This week's Special Children are Andy Gallagher, a lovable stoner with the power of psychic mind control and an amazing van, and his Evil Twin, who uses the mind control to kill people. Turn on the disco ball and fill your giant bong; it's time for Plushienatural! This week, Dean 🧸 gives the Plot Recap, Amanda gives the Commentary, and Sammy 🧸 contributes an LVP and Plushies Make Everything Better. Join us for the return of classic rock, and don't forget to text us!

Sam and Dean stumble onto yet another case involving an undead college student and the pathetic TA who brought her back with ancient Greek necromancy. It's a case that causes both Sam and Dean a great deal of pain--physical in Sam's case, emotional in Dean's. As usual, Dean gives the plot recap, Amanda gives the Commentary, and Sammy helps Dean explain how Plushies Make Everything Better. Join us for Dean's most athletic kill to date, and don't forget to text us!

Sam and Dean run into a fellow hunter, Gordon Walker (Sterling K. Brown), on a vampire case who turns out to be Real Bad News. As usual, Dean gives the Recap, Amanda gives the Commentary (and she promises that it's not just 20 minutes of gushing over Sterling K. Brown), and Sammy helps Dean explain how Plushies Make Everything Better. Join us for the most sinister game of Quarters ever!

Season Two gets underway by introducing a new location, the Roadhouse, with its own cast of recurring characters, Sam and Dean take on a case involving a killer clown from a traveling carnival despite Sam’s crippling coulraphobia.  Dean gives us the Plot Recap, Amanda gives the Commentary, Sammy gives us both an LVP and an Honorable Mention, and Dean and Sammy tell us how Plushies Make Everything Better. Join us for a window-smashing, crowbar-bashing good time!

We've made it to Season 2! In this episode, we see the fallout from the car crash cliffhanger that ended Season 1. Dean's in a coma and almost dead, John's a lying liar who lies, and Sam's making really unsubtle metaphors involving the totaled Impala.  Dean gives the Plot Recap, Amanda gives the Commentary (with a bonus song clip!), and Sammy gives us an LVP and Plushies Make Everything Better. Don't drop your coffee as you run to listen to this episode!

Plushienatural hosts Amanda and Dean attended Creation Entertainment's Supernatural convention in the Washington, DC area from November 1-3, 2019. In this special preseason episode, they recap the con panels as well as their adventures in karaoke, the Saturday Night Special concert, and Jensen Ackles's VIP Meet & Greet session.

It's the end of Season 1 of Supernatural in episode 22, "Devil's Trap." Bobby Singer is introduced, the demon possessing Meg is exorcised, killing her body in the process, the boys help John escape the demons, and it ends in a brutal cliffhanger, with the entire Winchester family fighting for their lives. Features include the Plot Recap (Dean), Commentary (Amanda), Lore Break (Sammy), Best Song (Dean), Plushies Make Everything Better (Dean & Sammy), and the End of Season Awards (Dean, Sammy, Amanda).

The Winchesters are in a tough spot this week in Season 1, Episode 21, "Salvation." Meg's killing John's friends in order to get him to hand over the Colt, which Sam and Dean need in order to kill the Yellow-Eyed Demon in Salvation, Iowa. The episode ends with John getting captured by Meg and Sam trying to run into a burning building to get revenge on the YED.  Dean does the Plot Recap and the Best Song, Amanda does the Commentary, and Sammy helps Dean explain how Plushies Make Everything Better.

We're in the home stretch! This week we're kicking the Season 1 mytharc into high gear with Episode 20, "Dead Man's Blood," in which the death of John's hunter friend allows the Winchesters to obtain a weapon that can kill the Yellow-Eyed Demon. John's back, and the tension between him and Sam finally is resolved in a surprisingly calm and quiet fashion. Dean does the Plot Recap, Amanda does the Winchester Family Feels recap, and Sammy gives out an LVP and says how Plushies Make Everything Better. 1

This week's episode is a Goth's dream. Season 1, episode 19, "Provenance" features a creepy painting, a creepy doll, and an incredibly creepy little girl ghost. It also has the first potential love interest for Sam, a spunky girl named Sarah who insists on being part of the hunt.  Dean gives the Plot Recap and the Best Song, Amanda gives the commentary (which includes a special listener giveaway!), and Sammy and Dean explain how Plushies Make Everything Better.