Reviews
via Podcasts
Great Podcast
Loved this podcast I’m not sure how I found it but I’m glad I did.
Ronarn2
Polarizing Reporting
I really wanted to like and finish this podcast, but the snarky comments and tone and the one-sided reporting about law-enforcement made it so distasteful. I did not finish this podcast.
New recruit!!
Won’t listen
Sorry, am sure the podcast isn’t bad but will not give any of my time to listen to anti-police propaganda. Recommend sticking to the story and keeping opinions to self. Unfollowing.
Bye bye IMDb
...
Not the best pacing but interesting story
it's me opal
Disappointing
Daisy’s story was compelling and deserved to be told. The anti police bias was frustrating but the podcast was solid until the end. Why in the world did they keep calling Jeffrey’s killing a murder and act like there was a murderer on the loose? They casually told the story quickly of how he setup a pizza delivery man and pulled a gun out to rob him. Then the delivery man defended himself and Jeffrey was killed. How can a podcast simultaneously speak up for those affected by violence and also dismiss this guys actions and play him a victim? What? A truly delusional narrator. Journalism was lost in this mess of a show.
Read more
everydaytrader
Dumb premise
Wow, such dumb
AnonyCrat
Ok
Started out great but turned into anti-police podcast.
Stephanie Waltz
Nice try
So one sided. Law enforcement are trained. Lots of whining and overdramatizing.
Asolare
A biased and drawn out telling of a very tragic story
The heart of the story, a case of domestic violence ending the life of a promising young woman, whilst very common, is important to tell over and over again in efforts to reduce such outcomes. But the narrator, and I’ll say narrator because I would never call this journalism, was very biased in her attempt to smear law enforcement when it sounds like they actually did a great job and truly cared. It’s understandable when families feel like law enforcement aren’t doing their jobs bc they are often provided little information as to what’s truly going on during an open investigation. But it sounds like they were doing - and did - a lot resulting in a successful outcome. The part which was touched upon and should have been the main focus was what to do in situations when a minor finds themselves in a domestic abuse situation and doesn’t want to report it. Legally, I can understand why it’s impossible to convict when the victim won’t report, but some type of support to both parents and Daisy should have been provided.
Read more
Whirlwind1788
One sided
Really going for that anti police rhetoric here… the officers and detectives have so many cases! Of course, each families case is most important to that family but these detectives are working hundreds of cases and are always working hard. The murder was solved, take the win.
LKMWAZ
Right?
Excellent reporting and investigation. Listening to your interviews with Detective Lugo, I feel the need to express that when someone is speaking and ends their sentence with "Right," it's because they are looking to others to affirm what they're saying, essentially to get the listeners buy-in. The detective said, "right," A LOT when he was speaking with you. I get that it could be a habit of his vernacular, but maybe he also knew he was feeding you half truths and wanted to make sure that he could say you "bought into" what he was selling.
May Daisy and her family, and the family of Jeffrey, find some peace.
Read more
Thusar30
10,000 stars
Praying for the families of those killed
Mycatbanana
Let’s be honest.
Let’s be honest on what this podcast was and what the motive was for making it. It’s a clearly anti police rhetoric with a victim mentality. You just want try and prove police didn’t do their jobs correctly and the public was responsible for solving the murder.
Disgusted11122
Too one sided
This podcast had potential, but it’s clear the host lacks a real understanding of how the justice system works or what law enforcement professionals actually go through. You’re being given explanations, yet you continue to push a narrative that blames everything on social or racial injustice. One of the individuals even says, “I grew up here, I’m Mexican,” trying to offer context and it’s completely dismissed.
You also don’t seem to understand how certain actions like families publicly announcing that someone is missing can actually harm an investigation. Anyone familiar with true crime podcasts knows that public interference often makes things worse. When there’s less outside noise, police are sometimes able to investigate more effectively, and suspects are less likely to flee unlike what happened here.
You’re just bashing the detectives without having any real insight into how their job actually works. I only finished listening to hear the results of the case.
Read more
Born in LA__
5 stars
Praying for the family.
dx jifztj
Rest and peace daisy and Jeffery
I really liked this podcast because they really try to help with this case and also that they mostly got justice for what happened to daisy and that the legacy of daisy and Jeffery can be shared to many people so they will never be forgotten
caleb__gone
The Story is great, narrating not so much
My wife & I were interested in this story from the beginning. I agree with other people here with the narrating being slow and unprofessional. The only reason we finished it was because we wanted to hear how it ended. The episodes are very short with a lot of commercials.
saintsgirl32
Well done podcast
Rest in peace Daisy. You deserved to live a full life and to be able to bring all the goodness you were about to embark on into this world. I appreciate the verdict. Everyone deserves justice. My heart goes out to her family and friends.
Thank you to the insightful people who brought this true story to life. Very well done. I just wish it was fiction.
twistydawn
Didn’t need to be a podcast
While justice is important… this is a murder, with one obvious suspect, who was arrested and found guilty. I’m not sure why this warrants a podcast. This happens all the time. Again, it’s sad. But not interesting.
M_A_Cross1997
great pod!
such a brutal and heartbreaking subject but i really appreciate the care jenn put into this
frickkkskk
Reality of DV
I listen to this in shock a few years after the murder took place even though I knew about it. I have friends that knew the victim and I just can’t imagine what everybody in this situation had to go through.
Celtic Leo
Definitely worth it
I listened to this whole thing in one day. It’s definitely worth it. To think these things happen in the world all the time makes me sick, but we can’t ignore it.
Thank you, Friends Of Daisy, for speaking up.
Documentarylover13
I love it but is it continuing?
For me, I can’t really see if there will be another episode, but it seems like it will be the final episode so I am STRAPPED IN for that.
Ace of the kingdom
Binge worthy
I just binged this whole first season. The narrator has such a calm soothing voice that makes it easy to listen to and makes you feel like you’re sitting there as if you’re watching from her pov. Great job ladies can’t wait for more episodes.
Katiiekat3
Lazy
I found this podcast to be frustrating and one-sided. The tone often veered into unnecessary cop-bashing, which felt more like provocation than thoughtful critique. TikTok - the show painted the platform as entirely positive without acknowledging any of its many issues.
The guests interviewed seemed immature and lacked depth in their analysis. Their comments came off as juvenile rather than informed, especially when discussing serious issues like law enforcement, crime and social media influence.
Also, relying so heavily on eyewitness accounts was disappointing. We know from extensive research that eyewitness evidence is often unreliable, and the podcast didn’t do enough to address that.
Read more
GCR64
Maybe I’ll try again later
The vocal delivery was distracting.
Rozet76
Too Slow
My biggest question is why is it taking forever to drop each episode? Agree with others the narrator is not my fave but I’d like to hear the conclusion without having to wait a week or more between episodes. I also agree this narrator does not understand how crime investigations work.
Not happy12345()
Not well narrated
Did not finish episode 1 because her voice is hard to listen to and the writing lacks professionalism with the overuse of “like…” I told myself that if she said “like” one more time then I would stop, which I did. Interesting story but I will search for the detail of this trial elsewhere
jmdv007
Gave it a chance
Sounds like something from a poetry jam or book reading. Too artsy. Stopped after five minutes.
Matt_B_W
Tempo
Amateur writing.
motsapropo
Clueless
While I appreciated the story and the manner in which it was told, it is more than obvious that this interviewer has absolutely NO idea of what goes into a homicide investigation. She also has no sense of the caseload these detectives and officers have. Or the resources that are stretched so very thin. I also didn’t appreciate her attitude toward law enforcement. You couldn’t possibly understand what these men and women go through if you’ve never walked a mile in their shoes.
Read more
Jenny Meagan
Love the Narrator and added sound effects
This is one of my favorite three crime podcasts that you can actually listen to consistently. I just binged season 1. Thank you and keep up the great work! The other negative reviews don’t do justice here!
Missess_lindsey
Season 2?
Shedding a light on DV and WOC is so important and hearing the accounts of Daisys community brings everything into perspective. Ready to hear more about this care. RIP to Daisy.
TTORRES.TR
Frog voice
I wish I could listen to more, but I had to stop. The narrator’s voice scrapes my eardrums like an ice pick.
Why on earth do so many of these podcasts sound like a frog?
I think it’s called “vocal fry” and perhaps it’s some kind of trend.
Unfortunately, for me, it completely ruined the experience.
dotsofuinmyeyes
Good..
I’m enjoying the podcast. I live in a neighboring city next to Compton. So close to home.
Mexi-Bunny
Before You Bash
Plays the same ol' 'race vs law enforcement' card. I think anyone who holds a podcast based on truecrimes should either; a) have a criminal justice background themselves or b) shadow someone in law enforcement for an entire case and see how many hoops, laws and procedures they have to jump through & follow before sharing details with family, let alone the media! Although, the story itself is very important and heartbreaking, I feel it's definitely one sided so far (episode 6).
Read more
MichCamJax
Mediocre At Best
I listen to a lot of true crime and a narrator can make or break listenability. This narrator is so melodramatic. The sharp inhales, theatrical pauses, emphasis on certain words, drawn out syllables for effect— there’s something about performing while telling someone else’s sad story that feels so narcissistic. This narrator centers herself somehow, takes herself way too seriously, and all in all the quality of the work feels YOUNG.
Read more
Bgisurja
😞
Interesting story.
California Carolann
Well done.
Great reporting. Smart. Well done.
kyespeer
Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Jaka
Get io oppp
Great Podcast and Stiry
To hear the voices of the people of the hood is revolutionary and it feels good to know their stories are getting out. Thank you. I am waiting for more.
Teritown
Great story, but…
Way too many minute details that aren’t needed. For example, what her high school (or college) teacher was wearing during his interview added no value. Small thing but there are so many instances where this happens, it becomes more noticeable. And it’s only now in episode 5 where it starts with finding Victor. I don’t know how many episodes are left but my opinion is this whole series could be done in 5. I will say I am riveted by Daisy’s story and appreciate the time & effort the host has spent telling it. Just tell the story without the in the weeds details. :)
Read more
FooForever
Great Story, bad ads, but want to hear the rest
I really enjoyed what I’ve listened to so far (4 episodes). Very much looking forward to more, I don’t know when they release as I just listened to all this past Sunday. There are a lot of ads and the California psychic one is really annoying. Love the story though and can’t wait to hear the rest of it.
Damienyikes
Syrian culture
Lebanon wasn’t in the country until 1942 and yet you’re saying all these people are Lebanese. All these culture references are all Syrian culture references, not Lebanon. At one point you actually had a legit scholar on that confirmed they were Syrian immigrants. Do the people who made this want to squash all middle eastern culture?
Omellyyyy
Great Listening
I find myself re-listening to podcasts because finding decent new ones is hard! This one was great! Easy to listen and keep interest!! Wish it was longer!! Can’t wait for more 🖤
kjomaurer
Narration
Probably an interesting story but I couldn’t get past the narrator’s voice and inflection. Had to stop listening.
HBmtn
Yawn…
Don’t waste your time.
No, please!
Amazing podcast!
I really liked enjoyed listening to this podcast. Hard to find new ones to listen to that I’ve never heard before. Looking forward to more. Great work:)
Nicole_ADA
Too many ads
Story is interesting but there are SO many ads - especially for 30m episodes. Seems close to 50/50 ads to content.
picsofyorkies
Not Exploitative + Social Value
Title says it. On ads: investigative journalism of this caliber is expensive. Ads pay for the many expenses you can even imagine. Plus creators should be paid for the gifts of their talent that we receive. We’re spoiled to expect « content » for free. This isn’t just entertainment. It’s about a young woman with dreams and aspirations who was stolen by violence. It’s about how law enforcement’s response (or not), it’s about public policy. It’s ultimately about love and justice. Worth some ads. Worth the listen. Just FF. Seriously. Bravo prod team.
Read more
nobody4971
