Absolutely riveting and well executed. Each episode is unique and truly personal, drawing in the listener. So listen and get drawn in!

This is such a beautifully produced podcast, with twists and turns and poignancy and surprises! The stories are simple yet captivating. I did the thing where I sat in the car in front of my destination, so engrossed I was unable to push pause. I was late for my thing. Thanks, dummies!

This was so interesting. I could see someone in the 70s hiding a stash like this; someone who treasured his paraphernalia and stash. Maybe it was an old guy/gal that hung on to the past.

But so good

Have to admit - I’m a podcast geek. I love them and this is my new favorite. It’s unique “hook” lends itself well to exploring personal stories. I listen often while driving and will sit in the car in the parking lot or at home to hear the end. And the hosts - insightful.

I enjoy listening to this intriguing podcast that uses simple objects as a way of getting into some very personal stories told by those involved and its fun and entertaining hosts. As a hoarder living in a small apartment, I have a lot of objects that affect me in a very real way :) Can't wait for the next one so I can mentally escape my physical prison of clutter!

This podcast is incredibly original. There's nothing else like it. It's storytelling will have you intrigued and on the edge of your seat.

I stumbled upon this mistaking it for Personal Effects: sword of blood. At first I didn't know what to make of it but I kept listening and now I think I like it.

Two sparkling personalities who happen to be pop culture authorities walk into a bar, and with this podcast you get to listen in on the conversation. Not content to merely indulge in their own considerable charisma, they introduce us to a cast of fascinating folk and the MacGuffins that move them. Charm and intrigue ensue!

Only a few episodes in, I can tell this will be one of my favorite podcasts. I love the premise of the show, and the storytelling is outstanding. Give it a whirl.

Already my new favorite podcast! The shows grab your interest while you're commuting to work, working out or enjoying a cup of coffee. Engaging, funny and sincere.

This podcast is fun, creative, has really interesting little stories, is delightfully conversational and I love the rapport between the two charming hosts, Alex and Warren. It reminds me of other greats like Love + Radio, Radiolab and Mystery Show. Thus far there's only been a few episodes but I can already tell this will be a mainstay in my playlist. Can't wait for the next one! Let's help keep this podcast around for a long time! Oh, and I love that logo! I'd go for a t-shirt with that logo... -WC

Full disclosure, I helped with the first episode, but the second hit me like a ton of bricks. The honesty and willingness to explore something so personal and intense was riveting...came to hear my own voice, sat in the car in the driveway to listen to the entire second episode because I didn't wanna go in and stop listening. Can't wait to see what they do next!

Oh my god this is the best review ever! EggMacguffin?! Cashbrowns!? Also I loved you in American History X! I love your sad eyes! V V V

I LIKE IT

Two episodes in and I am already as in love with this as I am McDonald's breakfast but without the guilt and shame! Give these two a side of cashbrowns!