The Critics Club kicks off the holiday season by arguing over what actually counts as a Christmas movie, with Die Hard at the center of the debate. From holiday traditions to non-traditional picks, the discussion spirals into nostalgia, genre rules, and why some arguments never die.

This week on The Critics Club, the guys tackle their Top 10 “Based on a True Story” movies… after Jim realizes he prepped for the completely wrong topic. From there, it quickly turns into a mix of actual film discussion, personal stories, heated arguments over what “based on a true story” even means, and a surprising amount of yelling about Fargo. Geoff kicks things off with Cool Runnings, immediately derailing the room. Jim scrambles to rebuild a list he never made. David goes to war defending and attacking movies in equal measure. And at some point, Oppenheimer becomes the unofficial drinking game answer. It’s unfiltered, dumb in the best way, and full of the exact kind of movie-nerd energy you listen for. Join us for bobsledding, McDonald’s history, CIA manhunts, Enigma machines, sad dog stories, and a truly unhinged debate about whether 300 counts as “history” (it absolutely does not).

The Critics Club ranks their top movie adaptations, from Jurassic Park and Casino Royale to Crazy Rich Asians and The Devil Wears Prada. Geoff, Jim, and David compare books and films, share opinions, and debate what makes an adaptation succeed.

In this inaugural episode of Critics Club: Deep Cuts, Jim and Geoff dive into Takashi Miike’s psychological shocker Audition. What begins as a melancholic romance transforms into one of the most unsettling horror films of the early 2000s.

The Critics Club: Superman Review (With Special Guest Louis) **Full SPOILERS** Geoff and Louis dive deep into James Gunn’s Superman, breaking down everything from the casting of David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan to Lex Luthor’s darker edge. They debate how this version stacks up against Man of Steel, gush over the film’s standout score, and discuss the impact of new characters like Krypto. Plus, the duo look ahead to the future of the DC Universe—Clayface, Supergirl, Lanterns, and more.

Geoff, Jim, and David each bring their personal Top 10 film scores—and yes, things get heated. Geoff champions emotional powerhouses like 1917 and Up. Jim dives deep with Gojira, Drive, and There Will Be Blood. David rounds it out with sweeping favorites like Gladiator, E.T., and his crowned #1: Star Wars: A New Hope. There’s some agreement, a lot of arguing, and maybe too much shade thrown at The Dark Knight. Come for the music, stay for the chaos. 🎧 Listen to all episodes at RantingMedia.com

Geoff and Jim (David’s off this week) crash the Cannes Film Festival 2025 and call out the hype. From Eddington to The Phoenician Scheme to Spike Lee’s latest, we break down what’s actually worth watching. No film school degree required—just press play.

Jim, David and Geoff have reconvened the Critics Club just before Summer--or Prime Time MOVIE TIME--rings in for 2025! Here are our essential, top 10 Summer Blockbusters! There are some surprising ones--Pacific Rim? Empire Strikes Back? ....a Will Smith movie that's NOT Independence Day? We got em all. Tune in and be schooled!

Geoff, Jim and David are back to talk about their favorite box office flops of all time. Didn't know your favorite films didn't make it big at the box office? You might be surprised to see some big names, including The Big Lebowski, Iron Giant, and more. Tune in to hear our favorites and let us know in the comments what yours are!

Join us on The Critics Club as we dive into some of the most iconic movies from the 2010s! From the stylish nostalgia of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood and the futuristic spectacle of Tron: Legacy to the intense passion of Whiplash, Jim, David, and Geoff break down what made these films unforgettable. Tune in for a thrilling journey through a decade of cinema filled with innovation, powerful storytelling, and unforgettable moments!