Send us Fan Mail Amy’s neighbor demanded $1,600 for a fence he built before she moved in. When she refused to pay, he sent a sheriff to serve her with small-claims papers. Amy and Zach revisit the unbelievable lawsuit, debate whether $30,000 in student debt should worry a future mother-in-law, and answer a listener who wants to know where Zach really fits within the family. Amy also shares the creepy text she received after a Hinge date at the rodeo, while Zach reveals how a hitchhiking ride ...
Aug 9
1 hr 22 min
Send us Fan Mail Amy returns from Dallas with a fake Southern accent and a plan to use it on her next date. She and Zach break down an awkward YSA encounter, their failed attempt to buy lottery tickets, and the argument that followed over what each would do with $600 million. They also discuss the Lindsay Clancy case and the difficult questions surrounding postpartum mental health, psychosis, medical treatment, and accountability. Later, Amy explains Alix Earle’s unconventional family dynamic...
Aug 2
1 hr 9 min
Send us Fan Mail Amy finally bought her horse—and apparently that was only the beginning of the spending. This week, Amy joins Zach in Dallas to talk about her new life as a horse girl, the enormous pile of supplies she bought before even bringing Doc home, and their plan to record an entire podcast episode while riding horses. They also get into Zach and Megan’s experience interviewing for The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, the strange tactics reality TV producers use to create drama, and why...
Jul 26
1 hr 3 min
Send us Fan Mail This video is about EP28 CUTAmy has officially crossed into full horse-girl territory… This week the conversation goes everywhere—in the best way. Amy reveals why she may be leasing a second horse, Zach exposes just how spoiled they both were growing up, they debate dream lives, confess the worst ways they cheated in school, laugh through awkward family dynamics, and react to another unbelievable Relative From Hell story. It’s one of the funniest, most natural episodes yet.
Jul 19
1 hr 35 min
Send us Fan Mail A husband thinks he’s getting his family back. Instead, he walks into one of the most unbelievable family stories we’ve ever discussed. This week, Amy and Zach introduce a new Relative From Hell segment before diving into a shocking real-life case involving a marriage on the brink, a mother-in-law, a brother-in-law, and a plan that ended with multiple family members behind bars. Plus, we catch up on everything from World Cup obsession and dating preferences to the kind of con...
Jul 12
1 hr 20 min
Send us Fan Mail Amy's out this week, which means it's just Zach and Megan, and the bickering is immediate. Zach opens up about his new job and the weird loneliness of watching your family have fun without you from a hotel room. Megan recaps the Telluride trip in a 15 passenger van (hairpin turns, fire smoke, one smashed finger), and then we get into it: did we hide our crazy during our 63 day engagement, why big reactions drive Zach insane, our screen time and clean eating philosophies, back...
Jul 5
1 hr 25 min
Send us Fan Mail Amy confesses to 10.5 hours of screen time a day, Zach is fighting his migraines with red light and cutting Diet Coke, and there's a guy from Texas trying to outbid her on a horse she found on Facebook Marketplace. Then it's go time: this is our giveaway episode, so we announce the sweatshirt winners and put NINE of your Judge & Jury dilemmas in front of the jury. On the docket this week: a mother-in-law who set up a sneaky playdate, in-laws lining up to book the lake hou...
Jun 28
1 hr 34 min
Send us Fan Mail This week, nobody is safe. Amy updates us on dating, Zach has way too many opinions, Emily somehow proves she can’t be trusted around a grill, and Judge & Jury returns with family drama that has us completely divided. In this episode: ⚖️ The DM that got left on read ⚖️ Dating rules we don’t agree on ⚖️ Why Emily should never be in charge of dinner⚖️ Amy’s latest horse obsession ⚖️ Family situations that deserve a verdict ⚖️ Relationship takes that might start an arg...
Jun 21
1 hr 57 min
Send us Fan Mail Court is in session for Episode 23, and this one has everything: Amy’s horse-girl era, barrel camp with 12-year-olds, Zach’s home renovation and septic drama, Yellowstone with kids, Taylor Swift debates, and one very important Instagram message request from 2021. Amy finds an old DM from a guy she now wants to go out with and sends a reply live on the podcast. Then we get into true crime rabbit holes, what’s chapping everyone’s ass, and two Judge & Jury write-ins involv...
Jun 14
1 hr 34 min
Send us Fan Mail Everyone has thoughts they're not supposed to say out loud. This week Amy and Zach discuss dating, intrusive thoughts, social situations, family dynamics, and the things we secretly judge people for. Some of these opinions probably should have stayed private, but that's never stopped us before.
Jun 7
1 hr 17 min
Load more