Love this! This has become one of my favorites. Thank you!

The hosts have a great chemistry. They each offer great commentary. Ethical to a fault and I appreciate that.

I’m a long-time listener, finally reviewing. This podcast represents the gold standard of ethical and well-researched journalism. While other media outlets talk the talk of corroborating sources and refraining from advancing spurious claims, Áine and Kevin actually walk the walk too. I have also so enjoyed learning more about criminal law, benefitting greatly from the hosts’ layperson-friendly explanations and examples. If you’re a nerd interested in criminal law and getting into the weeds of evolving criminal cases, this podcast is for you. If you’re not a details person, it may not be.

I listen to a lot of podcasts. There are too many words being said here. I want to hear what happened in the courtroom and facts. You are disputing with each other how names are pronounced and giving tons of opinions and speculation. I just want to hear the report back of what was factually said and happened in the courtroom and less of your opinions.

Really enjoyed listening to Aine and Kevin’s take on the Delphi murders. No nonsense and learned so many fascinating details. They were both compassionate, intelligent and personal! Love these guys! Justice was served for Libby & Abby ❤️

Looking for a podcast to follow the Delphi murders trial. Very unprofessional journalism, it felt biased. After the unspent bullet ep I tried another pod on same topic and was shocked at how much info Murder Sheet skipped. Moved on immediately. And they’re writing a book?!? lol.

There is good info, and good analysis. Pretty good about keeping speculation identified. However by being repetitive (saying the same thing multiple times in a row in an episode and continually repeating info each episode), and by often saying things in the a drawn out manner, it goes on too long/slowly.

Like the new format. Also the cheat sheets.

I realized I skipped at least half of the episodes entirely and fast-forwarded through a lot more. In the episodes where they do unbiased reporting they are fine, but wow do they take a complete slant in the O’Keefe murder episode. It’s like they don’t want to acknowledge anyone else but this one random commenter? He even uses that quote about letting 10 guilty people go free as if he has no idea how our justice system actually works. Apparently they really believe in the integrity of one of the most corrupt police forces in the country. This started out as a podcast about restaurant murders, but apparently that was too niche to come up with content so they just kind of go wherever they feel like. I’ll see what the rest of the content ends up as but this is really hard to listen to without cringing. This is the same police force of Serial infamy FYI so take that for what it’s worth.

There is no better source for information on the Delphi murders. These two have provided great coverage on. Yes, they both have their idiosyncrasies-so did Barbara Walters. I get tired of hearing them get attacked just keep bringing it Kevin and Anya at the only thing I would say is don’t broadcast responses to the idiots out there. They don’t matter and they don’t have your following either.

The condescending tone alone is making it hard to listen to. The only reason for listening is to see what spin they are going to put on recent court filings these days.

How many feeds of this podcast are there?

They have interesting guests, they explain things very well, they are easy to relate to and listen to, their updates are timely and they obviously care about the victims and their families.

Episodes are to short.

Congratulations on the cutting edge work to ensure the public’s right to freedom of information is upheld. Integrity has gone a long way I’m helping uphold the public’s rights but not burning a bridge with the court. The most recent 2 episodes BEGGING people to delete leaked photos if they have them and do the “right thing.” Good point, spent too long on it. Admire you for turning the photos over to law enforcement. Admire you for deleting photos after you did. A short statement asking those who might have the leaked photos not to share because it jeopardizes the investigation and traumatizes the families suffices. Please don’t drone on about it for over 10 minutes.

Horrible. It sounds like they are reading from a bad script. Very amateurish and a complete regurgitation of information we’ve known for years. Nothing new here. I’d rather suffer insomnia than listen to these two.

Rambling, disjointed, female host - who supposed to be a journalist interrupts. over uses “basically” and “like.” Poor sentence structuring. The male host is supposed to be an attorney- maybe in traffic court! These two need to start writing- not have rambling conversations and stop apologizing for their lack of preparation.

Anyone who is a serious fan of True Crime must follow The Murder Sheet. These 2 are cutting edge investigators. Brilliant! No regurgitation of old research. Thank You Murder Sheet!