
There I am starting the pizza show!
I wrote a pizza play called Slice Something Slice. Some call it a pizza opera or pizza musical. It’s a stage event about the power of pizza. I put the show on a few months ago with friends and family. It was so much fun we’re doing it again this October 29th at the Brillobox, but this time we’re opening this up to the pizza community at large. Tickets are on sale and we’re selling them at a nice clip. At only $10 (no fees!!) it’s a great deal for a truly unique experience.
Buy Tickets to the Pizza PlayWhat makes this Pittsburgh Pizza Play so unique?The actors are you - well if you want!There are six scenes in the play, each focusing on a different pizza parlor that the protagonist, Slice, visits. As people show up to the show they sign up for a part in the scene. You’ll be handed a script, a name tag and then when it’s your turn you’ll get on stage and read your lines.
Maybe you could be the Pizza Angel??
Something truly magical happens when people get on stage. Obviously the script is very funny, but because we’re all in this together it becomes a safe space where the inner actor comes out. I was blown away by the performances last time we did this and I’m looking forward to seeing how everyone interprets these characters.The scenes are short - maybe 5 minutes - so you’re not stuck on stage for long. You can see a list of some of the characters here.There’s a live band playing original songs written for the play!My friend and creative collaborator, Chad, got his band together and wrote a number of songs for the show. They help set the vibe and fill in some of the story beats. Like a real musical! If you ever heard the Pizza Talk With Me theme (below) you’ll love the songs at the show. Once you hear the Greasaroni Stomp, you’ll never forget it!
Pizza Play Theme Song
Chad McMutrie
I’m obviously bias, but having a live band on the stage just elevates the whole experience. Really makes it feel like a legit performance - which it of course is!There’s a neat visual elementMy sister made a nice little animation that, uh, expresses the themes of the show. It’s embedded below. Imagine seeing this on a big screen though - pretty cool!
Get your ticket todayThe Story So FarHere’s the Synopsis:The story takes place on the Pizza Continent. Over time the citizens have cultivated the land to reflect the beauty of pizza. All citizens of the land love and enjoy pizza pretty much daily. There is an organization who operate a Pizza Priory.This Priory takes in young children and trains them in the ways of pizza - this is important to their mission of uniting the world under one perfect pizza. They are protected from the outside world, but when the world needs united a Pizza Prophetis sent on a Pizza Pilgrimage to unite the land. These Pizza Prophets make their way to the Pizza Altar and give the ultimate pizza recommendation to the Pizza Angel.Pizza Shops around the continent must obey the decree from the Pizza Prophet. The hope is that the prophet suggests the perfect pizza and everyone on the continent is united by the one perfect pizza. Yet, none have been successful.Can the newest Pizza Prophet succeed where others have failed? Or will they be thwarted by the dreadful Greasaronis who haunt the prophets?Part of the reason I chose to write about pizza is the silly little thing everyone does about pizza: argue about what’s the best. There’s frequently new rankings, pizza awards or pizza brackets in the media. Why? People can’t get enough. If you ever need a spike in web traffic put out a ranking of Pittsburgh pizza shops. Like throwing chum in the water.This is shaping up to be a very special night, so text your group chat the link to the ticket page and start figuring out what parts you want to sign up for.
Two greasy guys playing the roles of GREASARONI TONI and Greasaroni Sam
Get these Greasy Tickets to the Pizza Play!
Aug 23

I talk to Dan of Mun's Pizza. He recently quit his job and is going all in on his pizza (and a few other things). He has ambitious plans to carefully cultivate and grow a pizza business. This is your chance to get in on the ground floor of the hype train.
Our discussion is far reaching. We talking about his career that lead him to this point, how he spent time working at Badamo's and Driftwood Oven, what is Pittsburgh pizza and some exciting new plans on the horizon. Super hyped to have him on here.
Jan 26, 2024
45 min

Hi there! Back in the feeds. Driftwood Oven is a pizza shop I've been covering since the inception of this website. When they burst onto the scene I knew that my site was perfect for covering the development of Driftwood Oven. It's been eight years, a lot has happened in the mean time. Driftwood Oven hardly shifts anymore, they now have a shop. They deliver. They do a lot of fun events and pastries. Listen to Neil dissect his business and how he got to where they are today.
Aug 4, 2023
45 min

Long time no pizza! Hard to believe we took a bit of a pizza hiatus. Funnily enough I was at the doctor today and they told me I need to “take a break from tomato sauce”! This means nothing but white pizzas for next week’s episode.
In the month or so we’ve been gone, too much has happened. We recap the wonderful winners of Pizza Expo. Winners include Eric Von Hansen who can’t seem to stop making award winning pizzas. Additionally, Pete Tolman from Iron Born placed second to Eric with his forager pie.
Pizzas We Ate
We go through our inventory of pizza and we ate a variety of slices between recordings. The biggest surprise for me was a box of frozen pizzas that arrived on our doorstep. Made in Italy, then put to sleep until they’re ready to be eaten, Pizza Talia is a clever and novel pizza invention. It’s a remarkable product that replicates authentic Neapolitan pizza. Check out Pizza Talia.
We eat Spak fairly often, but hardly dip into their specialty pizzas. We are big Buffalo Chicken Pizza fans so we gobbled up Spak’s take on the legendary style of pizza. It’s quite good!
During a recent trip to NYC, we got pizza from the “under rated” pizzeria F&F pizza. This is a newish shop in Brooklyn and is some of the juiciest pizza I’ve ever had! I’d compare it to a Pizzeria Davide. Very delicious, worth the trip.
Sep 23, 2021
45 min

Well, the fates have conspired once again to deliver a majestic pizza miracle to our humble doorstep. That’s right, a few days ago I received a text to “check my doorstep” where there was a suspicious package sitting. I figured we were beyond the days of “see something, say something” so I scooped up the package and unraveled it with excitement. My prize? Two day old slices of Altoona Hotel Pizza, straight from Altoona.
Christa and I couldn’t wait to dig in. We recorded a live episode of the podcast so our reactions are fresh out of the oven. Join us on our journey as we dissect Altoona Hotel Pizza, admire its character and sturdiness.
As you can see from the picture above, the pizza is a Sicilian style slice. There’s a thin layer of sauce, a green pepper and then it’s covered with a few slices of impenetrable American cheese. The cheese forms a protective layer around the pizza, like a tarp covering a classic car from the elements in a suburban driveway.
Our Order
24 hour old slice of Altoona Hotel Pizza
Altoona Hotel Pizza News
Altoona Hotel Pizza via PGH City Paper - Ryan Deto does a deep dive on the origin of Altoona Hotel Pizza, including its origin of creation dating back to 2013.
Join the Pizza Walk With Me Discord to talk about all things pizza with your new pizza besties!
Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify
Listen on Google Podcasts
Find your pizza date with Pizza Date With Me
Our Order
Pizzeria Davide Old World Style Pizza
The Lebanon Sweet Bologna & Hot Pepper Relish Pizza
The house salad
A secret meatball dish!
Aug 13, 2021
25 min

In this episode we declare Pizzeria Davide the official pizza of the Dogs Day of Summer. This is an elusive prize for pizzerias because eating a hot slice of pizza on a sweltering day may be overwhelming. But because Pizzeria Davide uses such fresh, delicious, ingredients their pizza is instantly refreshing. I could blend this up and drink it like a pizza smoothie!
Our Order
Pizzeria Davide Old World Style Pizza
The Lebanon Sweet Bologna & Hot Pepper Relish Pizza
The house salad
A secret meatball dish!
Jul 20, 2021
53 min

Christa and Dan devour all that Brooklyn has to offer via Caliente Pizza & Drafthouse in Bloomfield. We even get insight from a real live Brooklander.
Jul 5, 2021
47 min

Well it certainly was a hiatus, but we are back to bring you some greasy, gooey, ooey takes on Spak Brothers pizza. Spak Brothers is one of our classic go-to shops. With a wide selection of toppings, hoagies galore and salads that will bust your gut wide open.
A couple of items we talk about:
Driftwood Oven is closing for a month for some supreme renovations. We talk about what some of those renovations are and how excited we are for this upgrade.
Rockaway Pizzeria has created a Buffalo Chicken pizza, sans ranch. Is it really Buffalo Chicken pizza?
The international pizza expo is adding an Italian Sandwich category to their championship competition. What hoagie would you submit?
What is up with Altoona Hotel Pizza??
Spirit and the Vandal turned six years old! HBD to them, true staples of Lawrenceville.
Join the Pizza Walk With Me Discord to talk about all things pizza with your new pizza besties!
Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify
Listen on Google Podcasts
Find your pizza date with Pizza Date With Me
Jun 7, 2021
57 min

Welcome back to another great episode of Pizza Talk With Me! It’s been a while since we recorded so there was a huge back log of news and updates to provide. We talk about:
How Pittsburgh is secretly a world-class pizza incubator.
This extensive Food and Wine article that covers the best pizza in every state.
There is a mini review of Black Lotus Pizza in Lawrenceville.
The star of the show is Wood Fired, a new pizza shop in the old Pizza Taglio location run by the folks behind Lorelei.
May 17, 2021
55 min

We eat a supreme pizza and a white pizza from the Newman’s Own collection.
Apr 26, 2021
36 min
Load more
