This week, the girls discuss the disturbing stalking and subsequent disappearance of Cynthia Jane Anderson, and the strange incident involving a “toxic woman” which could be explained by anything from mass hysteria to alien abduction. It’s very fuzzy this week, ya’ll.

Gear up, ya'll. Episode 17 is here and things get a little wild. This week Alexandra gives us a bonus April Fools' story about a woman with the world's most gullible family. After that, Ariana dives into the gruesome murder of the Elvis-obsessed Grimes' sisters, and Alexandra gives us a story full of porn, runaways, and a sketchy sex advice line - the disappearance of Laureen Rahn. So, stay away from Elvis look-a-likes, avoid wave pools, and settle in for episode 17!

We’re baaack! Ariana has her voice back and is ready to use it to talk about mayhem. This week, Alexandra discusses the strange Circleville Letters and Ariana tells us about the eerie disappearance of Brianna Maitland. So, check your spelling, forget about the loose change, and tune in for episode 16!

This week, Ariana discusses the Smiley-Face Killer, a theory started by two retired NYC detectives that may not be as far-fetched as people think. After that, Alexandra tackles her first serial killer: the Freeway Phantom, a sadistic killer who may have gotten away with his crimes thanks to - you guessed it - racism. So, beware of graffiti smiley faces, get rid of your shag carpets, and settle in for episode 15!

This week the girls delve into the mysterious death of Charles C. Morgan, and the brutal slayings of three men on LaSalle Street in Indianapolis. So queue up your microfiche, make sure not to swallow, and buckle up for episode 14!

Episode 13 is here! This week, Ariana talks about the Texarkana Moonlight Murders and a suspect whose letter writing skills were spot on. After that, Alexandra tells us about the murder of Betsy Aardsma in Penn State’s Pattee Library. Also featured: our very first ghost story!

This week, the girls lose their minds a little bit as they discuss two insane cases. Alexandra tells the Natalee Holloway story, a case that just gets more and more convoluted as time goes on. After that, Ariana discusses the unsolved murder of Blair Adams, a man who may or may not have been chased almost three thousand miles from his home only to be heinously murdered. 

Episode 11 has arrived! This week, things get a little dark as the girls discuss the disturbing Hinterkaifeck murders and the tragic disappearances of the Beaumont Children. So fine tune your bad Australian accents, avoid any mattocks you may come in contact with, and buckle up for episode 11!

Episode 10 is here and it's a momentous occasion! This week Alexandra tells us about Finland's most famous unsolved homicide: the Lake Bodom murders. Then, Ariana digs into the deaths of Dutch students Lisanne Froon and Kris Kremers. Get rid of your camping gear - you don't need it, tend to your rice paddy, and buckle up for episode 10!

Beam us up, Scotty. This week Ariana and Alexandra discuss some truly bizarre characters. From the theft of a single bandaid to the drug-addled ravings of an obsessed man to a wine bottle with a mind of its own, there’s a lot of strange activity going on here. Ariana covers alleged serial killer and dead fish, Robert Durst. After that, Alexandra channels her inner Fox Mulder while telling the story of Granger Taylor who was definitely abducted by aliens. Trust us on this one, we’re experts.