Bring back OTM
I love this show. I need this show. Sometimes I listen twice. Please stop putting La Brega down the OTM feed. And loading the show with La Brega stories. I get it. You want a crossover audience. But you’ve overplayed your point, and now it’s enough. Tell WNYC to do the promos as they should and let us have OTM back.
OTM is the Worst
Journalism school try-hards commenting on the state of journalism... The reason OTM seems so out of touch is that the creators share all the same assumptions, allegiances, and biases of the thing they’re supposed to be analyzing! That’s why so many episodes end up sounding just like a (slightly more meta) version of your typical smug npr news weekly.
completely out of touch, for comfortable white liberals who don’t care about anyone else only
Basketball Warriors was a big turn off
I had to turn the basketball warriors episode off. I care about Puerto Rico. I care about the struggle for sovereignty and independence. I care about the stories and history of Puerto Rico. But I don’t care about sports. And the narrator of this episode was way over-the-top about sports, in every segment of the episode. A different host could have easily made me care about sports; but not by being overly-emphatic in ever single segment. It was exhausting, and it seemed like the narrater was more concerned with expressing his own passions about the sport, than about telling a story about the sport, and its significance to Puerto Rican culture/history. Unless *he* was supposed to be the story. And I guess I just don’t care about his own personal story (especially since I don’t share his passion for sports). . . . In previous episodes, the narrator weaved in personal stories with the content of the episode, and it worked. In previous episodes, I enjoyed learning about things I never cared about before (like how track homes are made), and I loved learning about those things in the context of Puerto Rican history. I was ready to go with the host anywhere she wanted to take me. But this guy? He wants to take me to his childhood bedroom and relive every quarter of a basketball game with him? No thanks. It just seems weirdly self-reflective, like he’s showing off some flex for which he hasn’t done the work to explain why I should care. . . . I do look forward to future episodes, and I really hope that they aren’t just tumbling down the rabbit hole of self-reflective autobiography, and instead refocus on the in-depth storytelling of Puerto Rico which was so captivating and wonderful in the first few episodes.
Heads Up, CNN has Entered into an Exclusive Contract with RUPERT Murdock
Hello "On the Media", I'm a loyal fan of your podcasts, but I hope you can cast your gaze onto a media access crisis that is about to take place in Australia. Here in Australia we have a few competing Cable TV providers, but only one carries FOX News Network, and that one is called FOXTEL and it is owned by Rupert Murdock. To avoid supporting FOX News, Australians can subscribe to FETCH TV as their Cable provider and get BBC World, MSNBC, etc.... and that included CNN International... or at least it did until the end of this month. Time Warner has entered into an exclusive contract to sell CNN broadcast rights exclusively to FOXTEL. Basicly, they've done a deal with the Devil. We're gobsmacked. That spot reserved for CNN is about to go dark on TVs across Australia, and we will go into a permanent state of mourning. Georgette Grezak Mosman, NSW, Australia
So one sided
I can’t. Had to listen to an episode for a school assignment. I’ll take a zero on the assignment then listen to this crap. So so so one sided. Thank you, next.
Depth, through lines do the job
Extremely-helpful depth so educational. Thank You.
The Decline of Cuomo with Alex Pareene
Good episode, but his butchering the pronunciation of the city that is home to New York’s state capital undermines Pareene’s claims to mastery of the subject of NYS politics.
La Brega is groundbreaking
OTM is a great show deserving of 5 stars, but the usual fare was eclipsed by the fabulous La Brega — Levittown. Who knew there was a Levittown in Peurto Rico? Vivid story telling, bursting with affection, family pride, frustration over the dysfuctional infrastructure of the neighborhood and the country, and heartbreak over dashed dreams. But most astonishing was the humor and total lack of bitternes in the telling.
Excellent reporting on the reporting of the news. Always interesting and different perspectives
Some stars are earned purely by the hosts’ voices alone. Both their voices sound so authoritative and sonorous, and I enjoy listening to them. But beyond that, the writing is excellent on this show and many times I have been struck by how eloquent the commentary is. The topics are very thought-provoking and the guests are interesting and informative.
While I believe everyone would benefit from listening to this program, as a former journalist I think it ought to be required listening to work in the industry. Your straight, truthful, fearless reporting is an inspiration
2/4/2021 podcast special
First, OTM is the best. But in this episode Bob says “the first voice you will hear is Julia’s”, and then Julia’s voice is not first, and when she does speak the first thing she says is “Hi, this is Julia...”
OTM really is the best.
The comment about TGIF is well put! I also look forward to Fridays to hear OTM. Thanks to everyone that puts this incredible show together for the rest of us!
green new deal
Brilliant on every level
Thank you for helping us through the past four years and hopefully seeing us back into the light, however dim. TGIF has another meaning for me.
I grok it
Always informative, always lucid. But I swear, half the appeal is hearing Gladstone consistently use the verb ‘grok’. Gladstone for President of Mars.
My go to source since 2001
At its best when it analyzes coverage of other media.
Used to be incredible, now just Meh at best.
On the Media used to hold EVERYONE accountable and would take to task irresponsible journalism. BUT NOW they have become part of the problem and have a thinly veiled agenda.
The Consistently Best Media Every Week
I have been listening since before podcasts were a thing and you I just hoped I caught it live on radio - well I soon made time for it every week and it continues to be the most important thing I read, listen to, or read. The variety of interviews as well as Bob and Brooke’s candor are the mix that keeps on giving. I promise every episode you will find something to love and possibly even something (or someone) to disagree with. Enjoy! (started listening in 2004ish)
Increasingly Distracting Background Music
This show is not alone in this but it is getting to the point where the background music is by turns so dramatic or so cutesy that I can’t even listen... This seems to be a fashion now with radio and podcasts. I really don’t understand it at all. Can anyone explain what the purpose of all the background music is for?
All media is biased because it is created by humans who are all biased in some way. Knowing that, media ought to be consumed as one would food in their diet. Healthy portions with understanding of what you’re putting inside you. I recommend OTM as an insightful podcast to add to your repertoire whatever direction your beliefs skew towards.
Must-listen every week.
Posted Episode jumbled
As posted, the episode posted 11/20/2020 to Appl podcasts , “Believe It Or Not”, is jumbled. It starts correctly with the intro, moving into the first segment on pressing government officials for sources driving government edicts in response to COVID-19. But then, 3+ minutes in, it jumps to the last 3+ minutes of the closing portion of the Pete Souza interview, then the closing credits. I can jump past this premature closing, but it goes to the same last 3+ minutes of the Souza interviews at least twice. I didn’t take the time to jump past the same sequence repeatedly until the full 50:30 podcast completed, but I expect the “Groundhog Day” syndrome repeated to the end. In short: needs fixing!
The only podcast that makes you want to dance
OTM has a vibe and unique mojo, and swings like Ellington and Armstrong (not words usually used to describe an NPR podcast) Maybe it’s there pacing or that Brook and Bob are so darn smart. The writing and production is stunning, every week year after year. It would be impossible to compile a “Best of OTM “episode.
Used to be good. Now it’s just another wokefest.
Really sad about this. I used to love this show’s intellectual curiosity. But in the last year or so, it’s become ideologically monotone. Ideology guides every story choice, every analysis, every take. Predictable and tedious now, especially if you don’t share the religion.
My favorite podcast
Always superbly crafted. (in detail, tone, timing, aesthetic etc) Just fabulous.
The amazing Randi
Thank you for this conversation with one of the great truth tellers!
simply the best
One of the only podcasts I have listened to on a regular basis for years.
Very clear reflection on the news
A clear presentation that goes over what’s going on without spinning it.
Don’t disrespect Darwin
The 10/14/20 conversation left me confuddled. The worst part is it’s based around a book. THE book. So many simple biological fallacies and misattributions to Darwin - I feel likely there was no malice, simple failure of comprehension and understanding of current science.
Liberal Austin Hawk
My Island of Sanity
BG and BG give me a bit of hope that all of the world has not abandoned reason and critical thinking. Thank you On the Media. I recommend your show to anyone and everyone who speaks of current events with either confusion or authority. You are my island of sanity and my comfort.
The Very Best News Analysis Podcast
No one does frank, brutally honest news analysis better. Immediate and topical, there are days I know I need to listen to On The Media right away to decipher and filter out the noise and make sense of it all.
Great show! Bad audio (sometimes)!
Brooke! Bob! You guys are the best. But I’m here to tell you there are better ways to record interviews than old-school phone call audio! There are myriad services (such as Zencastr) that will take audio from someone’s laptop microphone, which while not perfect, at least does not sound like it is coming from 1950. Smartphones also generally come equipped with simple audio-recording apps. My video team does this all the time and even hardcore luddites can manage it. Please consider making the switch and making your indispensable show even better!
Not like I remembered. Sad to have gotten so ugly and biased. Too bad I used to like this show
A strong bias in favor of consolidated, corporate media.
Seriously? Have they run out of subjects? Paris Hilton and Reality Daiting TV? The Qanon piece was up to their usual high standards and the rest was absolute garbage.
Doc the destroyer
Excellent but ...
Fifth star withheld because of the horrid noises and stressful drum beats on every intro so loud they obliterate everything said. WHY?????????
My favorite podcast
OTM is my favorite podcast. I listen religiously every week to their main episodes and the podcast extras. It truly is a great source for information on what the media is doing wrong and right and teaches me to be a more critical consumer of media. Share this podcast and donate to WNYC so they continue doing their essential work!!!
Your episode on Mr.Rogan was an absolute abomination.
I’ve had a hard time getting into this podcast, although I had high hopes bc of the topics addressed. Anyway, recent episode on joe Rogan put the nail in the coffin for me. The journalist on the topic already was biased against him from the get-go, like who is this “non-journalist” who is about host a presidential debate. Every single thing they mentioned about joe was in a negative light. They made it out as if all his guests are high or drunk, which is not true. They made home out to be this dumb muscle head who just appeals to bro- mentally. The guy has had Elon musk on his podcast just days after his baby was born. Wow. I just can’t believe what an inaccurate and poorly balanced show that was. TERRIBLE REPORTING.
My #1 Resource
I started listening to this show in March at the beginning of the pandemic. It’s been my resource for news ever since, especially since I don’t want to get sucked in and discouraged by the second to second headlines online. I appreciate that they discuss the news and how the media is sharing, or not sharing, important information. The April 24th episode, “On Matters of Time and Space,” probably got me hooked because their guest talked about the creation of time as we know it. It was relevant as many people were working from home due to social distancing, or unemployed...I know my use of the day had changed. The BLM movement was reinvigorated after that time period, layered with election coverage, layered with rampant conspiracies and misinformation. There is so much happening and I trust On The Media to help sort it out with their engaging guests and thoughtful questions.
Used to be a great show
I understand that you dont like the President and the President doesnt like the media. This would be a GREAT place for you to be, right in the middle of it and analyzing both sides. Instead you ALWAYS skew your viewpoints to the left. Its disappointing to hear what used to be a great and objective show just trying to take shots at the current administration. Too bad, good riddance to my subscription. You are living what is wrong with todays media, bias.
JS from NYC
One of the best news commentary shows of all
Imagine if reporters never took anything on face value. Imagine if reporters asked not only “who, what, what and where,” but also “why am I being told this?” Imagine if reporters had a deep appreciation for context and consistency. That’s On The Media.
The best podcast there is
I listen to dozens of podcasts regularly. I oftentimes put this one off because the subject matter is serious and requires concentration. But this is the most important. The unusual lens they take — coverage of the media covering the stories we know about — provides facts and insights found nowhere else. If I could ordain one podcast to be listened to by all Americans, it would be this.
Intro segment background music has got to go
I love OTM and have listened for years but the most recent episodes have 5+ minutes at the top of the show with clangy irritating background music competing with the show content—why?!?! Please eliminate this, it makes the show almost unlistenable.
Sounds more like a left wing puppet every day
I use to love npr... but it’s sounding more and more like a radical political servant. Today’s episode ended with a woman claiming that the wayfair scandal is 100% false. But I’m not convinced. If anything, this made NPR look complicit in Wayfair’s wrongdoing. Sex slavery seems like a real issue more enormous than I ever thought. With every reporter telling me it’s not real, my mental lie detector goes off.
After weekly “It’s hopeless why don’t I just end my life now?” malaise that I’m overcome by after each episode. I pull myself together and give thanks to Brooke, Bob, Katia and company for soldiering on. When I think of the sheer volume of manure that must be waded through in order to cull the choicest excrement down to a one hour show I must stop and salute you all for possessing a stronger constitution than I. Well produced, exceptionally well written. Just keep the sharp objects out of reach while listening
Armed and Dangerous
“Armed Right Wingers”, are causing violence in American cities??!!?? While I would not dispute this as happened, but then I’m objective. For you to say, in your title, even if qualified later in the story, shows that you lack objectivity and journalistic integrity. Yes, that commitment to neutrality you learned, of way back in college, and then committed your lives to can you remember that and say your meeting that standard. You clearly lack the morale fortitude to report anything that your click would not like to hear. How you could possibly, objectively, make the inference that violence in our cities is driven by the right wing. We all read, see the news, national, local and the black clad BLM and Antifa revolutionaries, the continuing destruction they have promoted, the disregard for the rule of law, over the last 100 days. What’s sad about it is they are primarily destroying property and lives in the very communities they are supposedly saving. It’s sad and your lack of moral courage, and obliviously fear becoming an outcast in your closed East Coast Community. Remember what made you journalist because this is just lazy work. Step outside your world, where everyone thinks the same, yes continue to hate the President, that’s fine, but do your job correctly. Joseph G. would be proud of this piece or work/propaganda. Yes, I live in the fly over zone, but no I’ve never worn a Trump Hat but I do posses moral courage and never lie to myself. Please do better than this your failing to live up to your own standards. And you wonder why people don’t trust you??!!!
Over production interferes with great content.
I really like this show but the production and montage is getting a bit too over produced and dramatic. Please leave On The Media alone. The black and white, no nonsense, honest and always interesting version was great.