I love true crime and I love the PNW. I’ve had to stop listening because of the unnecessary political commentary and insensitive joking when talking about someone who was murdered. Please stick to the story.

Your delivery would be better if you left your politics out it… Each his own.

These two are SOOOO ANNOYING!!! And the guy yells like a little schoolgirl and it is SOOOOO cringey!!! And the female is almost as annoying but not quite as cringey as that dude!

TikTok recommended but the 1star reviews were the real qualifier! Thank you to the maga reviewers for letting me know I was in the right place… where you aren’t!

Alright, at first I loved these guys. Even though it’s pretty amateur and some of their “facts” aren’t facts, they have the gist of the story. They read off a script and that’s totally fine, but it’s a little dry. Now for the real reason I give this a 1 star… This podcast might be for you if you say that you are for loving everyone and acceptance for all, but you really have a lot of hate in your heart. They preach how everyone should just be able to live their lives and be able to be themselves, yet they hate constantly. There isn’t an episode where they don’t bring up a group of people they don’t hate. They hate republicans and if you have any of those beliefs they think you are trash. They hate anyone who believes in any sort of religion or belief system. These people can’t seem to just get to the facts or spread awareness of a case without being cruel. In their early podcasts they had someone who gave them a bad review and they made fun of them and were just mean to them for several episodes. It’s clear if you aren’t their version of a perfect person, you aren’t good enough for anything. So, I say this. Take them with a grain of salt. This podcast isn’t for everyone, and they make that very clear.

This is a very amateur podcast. The narrator sits and reads off of a piece of paper, almost as if they’re giving a book report. It’s not very engaging and it’s very difficult to listen to. I feel they have the right idea as someone being from the Pacific Northwest I find the case is very interesting but the delivery is subpar.

Maybe African Americans commit many many more crimes

Missed you while you were taking a well deserved break. Anxious to hear your voices telling us more true crime stories. ❤️

These two podcast clowns have no clue how to fact-check. Take their reporting with a grain of salt—they’re not worth taking seriously.

It’s like listening to an awkwardly read 5th grader’s report on a Wikipedia page, followed by brief, uninformed commentary that offers no original insight into the subject. Well intentioned, but ultimately it seems a disservice to the victims and survivors.

I’ve listened to A LOT of true crime podcasts and I’ve listened to this one for years, still one of the best. With 3 hosts they manage to get the ‘story’ across without inappropriate commentary, and the bloopers at the end still make me laugh, keep up the amazing work you guys 👏

If you’d like to hear Wikipedia read to you, this is for you

Straight and to the point true crime podcast. I enjoy listening!

I love this podcast! It’s conversational without being overly chatty, and the crimes they cover are really interesting and the hosts find new details to share.

They literally validate murder and have no problem saying so..

Reagan is the podcasts favorite president… 🧐 whaaaa? The asides are sometimes 🤪

A good Podcast.. however it’s a tad annoying hearing the “white privilege” narrative in several episodes.. let’s do better ladies.

Twats

They screw around A lot and talk gibberish. I like to hear about the crime without a lot of jokes and side talk.

Love this podcast ❤️

I really do love the stories and the way you tell them but the way you bash law enforcement and push a political agenda that might not be everyone's bothers me! It's a podcast and everyone should be able to listen and not feel attacked bc of there morals or career choice which most ppl do go into first responder jobs bc they want to serve the public in a positive way! Please stick to the stories and leave the politics out im begging you! A lot of us come to podcasts to just relax not have more of this junk pushed on us! Other then that it's a great podcast I've recommend it more then once!

Contacted a few sponsors to let them know they’re sponsoring a bigoted podcast. Just woke and hateful people. Pass on this trash.

Thank you for telling stories that need to be told, that so often we don’t hear.

Second person is annoying….interrupts the flow of the stories, opinions on what happened or state of mind of perpetrator not helpful to story and so called experience questionable. Silliness at the end of each episode is super annoying….reminiscent of 13 year olds! Please, please quit taping the stupid nonsense at the end of the episodes! Painful to listen to…shrill, ear shattering, just plan stupid!

I'm so disappointed that it took me so long to listen but so glad that I finally have😊

This podcast is great! I love the chemistry between hosts, and the out-takes let me know you’re my people, lol. Thank you for covering cases and social injustices that aren’t all over the media. The hosts do great research and touch on a wide range of subjects. I look forward to listening every week.

I absolutely love this podcast. Don’t listen to the haters- you all are doing amazing! Don’t change a thing. I know a lot of murder podcasts struggle with how to end the show. The bloopers are by far the best palate cleanser ever. They have me belly laughing nearly every time! Love the podcast and love you three!

I just started listening and I already like this podcast! I like their integrity Re: show content and their honesty with their audience as they mature into a spectacular podcast!

Josh is alright! I just found the podcast recently when searching for someone with updates to the recent serial killings in the greater Portland area. I’ve caught up on a lot of episodes and am waiting for Josh’s Wet Dynamite podcast 😂 I’m not super into the bloopers at the end, but that’s not their problem. The team seems to put a lot into what they do, and I appreciate the way they tell the stories. Even Josh! And I don’t typically love listening to men on a podcast… Thank you!!

This was more like listening to someone speed through reading a report in front of the class than a podcast. If you are just going to read a manuscript - SLOW it down and maybe look up from the page now and then to make some attempt to connect with the audience. We cant see the podcaster so even more reason for them not to sound like an AUTOMATON. MITR was actually fascinating but was very hard to follow because it was not at all engaging. I'd like to see the print version or listen to someone tell the stories who has done the work and wasnt 100 percet reliant on merely rambling off what was written in front of them.

Stop the disgusting blooper ending to the podcast. It certainly gives the reader a different view of your intelligence.

Just read some because I couldn’t understand your overall low rating. People are so sensitive. Perhaps you should offer a tutorial on how to use the FF button?? 😆Keep on keepin on.

I enjoy the way the stories are told, clear, concise and the added commentary is a nice touch. The bloopers are so funny, I feel like I’ve known them forever which sounds weird when I think about it but here we are. Love these cool cats!! Awesome podcast!

The latest episode “Giving up is too boring” just bothered me. The entitlement to think that Marriott should respond to some podcast host just because she emailed is ridiculous. It makes the issue about them instead of about the victim’s mother. If you really cared, you would be more upset about them not reaching out to the mother instead of not responding to your email. It’s got weird white knight vibes to it.

Another true crime podcast that can’t keep politics out of it. Early episodes were good and then it slowly but surely crossed the line into shoving politics and personal beliefs down your throat.

I love the focus on PNW based crime! This podcast feels like you’re sitting down with your best friends. Alisha and Emily are not afraid to share their thoughts and are passionate about their cases. I’m a long-time Patreon supporter and definitely recommend!

I love the stories told by Emily and Alisha. They both make you feel like they are talking to you. I just can’t get into the stories told by Josh. He sounds like he is reading from a script, with many awkward pauses. My mind wanders. I end up not finishing the episode. I tried really hard this week and finally realized what one of the issues is. The sentences in his stories are too long, with many clauses, and that causes the monotone voice and awkward pauses. I think if he would break down his sentences into shorter sentences, the story would flow better and sound more like everyday speech. And be more interesting to listen to. Josh is quite animated when talking to Emily and Alisha. His personality, however, does not come through in his story telling.

I love Oregon and Portland and I think this podcast is pretty good. But months after hearing the comment about not reporting a drunk driver I am still bothered by this comment. I have even been charged with a dui 8 years ago and I cringe at the thought that I risked other peoples lives with my carelessness. I am of mixed race as well. No hard feelings to the hosts but I strongly disagree with that decision. What if you didn’t resort them and they went on to drive intoxicated and killed someone’s? Or a whole family? Or a child? Those lives are more important than the hypothetical repercussions you imagine.

I once loved this podcast, but they are no longer a true crime podcast. Too much anti religion and political agenda. I had hoped it was a one off and tried to skip those episodes, but it is every show. I have decided to unfollow. The early shows are pretty good though!

This podcast is such a delight. The three work together so well and have good chemistry. They tell these stories with compassion and care while balancing humor. So if you’re a dirtbag like me, strap in and start from the beginning.

I have listened to this podcast for years, and appreciated the research done to bring PNW stories to light. I have not always agreed with the hosts perspectives, (and always shut it off when it gets to the mostly unfunny and obnoxious bloopers,) but feel an adult should listen to other viewpoints and respect the rights of others to bring their own opinions to the table. One thing I do appreciate is tolerance, which the hosts of this show say they hold as a value. Sometimes they would have some leakage, and their biases would peek through, but the show I just listened to was over the top intolerant. It is okay to not be a religious person, but very hypocritical to go on a hate filled rant about how wrong ANY religion is. For this reason, I am unsubscribing, as I am sure a few others are, and will never again recommend this podcast to friends.

I really enjoy the podcast. I started from the beginning and working my way forward. Details in some episodes are a bit hard to take, but overall, I enjoy it. Skimming through reviews, I found most of the 1 stars entertaining, especially those offended by “wokeness”, which is basically just being a decent human being.

I was really enjoying your podcast until yesterday when you went on a rant about organized religion and basically religion as a whole. You are an entertainer, so you would think you would be smarter than to be that condescending and rude about something that so many people hold dear. I am all about everyone's right to believe what they want but you were more than opinionated. You were rude and ignorant and downright hateful. You said you wouldn't say those things to a friend's face and yet you spouted endless vitriol on this podcast which is listened to by so many. Hopefully after yesterday it will be less. There are way too many choices for podcasts to have to listen to someone who doesn't know how to be kind about others' beliefs while claiming that those beliefs are why the world is unkind. I think a lack of consideration is why the world is unkind and you just proved that. So I will be moving along.

So disappointed, I loved your podcast until this one. Please cover cases where good, honest officers are murdered as well. There are bad apples in every single category of humans, including officers. These stories put targets on more honest officers’ backs.

This is a fantastic podcast. Well written, researched, they actually interview ppl, high production quality. i could go on and on but all I’ll say is try it…i think you’ll follow. p.s. found this by total chance. I’m a native PNW’er living in the Northeast and so I was just looking for podcasts based on home when I found this. I’m really glad that I did despite the extremely sad cases and different accounts.

I really enjoy this podcast and the bloopers are quite amusing. I appreciate the perspective of someone who had worked with troubled kids and really appreciate that there are no political opinions. I have no idea how they stand on political issues and that is refreshing

I really like this podcast except the 5 minutes of blooper real at the end. Super obnoxious for it to be that long.

Blbllllbllbllb blooper reel 🤌🏼

Thanks for talking about true history! We here about making America great again. Oh please! Make it better and learn from our past. Eugene Oregon

Why the high school chit chat??? Ugh