A well spoken podcaster, rare. I did just hear an episode in which she finished too many sentences with”right”. Please do not finish thoughts or sentences with “right”.

But honestly, I’ve seen many times over my many years of actual telephones in people’s bathrooms. I’ve even seen them in model homes. Not the first time I’ve observed your youthful lack of experience when dismissing a situation. However carry on and I’ll continue to listen. 😊

I’m SOOOO GLAD YOU GUYS ARE BACK!!!! ☺️☺️☺️☺️ I love everything about this podcast. It’s well researched and informative. From the engaging, intelligent hosts and their straightforward storytelling that are based on facts , to the lesser known cases they present in a respectful, thoughtful, compassionate and informative manner. There’s no silly banter or narcissistic droning on about their personal lives- they have great chemistry, display genuine empathy for the victims, while tastefully adding an element of intrigue that holds my attention. Sam and Sean are articulate, their delivery is excellent and their voices are very pleasant to listen to. Podcast perfection imho! On par with LSA, Going West, Every Small Town Has a Dark Side, Trace Evidence, and Murder, She Told. Keep up the fantastic work! P.s more Disappearances please! ;)

I look forward to new episodes, this is an easy listen with good research. Please come back soon!

Well researched, no side conversations, respectful and empathetic. Love this podcast. Also, I love your tone, Sam:)

I was enjoying this podcast over the last year, however I have noticed Sam’s tone toward her husband is changing as the podcast evolves. Sam is borderline impatient and condescending now when her husband asks questions pertaining to the case. Time to check you tone Sam or risk losing listeners.

This is a well executed podcast. From the soothing voice/s to the informative well put together cases. Should be one of the top rated in podcast land.

This podcast deserves to be more popular! It’s well researched and has thoughtful analysis of cases. It also covers lesser known, very interesting cases.

👆🏻Two of my favorite things. A podcast where the hosts have done their homework and it's presented conversationally. I also appreciate that they don't cuss, they don't make light very serious situations...they're respectful. And since I love the storytelling format, I like that they give background on more than just the crime, but of the people involved.

Really enjoy this podcast. I love the way they speak to each other with calmness, respect, and kindness.

I look forward to new episodes and love the new thumbnail, I sort of see a face. Thanks for your hard work.

I found this podcast looking for more information on a local case, Loy Evitts. I really like the delivery and voices of the hosts. They treat the cases, law enforcement, victims, and their families with kindness and respect. The explanations provided are thoughtful and the stories of the cases are easy to follow. There seems to be a trend in true crime mysteries towards too much editorializing and bashing of police, suspects and even victims. This podcast tells a solid story without the need for extra melodrama.

Great content with a voice you can listen to with ease. Not at all judgemental or disagreeing with her cohost. A welcome new Podcast to my play list.

I love this podcast. I love the new artwork. I have binged all the past episodes and now have to wait each week for a new episode to come out

I am CONSTANTLY on the lookout for a good true crime podcast-- Casefile is my go-to but I've struggled to find others I think are reliably good. I don't need a lot of filler, I prefer just a straightforward, well-researched delivery. This has become my other weekly listen. It's well researched, the hosts are pleasant, and it does a great job of featuring lesser-known cases which I very much appreciate. Sam has even done an episode on a case I suggested via email, which is so cool! This is a TC podcast for true TC devotees.

Well researched, kind, intelligent, and respectful. Thank you

Me like!

High quality with intelligent hosts. I appreciate the correct grammar and word usage! This show is also well researched. I look forward to each new episode.

Wow, this podcast gets me on the edge my seat weekly, I’ve listened since episode one and find Sam’s voice just easy to listen to and dreamy. Sean does a nice job of presenting good opinions and ideas to the best of his ability, he sounds like a nice guy that wears stylish and tight clothes. Sam keeps me coming back every week for more of her true crime savvy.

The hosts do a good job researching, and I like their style and the variety of cases. Look forward to listening weekly.

Love this podcast, it’s on my must listen listen. It makes my Sunday! Thanks!

I LOVE THIS SHOW!! So many new cases compared to most other true crime shows

I love this show! The hosts are lovely and most of the cases are new to me. I look forward to listening each week!

I really want to like this podcast, and I keep listening because the hosts are fairly new, hoping it will get better over time. The hosts have good presentation voices and you can tell they care about the cases. What I don’t care for is the great amount of speculation about the cases. There is often information they “don’t know”, yet they don’t seem to do the extra step to try to determine missing information. They don’t talk to the families or law enforcement, and seem to rely strictly on information available to the public. Attempts to conduct interviews to obtain the “missing” information would go a long way of increasing the quality of this podcast.

This and Small Town Murder are by far my favorite podcast! Not a lot of small talk, and a lot of cases that aren’t as well known which I really love. Seems like most shows do the same cases and don’t want to research anything new! Great podcast!!

Thanks for covering Officer Jeffrey Mitchell’s case out of Sacramento where I Live. I remember when this happened and still hope for his family to get Justice.

Generic true crime podcast. Woman presents. Guy interrupts and destroys the flow of the podcast. The presentation is clunky and tough to listen to.

Just found you. Very good episodes. The hosts have very nice and pleasant voices. Most important to me.. no nonsense, no giggling, no small talk. This podcast is a keeper! Thank you! 👍

I recently found this podcast and am really enjoying it so far! The hosts present the case information and details very clearly and it’s organized well. I like that there is no banter that is distracting too much from the story, and it’s easy to follow. Looking forward to future episodes and am glad I found it.

Boring presentation! Interesting case but such a bland presentation I couldn’t listen to the whole thing!

One of the few pods I’ve seen that covered Scotty Ratigan’s case. Let’s catch the bastard who did this!

I've been binging this podcast since I first heard about it. I love their discussions - it's a high quality podcast. It reminds me of Anatomy of Murder. I can’t wait for more!

I heard about this podcast from Last Seen Alive and had to check it out. I love what Sam and Sean are doing with addressing unsolved cases. The sound quality is also surprisingly great for a newer podcast. More people need to hear about these cases they’re discussing!

Such an entertaining podcast covering so many cases I’ve never heard of! Sam really does her research and I can’t wait to see this podcast continue to grow! Also, I love the sexy man in this pod! His voice is sooooooo soothing. 🥰 Sam is a lucky girl!

This duo does such a great job at bringing awareness to cases and victims while keeping the listener engaged and interested. I can’t wait for more!!

I do not like her reporting style: I’m sorry.

For all the true crime lovers, this is a great new podcast to listen to! Easy to follow case stories, while also learning all the facts. I love how they cover non-popularized cases to shed light on victim stories who may have not been covered in the media. Can’t wait to listen more!

I love that they focus on unsolved cases that could lead to more awareness and the possibility of them being solved.