to these guys! Now I have a podcast too to obsess over and impatiently wait for the next episode! Thank you!

I really enjoy listening to Scott and Elton! Quite a great podcasting pair! I especially like all their hiatus podcast for the show! Great job guys....thanks!

Rethinking Lost is always informative and entertaining. Nothing against the marathon podcasts, but it's nice to have be able to listen to a concise show that packs a punch.

Scott & Elton do a great job of "rethinking LOST" while we listen over their shoulders. They have a good on-air chemistry and the podcast is informative and entertaining.

Best lost podcast out there. Don't overanalyze and keep it spoiler free. Fun and witty. The personalities have other podcasts to check out as well that are great. Listen to this on tuesday to hype for the coming episode!

Katy from What Katy Said has been the best thing about the show.

i love this podcast. that's all.

Elton and Scott are two funny and thoughtful commentators who bring the right blend of humor and intelligence to this podcast as well as their first podcast An Apotheosis of a Bombast! Give them both a try!

Rethinking Lost is a wonderful podcast. Scott and Elton do a great job of not getting too far over your head, yet they both have fantastic incite. One question guys where do you get your music I love it.

This, Donald is Lost, Lost mythos, Lostcast and the transmission make up a perfect podcast network! I love you guys.

Love your show. Keep it up. I need more.

Lost fans should enjoy this 'cast. Elton and Scott have a good rapport and create a fun and informative listening experience. I appreciate the imagination and effort they put into the show, especially in finding topics to discuss during the hiatus. Great job!

Elton and Scott put out a great Lost podcast. They have a unique take on the genre. They go back and 'rethink' older theories, articles and episodes. They have good chemistry, are respectful and thoughtful. These guys really stand apart from the other Lost podcasts that I listen to...

These guys know their stuff, are personable without being annoying and bring a fresh new perspective to the LPN. Thankfully they keep the non-Lost chitchat to a bare minimum. This podcast along with the Transmission and Dharma Dummies are the best value for your listening time.

Concise, informed, and refreshing. I really like this Lost podcast. Cheers guys!

I enjoyed this podcast. The guys really seem to know their stuff. Can't wait for future episodes!