Mystery Show
Mystery Show
Gimlet
Reviews
via Podcasts
More!
Starlee’s humor is spot on… this podcast is one of my top 5. I wish there were more
mikoliciouss
If you like Heavy Weight, you’ll Love This
Just caught up with Heavy Weight and wanted to see what else Gimlet has to offer and I wasn’t sure about this one. I just finished the first episode and I very much enjoy this. I hope there will be more! Officially binging!
gaptoothedbitch
Fantastic !
Love it so much!!
Holly Finch 90
Heck
I heard about it on the Gavfwst
Sno & Lo
Love this show!
I heard Starlee in a recent interview say the show may come back. I sure hope it does.
Iluser
Long time listener, first time rater.
I you guys, I’ve never done this before. I’m usually not that kinda girl. I can’t tell you how much I loved every second of this podcast. I want
kschwatzle
The best podcast of all time
Dont cry because it’s over, relisten to the episodes over and over because it happened
Tony Guac
Why not more?
I love the timbre of Starlee’s voice and her genuine demeanor. So much fun!
allimare
Gone but never forgotten
I miss this one.
GG from Seattle
Brilliant
More, more, more!
Fanboy5678
More please
I’ve always loved you on TAL. MYSTERY is brilliant.
Julie in AZ
Why do I love this so much?
Every topic seemed so off the wall that I kept thinking, "ok, there's no way Starly can make this one interesting."...and yet she does, repeatedly!! She tackles the random mystery or strange question from an individual's past or present and vows to solve the case, no matter what. It's humorous, heartwarming and downright interesting. I'm hooked!! I wish this podcast would come back. It was hands down the best think on the internet.
Read more
Waiting For Baseball
Starlee!
Love this pod. Starlee, you are the heart of EPM. And now this. Thank you, particularly for the toaster belt buckle and Jake G episodes.
Jane in Portland
More please!
Love this lighthearted mystery show! It’s entertaining, light, funny, and actually a little suspenseful because you do want to know what happens!
Raycrizzle
Please bring this show back
This show is amazing. Just discovering it now. Please bring it back! Especially in light of the Reply All mistakes
11Leonora1
Need more
Plz bring back this show!!!!!
GiTatanka
😛😋🤪🥳🤩😎 🌈🍄🌺
I love mystery stories but it is SO hard to find good ones, and this podcast is so good !😊
shsygidtjgj
LOVE and DEVASTATION
And a splash of hyperbole. I really really enjoyed this listen. I found this podcast via Heavyweight podcast. Knew Gimlet would have some other good stuff. BRING our fabulous mystery woman and her PDCAST BACK!!
alikovestotravel
2021 GREAT!!! FUNNY!! I love it!
Where is more what happen?!? It’s a great light listen I love it will their be more episodes?
Medinajoes
It’s a crime that there isn’t more Mystery Show
Simply the best of the genre. Starlee Kine is a genius.
Susannah Smith
Perfectly satisfying
I just found this in 2021 and I absolutely love every episode. I wish this had five seasons so I could keep listening! I love that each mystery has a solution. Each one is wonderful and I would honestly do alot of things to bring this podcast back.
Lillllll lõplik
Listen again and again
I have just now listened to all the episodes in 2021. I imagine I will listen to these episodes again. My favorite has to be “Belt Buckle.” This is so well produced and Starlee Kine is a wonderful interviewer. Thank you for this gift.
Moocow14
Light touch, sensitive investigations
Starlee was really a marvelous interviewer; she allowed the people she came across to be quite comfortable with her, even as I'm squirming in listening to it. I used to host a podcast and know how hard it is to get it done, and she did. If Mystery Show didn't have a sweet spot in that summer before Trump, it certainly hits it now.
touristinthecity
Hope
Wishing this back into existence!
Language Mentor
Just amazing
I got to this late and it is such a shame that this show was cancelled. This has brung me so much delight. Starlee is such a skilled storyteller and detective, it amazes me how she solves all of these mysteries.
Oncognito
A freaking delight
I am sad I don’t listen in 2015, but in 2020 / 21 world this podcast is even more of a delight. Now that Spotify owns Gimlet can we bring it back? Hey, Max Fun network - let’s create a “new” show. You know you want to.
hjcoffman
Kotter
Starlee. I listened to your Kotter podcast today. If you can send me your email, I can forward you my fourth grade picture, from 1977, wearing a Sweathogs shirt
KravMarc
Amazing show
This podcast is beautifully done. Starlee Kine is a gifted storyteller.
wtyyuuu
So good
I’m _way_ late on this podcast, but it has given me a lot of joy during the lockdown. F Gimlet
khlvklsh
Starker is so missed.
The best podcast, incomparable. Such a shame it was cancelled.
whitzgig
No more?
I love this podcast, but isn’t there more???
ßłë
Where did it go?
The last episode says they will be back in July...over 5 years ago. What happened? Where’s Starlee? We want more!
BreeSpree3
MORE PLEASE
Binged in two days. Please resurrect this 2015 gem.
Annie Acker
Ok so...
This is a really great podcast I completely understand if you do not like it but I found it very interesting and I am sad it is not still being made! Happy 2021 Also just wanted to say the song for the intro by spark and called those mysteries. Ps love yourself you are amazing Also if you love this podcast I recommend sending gimlet emails or letters to get this podcast back on
realreveiws from real people
Need more
Just discovered! Love this show
softail1959
Bring it back!!!
Just discovered this podcast and it totally surpassed my expectations. The host is extremely likeable and you can tell she put a lot of time into writing the story. I wish it would come back! Belt buckle episode is the sweetest thing I’ve heard. And the Britney episode was super nostalgic.
Annieheart
Great Podcast. I miss it.
This was my all time favorite podcast. It was a nice break from the True Crime overload. It was nice to just hear a story and to find out the foundations of it. A+
illnation504
Simply the Best
More than five years after first hearing Mystery Show, it remains among my all-time faves. Such a pity that its run was so brief, but that makes each one of the episodes a true treasure. I’ve made everyone I know listen to the belt buckle episode.
Modernista64
Great little podcast
What a gem. Every story is told with great detail and care. So interesting!
Bronx.amy
Crushed
I came across this the other day and I absolutely love it. Each episode is so rich with lots of unexpected turns. Amazing story telling. I just noticed this came out in 2015 so that’s that. It’s one of my favorite podcasts (I listen to a TON of shows) and I am so sad there isn’t more! Times are dark and this was a great escape.
Cry Trefz
More Starlee please!
This is a great podcast. If I find anything else by starlee I will definitely listen to it.
Kmac54386
OBSESSED!
Absolutely obsessed! Charming and so interesting. Please come back!
Esutton2
Love it!!
Please continue! These are sooooo good!!
Unknown12345708431
Bring it back!
I want many things in life. One of the biggest ones is for this podcast to come back. It’s incredible, and I’ve been waiting for five years now. 😞
Father French
Road Trip Essential
I recommend this to everyone with long commutes/travels. Regardless of their preferences they all love it!
Ayo.Stay-
bring this back!
the latest mystery is “why did this amazing show stop?” please make more of it!
calilah westley
Please come back.....
I loved this show. Starker...come back!
Teh Brw
Mystery Show was the best
Every now and again I check back to see if this podcast has re-emerged from its marvelous cloud of ridiculousness. And alas, again no Mystery Show. Absolutely brilliant show. Please return!!
josebuendia
Bring it back!
Can we bring this show back!!!? It’s soo good!
Po L.
Perfect. Timing.
Perhaps the best way to end 2020 for me was finding and listening to this show. But unlike 2020, the series ended way too fast.
HeLLo...M
Load more