“LOL” I feel stupider for listening.

I am extremely disappointed and disgusted by what I have heard from this podcast. Each episode I listened to was not researched and left out CRUCIAL information. These girls left out the fact that a suspect had a solid alibi and instead made horrific and misleading implications and comments about them. They simultaneously showed overwhelming affection and encouraged listeners to do the same for another suspect??? While conveniently leaving out HORRIFYING details about this person. And I’m not just another listener, I’m very close to someone who is discussed in one of their episodes and it breaks my heart to see the disrespect shed on their name and trauma. DO NOT TRUST THESE GIRLS. Please show support for my loved one who has been horribly misrepresented by their lack of knowledge and research on this topic.

Claire and Randy are great story tellers and bring such an interesting perspective to true crime and the criminal justice system. Any true crime junkie will love this podcast

Was interested in the Dozier Boys School story, and they are capable of making even the simplest sentences sound ignorant. At least know how the name is pronounced before just babbling on and cackling like a child.

Singularly the most obnoxious thing I've ever listened to. They are ignorant and have done next to no real research on anything they babble on about. Perhaps this is funny and entertaining if you're a 12 y/o girl, and hey, if you get murdered they might make an episode about it and giggle for 30 minutes while mindlessly rambling a few lines from an online article.

These girls are so annoying. They talk like idiots. Think a mix of valley girl and kardashian. Ugh.

I feel like I’m listening to two 13 year girls giggling throughout the murder stories that aren’t funny. I just can’t.

The hosts are basically reading you news stories and clearly haven’t done any in depth research into the cases they discuss. It also feels really poorly produced, they are constantly going on tangents about their own lives and their plans for the day. Choose a different podcast

This true crime podcast won’t disappoint! The content is well researched and full of details of each case but also full of funny comments. I love listening to them!

These ladies are absolutely hilarious! They’re so upbeat and funny while talking about serial killers. They’re so informative and I love listening to the cases they pick! Their delivery is unbeatable and I can’t wait for more!

These ladies are funny & knowledgeable. It is a delight to listen to them.

I feel the podcasters are funny, upbeat and personable. My first episode I listened to was the Selena episode. Although generally I thought it was good, there were many inconsistencies in the story told. For example, 60,000 people attended the funeral not 600 and Selena did in fact consider Yolanda her best friend. They even had a term of endearment for each other (along with Suzette, Selena’s sister) which was “Buffy”. Also, the boutiques opened in 1993 not 1995. Sorry, I’ve been a HUGE Selena fan for over 20 plus years so I’m just wanting to clarify a few things;) Keep up the good work ladies!

I’m the type of person who needs to watch “happy” shows before bed if I’ve watched something even slightly scary. I’m not going to lie, after my first episode of this podcast I clutched my pepper spray on my walk home and checked around every corner. Maybe that’s the point? I do think I will be safer, as Randi and Claire constantly warn us not to make stupid mistakes that could lead to murder. Now I’m flying through half a season at a time. Somehow these women make the ugliest side of society into something I enjoy listening to (even before bed without my happy shows).

Love this podcast and these ladies so much!

Very interesting. Especially like the added historical information in the Darya Case. Both case in season 2 are very well told in an interesting way that keeps you listening until the end. If you like true crime stories, you should give this a listen!!

I love this new podcast! The murders they share are interesting, and they’re thorough in their stories. And I love the way they banter throughout the podcast. Good job ladies!

I love this podcast! I feel like I’m sitting in their living room drinking coffee and listening to them tell me fascinating facts about the most interesting murders!