Honestly, this was the first podcast I’d ever listened to and it got me through the early parts of the pandemic. I’m deeply saddened that Matt and Nicole have not returned for a season 3. I cannot for the life of me find a more endearing and funny podcast.

This podcast is the best one I listen to. I have so much trouble finding something near as good to listen to between seasons. I love that Nicole thinks only like 5 people listen to the podcast even though it’s actually one of the top rated podcast on Apple podcast. I also enjoy listening to Nicole’s journey of finding a guest that is on Goodreads. I can’t wait for season 3.

The premise of this show is genius, Matt and Nicole are hilarious, the guests’ willingness to humiliate themselves is truly inspired. I look forward to it every Tuesday and was so thrilled when s2 came out! #SnickersBarMystery will haunt me till I die. Can’t wait for season 3.

Hilarious podcast. I wish they would have more of their friends on though.

Matt and Nicole are a great pair of hosts with lovely chemistry. And maybe this is weird to say, but I love their voices. Not only do their voices soothe my ears, but they're also super funny and ridiculously witty. The emails they come up with on Email Roulette always tickle me. They're hilarious and absurd in the best way possible. I feared for awhile that they wouldn't be continuing the podcast after season 1 concluded. But alas, they are back with a new season and I'm so delighted! Thank you guys so much for what you do

Love the hosts dynamic and book wonderful guests. I feel like some podcasts live or die by having a constant stream of high profile guests. But every guest (even the ones I am not familiar with) are game, interesting, and lead me to look into their work after listening. Very happy for a second season and hopefully another in the future!

This is maybe my favorite podcast? Certainly the one with my favorite tag line and the most recent episode with Jo was such a delight!

For sure my favorite podcast (and I hear there’s actually a lot of them out there, so that’s saying something). I find myself genuinely laughing out loud, and Matt and Nicole are an incredibly hilarious combination (and hilarious separately). Hope there are many seasons to come!

This show is a great time!

I can't imagine how stressed i'd be if I were a guest on this podcast, but I love listening to it.

I absolutely love listening to this podcast - i look forward to it coming out every week. Prying into people's inboxes is the dream

I’m listening to the most recent podcast today. I have to laugh cause I picked up “bud” from Nicole. Great show, I look forward to Tuesdays to listen to Matt and Nicole.

This unique podcast brings us lots of laughs, insights into human nature, and all-around joy. Very special!

Okay so yeah three tries is maybe two much for four answers, however, my view of this is that the person creating the question has this in mind, and thus finds questions with such a crazy or medium-crazy answer that it will always be the fourth choice. So I think whatever works.

I can stop listening

The show is perfectly balanced between being VERY funny and also giving fascinating glimpses into guests lives. I love!

Really funny ep... this, so far, is your funniest episode! Thanks for the laugh!

Matt and Nicole have great chemistry, you can tell they've known each other for ages! I LOVE RISK! so when I saw Kevin Allison on here I listened and now I'm hooked!

Yes! I love story telling podcasts and this is a new twist on that. LOVE IT!

I really wanted to like this podcast -- I really did, I stayed for 14 episodes. The episode with Jackie, where I was forced to listen to several minutes of unsubscribing from an email list, was my last straw. Too often the hosts get distracted by minutia and barely execute the goal of the segments. The segments are mostly uninteresting. The tantalizing line they give to describe the podcast falls flat when eveyrone acts way too guarded about their mission. There is too much personal relationship banter between the hosts and guests where it is made clear that the hosts are really only reaching out to a friend circle. These conversations are completely alienating to a listener who knows nothing about the guests. This podcast would be much more interesting if it ventured outside of email more, as it really is a dying mode of communication. The IDEA of this show is amazing -- the execution is probably the worst it could possibly be.

This podcast is very funny and I often have to rewind because I'm laughing too loud! I do fast forward through writing the email in the beginning but like hearing the final product at the end of the cast. Thank you for introducing me to Beep Beep cereal and a new Halloween costume: wolf going to the park.

This is definitely a fun listen. Though it is definitely guest-dependent... listening to Elisa Kreisinger was the wrong kind of cringe, too much faux self-righteous feminism from her end. Also, it always seems like Matt is on the struggle bus keeping up with Nicole and her colleagues— but that is actually an endearing dynamic. I mostly can’t believe that no one thought of this concept before... pretty much exactly what I’d expect from gimlet 🤪

I love Kevin I thought his episode would be good but ooooohhhh my god this was so disorganized and rambling. I’ll try to be constructive instead of rude. It needs organization, planning, and editing. The most vulgar exciting person you could have interviews and I feel you really missed the opportunity to create a wild episode that would make you standout. You could take cues from Ted Radio Risk etc and do short intros to the subject to explain a specific story or message etc then go off on it instead of rambling and talking about your personal relationships of the hosts to each other sooo often. It’s okay to be quirky and personal but make sure you have the powerful content to back it up. Maybe this was just me, and maybe just listening to an episode of Risk before was harsh contrast. I’ll try another episode but I could barely sit through this.

Hit me straight!

Found Inbox on my podcast app and it's officially my favorite! I love the humor and dynamics of the show..and Email Roulette?! #NoWords I am giddy at 4 am on Tuesdays becuase I know there's a new episode to listen to as I run (jog...ok, walk) at the gym. Love love love this show!

I actually look forward to Tuesday. I love you guys

"

Like being stuck in a bus full of high school kids.

I like this podcast! The female host strikes me as a modern day Jane Austen. I think the way they do ads is pretty clever.

Great even

this is so so so so funny!

Two episodes in and I'm hooked. This is so great.

These two are really onto something funny. The dumb messages I send to my friends would be enough for a 3 part series and let's not even get into the emails I send to my parents that sound like I'm a crazy person!

This podcast proves why I never let my mates go through my phone, because they would definitely embarrass the hell out of me for the corny texts I send to my lady.

I wish they could get some politicians in this show, that would be an amazing episode to go through their inboxes! Such a fun listen. I'm in love with the hosts, their banter is great and I love how the guests are in on the joke.

no need to look any further, this show will be your new podcast obsession

This show had me laughing the whole time. I love the idea lof going through someone else's emails and the guests and hosts were really funny.

Need more proof that your messages are embarrassing AF? This show takes a look at how obsessed we are with our digital lives and makes it funny AF. I can only imagine sinking deeper and deeper into my chair as these hosts read my cringe-worthy texts. Ugh, this is my new favorite podcast, hands down!

these two are geniuses and thank you for making my new obsession if you love to feel awkward and love second-hand embarrassment this is the perfect laugh out loud, cringe-worthy podcast out there

For all that is good in this world, YOU MUST listen to this podcast. I was clutching my phone making sure no one on the subway could see what I was writing because I felt like I was in the studio with them.

This show is killing me. Every second is funnier than the last. I think I have a crush on Nicole and Matt. <3<3<3 xoxoxoxo

seriously though, Nicole and Matt can we become best friends? You guys are hilarious and I couldn’t imagine keeping a straight face while hanging out with you guys. I'll just stand here with my hand raised just in case. you're looking for a guest to come on the show!

Sorry, James, but I can and will continue to order sushi at all hours of the night and wee hours of the morning. HA! What a great concept, why hasn't anyone thought to do this before?! The notes section on my phone is filled with insane ideas. How do I submit to be on this show?

trust me, this show is one of the best I've heard in a while. It's a great concept and perfect for anyone who's ever sent a text accidentally after pouring their heart out to their crush with no intention of actually hitting send...not that I know anything about that...

I'm absolutely in love with this show. I keep listening to the first 2 episodes on repeat. I NEED MORE!!!!!

This show is going to be a huge hit. This is like every millennials fear, that someone would get access to their messages and see how embarrassing they are and share it with the world! This show is hilarious and of course it's all in good fun!

I love, love, love this idea. More please!

If you need a light-hearted show to listen to on your way between places you should consider subscribing to this show. The hosts are funny and I'm really enjoying the guests they've brought in so far. Feels like a new take on some of the storytelling podcasts that are popular like RISK! and The Moth.

A new take on the interview podcast that I am obsessed with. I'd be so embarrassesd if they read my chats on the show, but I bet they would make even the most mundane ones hilarious.

I'd love to be on this show, it's so much fun! I've defeintely sent my fair share of half-baked emails and we could do a special epsiode all about the disgusting food I've ordered - ahem - 5:30 in the morning.